Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
For over 86 years, spanning three generations, Eddie’s has offered up great food, warm hospitality, and happy memories to thousands of beachgoers. From its humble beginnings as a seasonal hot dog stand, to the bustling restaurant it is today, Eddie’s has always provided quick and friendly service, delicious homemade food, and an unforgettable experience.
Enduring, family-run eatery for breakfast & sandwiches, plus hearty Italian & American dinners.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 901 Main St, Sylvan Beach, NY 13157
Phone: (315) 762-5430
Website: http://eddies1934.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Eddie’s Restaurant: Sylvan Beach’s Family Restaurant
Join us on Oneida Lake in Sylvan Beach, NY to enjoy delicious food and a tradition of family hospitality dating back to 1934.
Home | Harpoon Eddie’s, Sylvan Beach
Join us on Oneida Lake in Sylvan Beach, NY for the best food, drinks, entertainment, and views in all of Central New York.
Eddie’s Restaurant | Sylvan Beach NY – Facebook
Eddie’s Restaurant, Sylvan Beach. 7579 likes · 2699 talking about this · 10656 were here. It’s Famous…It’s Fabulous…It’s Eddies! Eddies is now…
Reviews
Patti Clark
AMAZING!! Friendly, fun, and very tasty food…… Until I got to the homemade pie!! WOW!! Banana Cream Pie was AMAZING!!!
Bethany was very tentative and helpful. Her family was dining there as well across from us and were so much fun!! Tim, her dad mentioned that Mary, the pie baker was in the restaurant. 🙂 So I went bad and told her how amazing it was!!!
All around highly recommend to bring your family. My aunt and I split a grilled ham and cheese and then the hot roast beef sandwich with chips!! OUTSTANDING!! It was like I was sitting in my home……comfort food!! YUMMY!!
I’ll be back before I head back home to New Hampshire!!
… moreBethany was very tentative and helpful. Her family was dining there as well across from us and were so much fun!! Tim, her dad mentioned that Mary, the pie baker was in the restaurant. 🙂 So I went bad and told her how amazing it was!!!
All around highly recommend to bring your family. My aunt and I split a grilled ham and cheese and then the hot roast beef sandwich with chips!! OUTSTANDING!! It was like I was sitting in my home……comfort food!! YUMMY!!
I’ll be back before I head back home to New Hampshire!!
DW Rich
Great place to eat when visiting Sylvan Beach. It makes a good combination with wandering around the amusement park or listening to bands at the nearby bandstand. Also a great spot to then walk along the lake shore or along the beach that is nearby
… moreTina Lucarelli
Eddie’s Restaurant has been serving the community for over 86 years, and stepping inside feels like stepping back in time—in the best way. The fish sandwiches are pretty darn good, and the portions are generous, perfect for a satisfying meal. For me, this place is filled with nostalgia—I used to come here as a kid with my parents and siblings, and just walking in brings back that warm, classic summer feeling. If you love old-school diners with history, hearty comfort food, and a slice of Americana, Eddie’s is the place to be.
… moreSheena W
The nostalgia of this place for me is everything, I haven’t been in years since my family have moved away. Bur being in the area we had to come see how the food held up under the new management. I will say the antipasto was everything I remember it and fulfilled my craving for it. The fish sandwich was also cooked perfectly. Our server was friendly and personable and helpful. Everything was clean the quality was high. Will be back next time I’m in town.
… moreEllie
eddies is a great little place in sylvan beach! i’ve been coming here for years, and have never been disappointed. that being said, the food and service can vary from time to time – sometimes it’s good, and sometimes it’s below par. however, i would still recommend coming here!
… moreMatthew March
Amazing! The service was awesome. They were great with my fussy toddler! Got us an emergency side of fries to make him happy! The service was great but the food was even better. Reminds me of grandma’s meatballs and sausage. Will definitely be coming again! Highly recommend!
… moreThomas Tracy
Excellent service. The Manhattan Clam Chowder was loaded and very delicious. I got the Italian Sampler (manicotti, 1/2 eggplant parm, and 1/2 lasagna. Everything was homemade and the sauce was fantastic. My wife had the roast pork. It was some of the most flavourful roast pork I’ve had in years.
Great service, great food, and fair prices. Will definitely be back.
… moreGreat service, great food, and fair prices. Will definitely be back.
Joe L
Place is stuck in a time warp but overall not bad. It is overpriced for what you get. $18 fish fry. Service was good and friendly. 50 cents for a refill? 3.00 for the initial Coke? Cmon. The portions were also small along with processed deli ham on the grilled cheese.
… moreErica Slater
This was a nice place to end our beach day! When we got there it was a little bit of a wait but completely understandable as it was Labor Day and they we’re only one of a couple places still open for the season. Put while waiting you get to stand next to the dessert case full of delicious looking pies that we now couldn’t wait to try. This was our first time here and loved the family friendly dinner feel it had to it, plus the little pigs and family portraits made for many interesting things to look at. The staff was sure moving fast but even in their busy haist everyone was very friendly. There is a lot on the menu! You can get breakfast all day, plus lots of sandwiches, salads, starters, and a few pages of dinner items, then of course a huge list of pies, ice cream sundaes, and other items. It was definitely hard making a decision. For starters we got mozzarella sticks, zip zap shrimp, pickle fries, and meatballs with ricotta. They all taste good like your average restaurant starters, the zip zap shrimp was more like a buffalo shrimp, and the ricotta cheese that came in the meatballs was cold, I do wish they baked the cheese with the meatballs to warm everything but again everything was tasty. For dinner we got a cup of chicken pastina soup, the Ruben, fried clam strips, kids Mac and cheese, lemon dill salmon, and stuffed French toast with Nutella and strawberries (not pictured). Everything was delicious I wish my salmon had more lemon but still tasty, but I did not like the rice pilaf so I would recommend a different side. Everyone was sufficiently full. We couldn’t forget dessert and took several slices of pie home that we enjoyed the next day. They were so yummy I forgot to take pictures. In all it was a good dinner at a nice local family establishment, after a day on the beach for a family this would be a great place to dine. I will be back one day just to eat a sundae for sure.
… moreRichard Vence
Food was amazing! But the service was just okay.. we have a few kids and the looks we got from some of the servers made us feel uncomfortable. They almost seemed annoyed that we had kids. We spent over $200 and tipped well but left feeling like we inconvenienced them. The pasta dishes were great though!
… more