Eats N’ Treats Pizza, Ice Cream & More!

  4.2 – 760 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Indie spot for pizza, burgers, wings & ice cream with indoor-outdoor seating, drive-thru & delivery.

✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Eats N' Treats Pizza, Ice Cream & More! 44870

Menu Photos

eatsntreatssandusky.org

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Home | Eats N Treats Pizza, Ice Cream & More!

In 2007, Randy and Stephanie Neidler opened their family owned and operated restaurant, Eats N’ Treats. Randy, a 1984 graduate of Sandusky High School, and …

Eats N’ Treats | Sandusky OH – Facebook

Eats N’ Treats, Sandusky. 5356 likes · 109 talking about this · 1314 were here. Pizza, Ice Cream, and Much More! • Sandusky, OH • Est. 2007 •…

Eats N’ Treats (@eatsntreatssandusky) · Sandusky, OH – Instagram

787 followers · 742 posts · Pizza, Ice Cream, and Much More! • Sandusky, OH • Est. 2007 • Voted BEST Carry-Out Pizza in the Area.

Last Updates

Reviews

allea stefan
This place! My burger! The staff! Everything 5 stars. There is something about a good ol burger that just hits right. Thank you to the staff that was extremely friendly with my family. We are grateful! If you’re looking for a good family friendly atmosphere – look no further. Just come and thank me later
… more
Johnny Lusk
Wish the salad bar had been open when wee we were there, but the food was really good. Everybody loved what they ordered and we all shared our dishes and it was good. Service was good too. Really nice and patient with us when ordering. We had never been there and had a lot of questions. Only real complaint is no mayonnaise. Only miracle whip and that’s just gross. With all of the tourists surely it would pay to keep some even if it’s just packets.
… more
Big Bad
Great little diner to grab a quick bite, I would recommend this place of Business. Food was plentiful, and very good. Update came back for dinner, food was hot and very good, try the sauerkraut balls and potato skin pizza you won’t be disappointed!!
… more
Hayley Corso
We’ve ordered from Eats n Treats consistently for almost 5 years and we absolutely love it. In 5 years they’ve never once gotten our order wrong. They’re quick and efficient, all the delivery drivers are so nice. We love them
… more
Stephany
Decided to give this place a try after recommendations from a staff member at the hotel we stayed at. Never again. Terrible experience from teenage staff who treated us like we were bothering them to some of the food quality. For the price paid we expected better. Pickle spear came in a plastic package, opened it from the back side of package. Thank goodness I did. Expired 9/28. When brought to staff attention again we were treated as if we were bothering them, she rolled her eyes and said they all have expired dates so we don’t have any. Ordered a BLT asked if they had mayo, we were told yes. Food came out bread barely toasted and miracle whip packets in basket. Again asked staff for mayonnaise because we got wrong item. We don’t have mayo. Ordered potato skins which were not bad but charged for sour cream which typically would be part of the price at any restaurant. $36 for a small pizza, blt/fries and 5 potato skins we expected better. Staff needs some retraining on customer service.
… more
Dawn-Marie Bailey
We eat here regularly, but usually get delivery.
I ordered pick up and it was not a great experience. $85 worth of food. I had to wait for my order to be completed after the time I was told, which is fine. Left with all of the order except my calzone. All of the food I took with me was cold except the wings (which I assume I was waiting on. Fine), and went back to get the calzone. The calzone had clearly been made awhile ago, because it was ice cold when I got it home and smothered in ricotta. First bad experience there, honestly. I was going to go back a third time, but it seemed that everyone was a teen employee and it didn’t seem worth the third trip there. Now I will always order delivery. Never had any issues with that. I left them $100 for the bill and tip and it wasn’t worth it.
… more
Dj Sullivan
We ran through the drive-through to get something quick before a ball game. All in all, it took us maybe 10 minutes to get an order, which wasn’t bad.

The tater tots were nice and fresh. The burger not so much. They have a huge menu, so I think I would try eating here again
… more
Rachel Brock
Friendly staff and good service. Burger, Cheese Fries, onion rings, and pretzel sticks were all delicious. My son enjoyed his pizza as well. The flurries for dessert were also very good!
… more
Kat Getts
Ordered delivery. Shout out to whomever made our pizza pocket today!! Plenty of fillings, butter garlic crust was cooked perfect. The topping of Parmesan cheese made it perfect ♥️
… more
Ruth Palmer
Delicious food and ice cream at good prices, however the service was a little slow. We ordered inside and it seemed like drive thru orders got priority even though we ordered before them. However, we would definitely come back.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment