Shady Horton
I have always had a great experience with East of Chicago’s locations that I’ve visited. Thankfully, I enjoyed the delicious deep dish pizza instead of the sandwich being prepared in the pictures submitted.
… morebrenda jarrell
Staff at 4th Strret was very pleasant and most cordial. However, The newer “loaded crust” pizza should be advertised as it appears in the box! With approx. 2.5 inches of crust around the diameter, the actual pizza left in the middle is a bit larger than a personal pan pizza. At $19.99 WITH a coupon, this is hardly a good deal. The bottom was a bit dough-y, and even though the outside loaded crust is pretty good, the amount of pepperoni in the loaded crust is quite scarce.
Do NOT recommend. We Will not order this pizza again… sorry.
… moreHeather Crose
Deluxe pizza was delicious! Loved the Steak sub and the loaded fries were pretty good too! Enjoyed our dinner late today. Thank you!
… moreTravel Always
We ordered delivery tonight. They were down to one delivery driver. Our food was good, but a little cold. Understandably, there was a delay. The employees we spoke with were all very nice. I will update when I try again!
… moreAmanda Furlong
First time trying the taco pizza tonight ( Feb 27th ) and it was FABULOUS warm and just so good .. and the driver was on time per app ..and friendly 10/10 recommend.
… moreHeather Rhoades
We haven’t had East of Chicago in a bit. I was so excited when I saw there was now one right down the road from our business. Had my husband grab a taco pizza on his way home. Absolutely the best taco pizza we have had from anywhere. You’ll be seeing me at least once a week
… moreClint liersemann
Love the attention to detail with every pizza that has been prepared for me since the current owners have taken charge! Consistency is key and they have been on point every time with their pizza and costumer care!
… moreChris
I love the service great staff and the food is always on point and the guy that I picked my order up from I think his name is Robbie was respectful and kind and fixed any problem I had I highly recommend this place keep it up man
… moreJimmy Trine
When ordering I was told to bear with her cuz she’s new, so I t took a bit to complete the order. I asked if they could cut the pizza like others cut garlic bread pizza, and was told yes. When the pizza arrived, the topping were so spread out, only a few pieces had all the toppings, and enough cheese to choke a chicken. Asked for extra sausage and onions, with barely any of both on it, and the pizza was cut in triangles. When I called about it, it took some time for them to even find my order. While now speaking with manager, all I got was excuses, and when it came to the cutting of the pizza , I was told they only cut them per company standard of square or triangle. I was surprised he was anything but polite, and never once even apologized. It was actually the owner who I spoke with, and was the one to deliver the replacement pizza. When showing him the pizza, that already had the cheese pealed back to expose the lack of toppings. He told me that I kept his employee on the phone for 7 minutes when I ordered, an 11 minutes when I called back, and now, you waisted 5 more minutes, rifling through the pizza to show him what’s wrong with it. With more excuses, and still no apology, I still stuck my hand out to shake his hand, and left me hanging it out there for like 10 seconds, till I said, that is why I’m willing to shake your hand. He reach up, and shook my hand and squeezed with “WAY” more force than anyone ever shook my hand with, unless they were making a point to. I was so excited to be getting a new store in our area, but will never again order from there, or his Lexington store, which has similar reviews, regarding him personally.
… moreWally Wildin
Visiting Family friends here in Mansfield from Atlanta and this place was suggested. I made an order of 2 pizzas and they are delicious!! Definitely a go to if in the area
… more