Scuba Divemaster
So good! A solid destination for some big bactivities. Reminds me of European-run bakeries in Fort Lauderdale. Everything was so fresh delicious and high-quality. I got a baguette, and it was so wonderful to have good bread again. The cream puff was out of this world. Excellent bakery for Long Island, and very good service. Surprisingly affordable prices.
… moreSuha Sheikh
Been coming here for years even before the move to wall st. and I recently bought a sourdough loaf and found a hair baked into it. Huge turn off especially since it’s hard to find bakery style bread on Long Island. Have found it hard to come back here. Please do better to have everyone wear beard or hair masks.
… moreRay Fehringer
Delicious pastries and baked goods. Buttery, flaky exterior with a soft interior. Everyone in my home absolutely loved everything. It was all gone by the end of the day. My personal favorite is the morning bun—it was sensational.
Excellent service with great attention to detail.
This is hand down the best bakery on the island, and if anyone is thinking about trying this place, I highly recommend doing so.
… moreBill Spitalnick
If you haven’t been here, I would say you should go immediately. There’s something for everybody here. It’s probably the best bakery around without a doubt. The help is extremely friendly very fast very efficient. It’s absolutely lovely people and terrific baked goods. Something for everyone just go. While you’re there next-door is the great R&S butcher shop, Southdown coffee and excellent Sushi spot.
… moreDavid Wallman
One of the if not the best bakery I have been to! A couple of weeks ago my sister got the focaccia bread from here for a family party and it was some of the best I’ve ever had. Since then we have been to Duck Island several times. We typically get the bread for parties or as an appetizer and it goes immediately! We have also gotten their chocolate chip cookies and brownies, both of which I highly recommend. Well usually throw them in the oven for 3/4 min to heat them up a little. They have dozens of other delicious looking baked goods but we haven’t had a chance to try them out yet. Would highly recommend!
… moreElias
Been coming to this bakery for a year now, and will not be leaving for another one soon. I probably have tried all of their products here. My favorite by far is the breads. All of them are baked to perfection and is the perfect addition to any events or get together. Another product I really enjoy is their catering sandwiches. You can customize what type and size you need. We catered for an event with these sandwiches and it was a great hit. Their pastries of course are alwags a no-brainer to get. Some of my favorites when it comes to pastries are the blueberry muffin, pistachio croissant, bear claw and cheesecake. I highly recommend you visit this bakery, you will be hooked!
… moreMark Heyert
This is the best bakery in town. Selected favorites: cinnamon roll, sour dough bread, junior loaf, peach turnover, but the fact of the matter is the quality and taste is outstanding with all the products. Added bonus, staff is friendly and knowledgable!
… moreMichelle
I was a bit disappointed but think I just had bad luck. My friends rave about how this is the best bakery on the island. I tried the chocolate eclair and it tasted burnt on the pastry. It wasn’t overcooked underneath so likely they just put the chocolate on top. The actual custard was actually amazing and some of the best I’ve had. All the staff were super nice and the place looks so cool on the inside with their display cases and the open kitchen so you can see them working in the back. I would come here to try something different but I can say I was really impressed by the custard.
… moredom scarola
This bakery is a bit pricey. I went to get a loaf of Italian bread to have with my pasta and sauce. It took a while to get served and I was able to get one of the last loaves they had. I saw that they were selling pignoli cookies for $2.00 each, wow!
… moreKenneth Seff
So we have not tried many of the products there BUT THE ONES WE HAVE ARE AWESOME in particular the Chicken pot pie,not typical in a bakery but the best I’ve had. The sour dough semolina bread is fabulous , and the chocolate chip cookies are also the best I’ve ever had
Thanx Bob
We will try something new soon and write a review
… more