Zaza Nicolette
Have to say this was disappointing. We ordered a Supreme Pizza, once picked up we checked it in the car and realized this wasn’t what we fully ordered, there were ingredients missing.
Kindly walked in and mentioned this might not be our pizza, after checking he said it was, we then proceeded to look at the menu with ingredients.
In fact missing ingredients, he went in the back and said we are out of those ingredients.
Playing it off as if this is what we ordered isn’t honest, the pizza also looked NOTHING not even close to the photos in their Google Maps images.
The pizza was extremely thin and WAY OVER COOKED, as shown in the photos the bottom was burnt. Being world travelers we’ve had some INCREDIBLE PIZZA, even in the US. But this place has a lot to learn about culture, seasonings and how it all blends together. The dough had no flavor, we should have stuck to our guns and went with Atmosphere Pizza. Which so far truly is the only place in Sarasota that has won us over. Not a fan of leaving these types of reviews but from beginning to end our experience for a $27 pizza was just not it
… moreOneshia Green
I really wanted to like this place, but unfortunately it was a big miss. I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza, wings, and pasta. The pizza and wings were basically inedible, the pizza was drowned in hot sauce to the point where it was overwhelming, and the crust was extremely soggy. The wings had an odd taste, were breaded, and just as soggy. Both ended up in the trash. Thankfully, the pasta was at least edible. Overall, 2/10. Wouldn’t recommend.
… moreJeanne Bernt
Did take out – process easy and ready when told it would be. Got one regular crust and one cauliflower and both were really really good! Meat lovers and pepperoni – both great amount of toppings and crust was crispy and nicely browned. Staff immediately came over to help us even though bar was full and tables too. Cute little place will definitely eat in next time!
… moreMike Richard
Tried Dough Boy Swift for the first time tonight. (Clark + swift) We got the meat lovers and the Frank White. Pizza was very good. The crust was crisp, light, and flavorful. I preferred the meat lovers but when you added the table side hot honey to the white pizza it was incredible! We’ll definitely go back and try other varieties.
… moreSandy Woods
Best pizza in town. Still good even the next day.
Ordered delivery via Uber Eats. Pizza is excellent especially if you like a little doughier NY style. Wings have a great crunch. I wish the garlic parm had more flavor but maybe everyone isn’t trying to kill off vampires like me. Mozzarella sticks were excellent with a great crust flavor and crunch. Overall very very happy to have this pizza in the area finally!!! We have been starving for something better than what we have had.
Second time ordering was amazing as well. We tried the Korean bbq wings, hot wings, truffle fries, da meats pizza, and the Deebo chicken sandwich. Loved it all! Best chicken sandwich I have had in a long while! Also loved the sliced meatballs on the meats pizza. Added great flavor.
… moreDan Stein
My son’s teacher recommended we try Doughboy’s pizza, so we gave it a try and we were blown away! The young lady who ran the counter was super friendly and helpful. And the pizza has got to be the best in Florida! They have a cool atmosphere that would be great to dine-in.
My family was so upset because the time I got home with the pizza, it was already half gone!
… moreShawn Smith
Dough Boy impressed from start to finish. The pizza came out perfectly—great flavor, great texture, zero notes. The drinks were just as solid, balanced and well-made. What really stood out, though, was the staff. They were welcoming, attentive, and genuinely made the visit feel special. A place that gets every detail right.
… moreaustin barto
Dough Boy absolutely delivered. The pizza was fantastic—fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The drinks were on point too, well‑made and a great match for the food. But the real standout was the staff. They were friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience feel even better.
If you’re looking for a spot that nails great food, solid drinks, and top‑tier service, Dough Boy is the move.
… moreErin Thomassen
I honestly don’t understand how there are so many good reviews for this place. Maybe we went on a bad night? I saw in another review that they thought the crust was frozen and ours absolutely tasted like cafeteria style pizza. The crust was chewy and flat like a stale cracker and I asked for extra cheese and got a smattering of plasticy shredded processed cheese. There was no flavor to the sauce. I am seeing photos of fluffy and airy pizza crust on here and both of our pizzas were unredeemable. I was really hoping.
… moreDigital Skratch
Had been going Donato’s for years so wanted to give this place a shot. I’m glad I checked it out.
The “Killa-B” is a must have if you love pepperoni pizza. They load it up with extra mini pepperonis and have just the right amount hot honey on top to give it even more flavor which pops! One of the best pizza’s I’ve had in a long time.
… more