Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Online Ordering Now Available on our Website! Family Owned and Operated Since the 1960’s. The First and Oldest Pizza Restaurant in Newton. For more than 50 years, a dedication to customer satisfaction, exceptional service, uncompromising value and delicious food has been the foundation of our business. As time marches on, we are constantly challenged to grow and improve and we welcome that challenge. One thing, however, will never change – our family’s time honored commitment to being the very best we can be for ourselves and, more importantly, our customers. Dine with us in person or order online at our website.
Shopping-mall Italian trattoria with brick-oven pizzas by the slice, a BYOB policy & a relaxed vibe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 10 E Clinton St, Newton, NJ 07860
Phone: (973) 383-9330
Website: https://dominicksnj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Dominick’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria | The first and oldest …
Just $12.95 per person. Learn more. Dominick’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria. 10 East Clinton Street Newton, NJ 07860. Phone: 973-383-9330. The Details. OPEN …
Dominick’s Pizzeria and Restaurant | Newton NJ – Facebook
We would like to help you out if you are in need! Please call us at (973) 383-9330 and ask for Pete or Sal if you need help providing food for you or your …
Dominick’s Pizzeria and Restaurant – is a Newton staple. They’ve …
… #GoNewtonNJ #EatLocal #FoodieFriday | Newton, NJ | Facebook. Log in · Video. . Newton, NJ. Aug 14, 2020 . . Dominick’s Pizzeria & Restaurant …
Reviews
Annette Eichler
Not great! Wanted to try this place , the cheese steak was dry , was not asked if we wanted fries with it ,had to basically scoop finely chopping meat up with a fork ,the pizza was so so ,I wanted a soup ,I asked if wild mushroom had a beef base broth , or was it vegetarian ,( I am vegetarian) waiter didn’t have a clue and did not offer to ask! I have reviewed a lot of places on Google maps over 4 million views , I would not go back here!
… moreDonald B
Winner****Best Slice in NJ 2025****
We shlepped here from a number of miles away and we’re glad we did. Our adorable waitress couldn’t have been nicer. We ordered a Caesar Salad and a Garden Salad which were both very good. The star of the show was the pizza which was ordered plain so its goodness wasn’t hidden by toppings. The first thing you notice about the pizza is the lightness and quality of the crust, tremendous. Good tomato flavoring. Not too much cheese which we consider a plus. We don’t like pizzas swimming in cheese. You need to come here soon. You will see us ahead of you!
… moreWe shlepped here from a number of miles away and we’re glad we did. Our adorable waitress couldn’t have been nicer. We ordered a Caesar Salad and a Garden Salad which were both very good. The star of the show was the pizza which was ordered plain so its goodness wasn’t hidden by toppings. The first thing you notice about the pizza is the lightness and quality of the crust, tremendous. Good tomato flavoring. Not too much cheese which we consider a plus. We don’t like pizzas swimming in cheese. You need to come here soon. You will see us ahead of you!
Andrew Vogel
Ordered takeout for Friday night 2/27/26
The pizza came burnt and cheese unapetizing. The mozzarella sticks were hard and raw inside. Very disappointed. Its not French Cuisine we’re making is it. Just tired of paying big money for mediocre products.
… moreThe pizza came burnt and cheese unapetizing. The mozzarella sticks were hard and raw inside. Very disappointed. Its not French Cuisine we’re making is it. Just tired of paying big money for mediocre products.
P. Kahn
Great place for pizza and italian dishes. Love that it’s BYOB and has a chill atmosphere. A group of us split a couple of pizzas and appys and had a very nice meal. It’s a favorite of the locals. Check it out
… moreJ.A.G.
First time ever going to Dominicks we ordered the Buffalo Chicken Roll and pizza. My wife and I have been sick for a week now. We know it’s from the chicken roll. Pizza was great. My wife will never let me order from there again. She ate more of the chicken roll. I had one piece and did not get as sick as her. Stomach pain and other issues related.
… moreChris Cooke
Clean, neat facility in a new location just off Main St. The staff was friendly and professional, the food fresh and tasty. Large portions make for a nice second meal. Definitely will return.
… moreJohn B
Stopped in the other day for two slices. The owner was super friendly, made me feel very welcome.. definitely a place ingrained in the community. had a slice of Palermo tasty perfect blend of sauce/cheese/spices. The regular slice disappointing doughy, not enough sauce or flavor.. will return but only for traditional
… moreM Boone
Just go and don’t think twice about it.
We went by Newsoms pizza but they had no dining in so this one came up as being 3 minutes away. What a good choice!
We got the Chicken Parmesan w Angel hair and a salad with creamy balsalmic(good choice) ,Personal Cheesesteak Pizza and XL 1/2 Cheese1/2 Pepperoni.
Needed more from beverages and seasoning of pasta and sauce(personal preference) but everything else with food and service was good!
Fast service with 3 other families coming in at the same time 45 minutes before closing.
Customers were picking up orders the whole time we were there. They were busy so we figured we picked a good spot.
We will probably return if in the area.
… moreWe went by Newsoms pizza but they had no dining in so this one came up as being 3 minutes away. What a good choice!
We got the Chicken Parmesan w Angel hair and a salad with creamy balsalmic(good choice) ,Personal Cheesesteak Pizza and XL 1/2 Cheese1/2 Pepperoni.
Needed more from beverages and seasoning of pasta and sauce(personal preference) but everything else with food and service was good!
Fast service with 3 other families coming in at the same time 45 minutes before closing.
Customers were picking up orders the whole time we were there. They were busy so we figured we picked a good spot.
We will probably return if in the area.
Denise Hart, REALTOR
Thank you for the excellent service! My colleagues and I enjoyed lunch at Dominick’s after volunteering at the Sussex County Food Bank. Our party was approximately 30 people. Food was great and services were top notch! Thank you again! Cannot wait to come back.
… moreChuck Mound
Was not sure if I was in the right place being that the outdoor sign said Restuarnt and Catering and Not Dominicks. At first glance, I thought it was an extension of the Chinese Food place. But once inside, there was no mistaken your were at a good pizzeria. Being in sussex county, I cannot imagine many pizzerias that would be as good as Dominicks. By the layout, you can either sit down in the main area or order take out. On a Friday night, the flow of traffic seemed to be a combination of both.The staff was really friendly and attentive. I really liked the bigger glasses for your beverage. We didnt have to keep asking for refills. The bread that they serve before the pizza was outstanding. The pizza itself was a very good slice. Great blend of sauce and cheese. The pie was made with love and you can easy say that they know how to make good pizza. I would recommend stopping in, I will be back at some point.
… more