Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Cheery pizzeria known for its thin-crust pies, plus pasta, sandwiches & a Friday-night fish fry.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 481-2348
Website: https://www.domandphildemarinis.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes | Catering | Milwaukee, WI
Serving our renowned original recipe pizza, authentic Italian specialties, fresh made pasta, and our traditional Friday Fish Fry.
Home | Dom And Phil Demarinis Original Recipes – Milwaukee …
Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes. Serving the people of Bay View, West Allis, and surrounding areas of Milwaukee with their renowned original recipe …
Dom & Phil’s DeMarinis Original Recipes | Milwaukee WI – Facebook
A family favorite for generations. Dom&Phil’s DeMarinis Original Recipes 1211 E Conway St Bay View 414-481-2348 It’s not just pizza. It’s a taste of history.
Reviews
Justine Filapek
Though the restaurant itself is a bit outdated, it is not worn out, and still has a very relaxed, cozy feel. I don’t go out to eat for the décor, I go for the food and socializing. As we progressed through our meal, it filled up and got pretty loud. Not with obnoxious drunks causing a scene, but with families out having a good time.
Our server was Jessica and she was just fabulous. She was friendly and outgoing with zero fake. She accommodated our requests, was present when we had needs, and didn’t hover. Would NOT be disappointed to have her with us again.
Now the food. We were all VERY pleased with our choices. Amongst us we had some standard pizzas, baked mostaccioli, a meatball sub, garlic bread, small dinner salad, and I had the Breaded Mozzarella Ala DeMarinis, Small Italian Salad, and the Steak Compobasa Pizza (junior size). Lunch today is going to be awesome. I’ve seen reviews where people are complaining about the small dinner salad being just chopped lettuce and a few toppings. I don’t know what they expect for $2.25, but it is exactly what we expected to see – actually a bit bigger than expected for that price. The “Small” Italian Salad is pretty massive. Definitely not a single serve salad, which had we realized how big it was, my friend and I would probably have split one (and still had leftovers). It’s like an entire head of lettuce is chopped up into the bowl first, then LOADED on top with tomatoes, cheese, black olives, pepperoncini, and pepperoni. The mozzarella sticks were crunchy but not overdone so there was no leaking cheese. I forgot to take my picture before I had started eating them (again) but I believe you get eight. The pizza I chose was just amazing. There’s no red sauce, just garlic and olive oil under the cheese. It was so tasty and the steak was VERY tender. Had the leftover pizza for breakfast while I’m typing this because I was thinking about it so much. That leaves the salad for lunch and the mozz sticks for a snack.
I had not been here in decades. It’s great to know it’s still as good as it was back then.
… moreOur server was Jessica and she was just fabulous. She was friendly and outgoing with zero fake. She accommodated our requests, was present when we had needs, and didn’t hover. Would NOT be disappointed to have her with us again.
Now the food. We were all VERY pleased with our choices. Amongst us we had some standard pizzas, baked mostaccioli, a meatball sub, garlic bread, small dinner salad, and I had the Breaded Mozzarella Ala DeMarinis, Small Italian Salad, and the Steak Compobasa Pizza (junior size). Lunch today is going to be awesome. I’ve seen reviews where people are complaining about the small dinner salad being just chopped lettuce and a few toppings. I don’t know what they expect for $2.25, but it is exactly what we expected to see – actually a bit bigger than expected for that price. The “Small” Italian Salad is pretty massive. Definitely not a single serve salad, which had we realized how big it was, my friend and I would probably have split one (and still had leftovers). It’s like an entire head of lettuce is chopped up into the bowl first, then LOADED on top with tomatoes, cheese, black olives, pepperoncini, and pepperoni. The mozzarella sticks were crunchy but not overdone so there was no leaking cheese. I forgot to take my picture before I had started eating them (again) but I believe you get eight. The pizza I chose was just amazing. There’s no red sauce, just garlic and olive oil under the cheese. It was so tasty and the steak was VERY tender. Had the leftover pizza for breakfast while I’m typing this because I was thinking about it so much. That leaves the salad for lunch and the mozz sticks for a snack.
I had not been here in decades. It’s great to know it’s still as good as it was back then.
J H
The pizza sauce and crust is really great. The sausage is more of a meatball and the mushrooms are canned. Overall this place is fabulous but I would order differently next time based on what we learned the first time. Food was pretty fast, service was super attentive. The atmosphere was nice in many ways but even though the place was not full it was still loud enough it was hard for us and the server to hear each other. This food feels homemade and that’s a huge plus.
… moreCollin O’Brien
We simply loved every single thing about this place. Thanks Annamaria for the wonderful, kind, and fun service! We will 100% be coming back anytime when in Milwaukee. Get the garlic bread.
– The Snickerdoodles
… more– The Snickerdoodles
Troy Klosinski
The people are so overly friendly. The pizza crust was so light and flaky. The pasta was full of sauce and cheese. So good!
… moreEngel’s Daniel’s
Visit this restaurant for a meeting with a friend. The atmosphere is very pleasant, plus the style of decoration is cozy.
I really loved the customer service and the performance of the waitress, dynamic, punctual, attentive.
I recommend that you do not make the same mistake as me, my visit was on a fish Friday and I went for this one, a serious mistake that fish was a dish not at all recommended, do not try it, fish is not its forte.
I tried pasta and yes I loved it.
… moreI really loved the customer service and the performance of the waitress, dynamic, punctual, attentive.
I recommend that you do not make the same mistake as me, my visit was on a fish Friday and I went for this one, a serious mistake that fish was a dish not at all recommended, do not try it, fish is not its forte.
I tried pasta and yes I loved it.
Mathias J
The place is outdated, but the staff was very friendly and a great service overall.
The pizza was the only food item we tried. It was alright. Overall, with prices, food, and service, we were happy with what we got.
… moreThe pizza was the only food item we tried. It was alright. Overall, with prices, food, and service, we were happy with what we got.
David Cannon
Very good pizza served in an old school style restaurant with a comfortable, family friendly vibe. They also feature a fish fry on Fridays.
… moreJack Jachowicz
First of all, I want to say that this is my favorite pizza I have ever had. I’ve been going here since I was born, and I have never had a bad experience. My go-to order is an Italian salad for an appetizer, and for the entree, a sausage mushroom pizza with pepperoncinis. It has always been a pleasure to go here, and I would like to thank DeMarinis for all the great times!
… moreMark Thomson
Happen to be in the area and it has been a long time since we did DeMarinis pizza. Used to go to the original one in Bayview. Pizza was okay but used to be better. Would still go if in the area, but we would probably not go out of our way to go for the pizza when we have found better places closer to home.
… morePaul Sidlowski
The atmosphere was excellent, the service was attentive and friendly and the prices were good. Overall, it felt like a well-loved neighborhood establishment, and it clearly is.
Unfortunately, the food was a bit of a let-down. We didn’t try the pizza, so maybe they is much better, but the pasta left something to be desired. The mostacoli was badly overcooked, and although the lasagna was better it was still not especially good. Fortunately, the garlic bread was enjoyable.
Overall, I wouldn’t object to going there if we were in the neighborhood with no other options, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back.
… moreUnfortunately, the food was a bit of a let-down. We didn’t try the pizza, so maybe they is much better, but the pasta left something to be desired. The mostacoli was badly overcooked, and although the lasagna was better it was still not especially good. Fortunately, the garlic bread was enjoyable.
Overall, I wouldn’t object to going there if we were in the neighborhood with no other options, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back.