Christine Lantry
In town visiting relatives and it was great being back In NY to enjoy Italian food. Lovely local spot full of hustle and bustle. I recommend the front dining room over the back. We sampled the eggplant parm which was delicious. Nicely stacked up and not mushy. The marinara on point. Had a nice sweetness to it. The gnocchi was outstanding. Excellent texture with a creamy softness to it. We chose to have it pairs with vodka sauce. The bread was served warm with butter. My glass of red was perfectly matched to our food. Thank you!
… moreJ
This was my childhood place. Having been back almost 15 years later and being able to enjoy the same quality food was a privilege. Authentic delicious food, impeccable customer service, I cant wait to be back eventho I’m in NJ now
Thank you for all your warmth you shared with my family and truly wish you the bestest
… morebill d
Top notch authentic Italian dishes. Quality of the food is excellent. Hot appetizer is delicious. All the veal entrees are great. Not inexpensive but worth it. Escarole and white bean soup is fantastic as is the bull’s eye pasta.
… moreJoe
This restaurant was by far the BEST Italian food I have had in NYC and Long Island. The portions were perfect, the taste was delicious, the timing of the food coming out amazing. From start to finish the experience we had was spot on perfect. The wait staff and the owner were also very nice. We will definitely be coming back to DiMaggio’s.
… moreSuzy Mellen
We just had our son’s communion party here and Dimaggios was perfection!! The food was mind blowing! The hot and cold antipasti kept coming – burrata, roasted peppers, olives, tomato & basil, artichokes with bread crumbs, fried calamari and marinara, garlic bread- each dish was so delicious!! Then came the salad course, followed by an impressive selection of entrees and it was topped off with our cake and a choice of tea, espresso and coffee!! We even had limoncello! What a way to finish!! I also had guests with gluten free and dairy free requests and they were served wonderful options as well!! Everyone I spoke to raved that this was the best Italian restaurant they’ve ever been to!! And the atmosphere could not be beat!! We had the entire back room to ourselves and we felt as though we were transported to Italy! It was so authentic! Eddy was so helpful during the planning process and he knew just how to set up the room to compliment our decorations for the occasion! He even put together a beautiful personalized menu for our guests to make their selections! It added just the right touch! The service staff also went above and beyond and were so attentive and friendly!! It made for such a memorable experience!! I can’t thank them all enough!! Our son said that “this was the best time of his life and that this is his favorite restaurant.” I can wholeheartedly say that we agree!! We can’t wait to plan our next event here! I know we will be having my other son’s communion here without a doubt! But we are already trying to figure out the next time we can go out to dinner here because we know that the food will always be phenomenal!! Thanks again for such a wonderful time!! I cannot recommend Dimaggios enough!! Event planning has never been so easy! Rest assured all will be taken care of! I wish I had pics of the food but we devoured it ALL before we had the opportunity! Thanks so much again to everyone that was involved in making our day so special!
… moreMichael Fockler
Came here on a strong recommendation of a friend! Boy, was this place amazing! Authentic and everyone was so hospitable. I flew in from LA for an event and this was the first stop. The food was spectacular! Take some time to see the town too. A real charmer. Thank you Ed for your kindness!
… moreJennifer S
I love coming here with my mom who lives close by in PW. Her favorite dish is the appetizer, La Foresta. I love the linguine white clam sauce. We also share a pizzetta. We have tried so many of their dishes, all impeccable. What we truly love about DiMaggio’s is Eddy and the staff. They make you feel so welcome. Eddy even puts on music from my mom’s favorite Italian singer when we dine there. He is a gem of a man and this restaurant is a must try when in the area.
… moreMellie Sarodz
Great place very familiar and also music is good. It’s not too loud so you can still talk to the person with you, the environment here is awesome I loved it. The waitress was very attentive all time.
… moreAlva Lai
Found this hidden jewel because I couldn’t get in the restaurant I planned to visit. The Penne a la vodka turned out to be the highlight of my day. It’s the best pasta I’ve ever had in the past 3 years and it definitely showed me the true form of comfort food. I’ve never found myself smiling nonstop from the second pasta was served. Definitely recommend the pasta. Tiramisu was not too sweet, super moist and flavorful, perfect match with the extra foamy cappuccino served with perfect amount of ground cinnamon on top. Do not miss out on the dessert!!
… morejohn leonard
Went for lunch with my friend. One glass of wine, soup, pasta…. x2=$175… ouch. food was good not great, It has been 6 hours past I still cant get over how expensive it was.
… more