David Brosius
Upon arrival at my Hotel in Wheeling, I asked about a local restaurant that had something different. They recommended DiCarlo’s Pizza – what a treat. The provolone cheese and pepperoni are put on the pizza AFTER it comes out of the oven. Ohio Valley Style Pizza! It was absolutely delicious… I will definitely come here again when I am in the area! Awesome Pizza!
… moreChris Howell
Very clean, not a sit in restaurant, but a nice bench to wait. Food was fast and very good. I had the pepperoni roll, and wife had 2 pieces of pizza, for $8, great deal. Just sorry I didnt see the combo for the soda for an extra $1.25 with the pepperoni roll.
… moreStacy
Called in for a pickup order, on a Saturday afternoon. So I’m sure they were super busy. The female that answered the phone didn’t ask for my name, but kept calling me Kay. I did correct her, once, but since they had my phone number, didn’t really worry me. I get there(10 mins later) and immediately was greeted. I said I called in an order, tell her what it was and she says, “I don’t have that”. I explain I just talked to her and give my phone number. She says, “nope, don’t have it”. I remind her that she was calling me Kay. She says, “oh, Marquis!”. Not a big deal, since I got my order, but it definitely could have been. If you are not going to ask for a name, then maybe give me a number for my order? The pizza was delicious, which is why it’s 5 star. Plenty of sauce, which I love. Cheese/pepperoni ratio was good. Crust was crisp. But maybe make sure she has your name correct, lol
… moreJames “Jim WV8JHF” Foster
Great pizza. It had been a while since I’ve had DiCarlos and it did not disappoint both delicious and affordable pieces with pepperoni and a drink for 7 bucks. Pizza was fresh will be visiting again next time I’m in the area.
… moreBrandon
Great style pizza for a change. Get the Cold cheese extra. Great lunch spot. Everyone says ewww cold cheese. No you don’t understand until you try it. The cheese is so fine it just melts in your mouth. Give it a shot I know you’ll like it.
… moreK W
I’m from Baltimore, Maryland and dicarlos is a family tradition of mine going all the way back to when I was 6 in the early 90s. Some of the best pizza and I was still impressed
… moreM Woods
I work at the highlands and Dicarlos is always friendly, food is always terrific. I ordered 12 pepperoni roll for our office and they were great! I said we’re because everyone gobbled them up! Great staff!
… moreBrandon Gilbert
Ate at DiCarlo’s Pizza in Triadelphia, WV for the first time, in November 2023, while visiting nearby Cabela’s. The pizza was great! However, the location was confusing, as it is located in a plaza that requires you to go one way around a circle.
Also, some of the photos posted in the Google Maps entry and reviews show an entirely different restaurant. There is no indoor eating at the Triadelphia location. Instead, it is a very small carry-out. Thankfully it was a nice day, and there are picnic tables across the parking lot.
There are also NO restrooms available for patrons, and that is posted on their door. Not good for traveling customers.
One of the employees appeared to be high or really out of it. I observed him smoking something outside the business’ doors after I had left. However, he did get the job done.
Being a longtime fan of Ohio Valley style pizza, I was happy to be able to eat some while in the area. I definitely recommend this very unique style of pizza!
… moreJulia B
I really liked this pizza – few things. Toppings are limited so I hope you like sausage, banana peppers or pepperoni. Second, they are take out only. I happen to like sausage and banana peppers so it was fine for me.
… moreMichelle Riedlinger
Truly a different pizza! Tastes great just DON’T GET EXTRA CHEESE! Extra cheese isn’t for this style of pizza!
… more