Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
We are a family-owned small business dedicated to serving delicious food in a welcoming atmosphere. As a family restaurant, we specialize in classic Italian-American comfort food. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering pizzas, crisp salads, savory pasta dishes, and hearty subs. We put our heart into every dish, ensuring a delightful dining experience for our valued customers.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2070 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter, SC 29154
Phone: (803) 499-4741
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Demara’s Italian Restaurant | Sumter SC – Facebook
We are a locally owned restaurant serving pizza, pasta, salads and subs to Sumter, Shaw Air Force Base and the surrounding areas for over 30 years.
DeMara’s Sumter – Authentic Italian Cuisine in Sumter, SC
Nestled in the heart of Sumter, South Carolina, DeMara’s Restaurant (located at 2070 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter, SC 29154) is a must-visit destination for food …
DE Mara’s Italian Restaurant – Sumter,SC | Menu,Photos,Reviews
DE Mara’s Italian Restaurant Sumter, DE Mara’s Italian Restaurant Sumter Online ordering, online order accepting credit card, DE Mara’s Italian Restaurant …
Reviews
Kimber Wisener
Nice casual atmosphere that is super family friendly!
Service was friendly too!
We ordered pizza, a foot long meatball sub and salad. It was delicious and we’ll definitely be going back soon!
… moreService was friendly too!
We ordered pizza, a foot long meatball sub and salad. It was delicious and we’ll definitely be going back soon!
NJ Fraysier
I ordered the pizza at 8:53 PM at the location, and received it at 9:18 PM, 25 minutes later and cost a little over $16. The staff was friendly and the place appeared clean. The pizza itself though was underwhelming. The pizza was loaded with Pepperonis which resulted in them being cooked in consistently with some being soft others being crunchy. The cheese was not evenly distributed, resulting in a pile of cheese in the center which had a rubbery texture. The crust had no flavor and the first thing you taste when you take a bite is sauce, resulting in the crust being soggy along with the topping sliding off the pizza with ease
If you enjoy this pizza, you don’t know what good pizza is. I would recommend going elsewhere for pizza.
… moreIf you enjoy this pizza, you don’t know what good pizza is. I would recommend going elsewhere for pizza.
BasicBrittani
I loved it. Simple little place. Quite affordable.
Ya walk in and see the big board of so many options then you order, pay and go take a seat. They’ll bring your food to you.
I was very happy the pizza wasn’t greasy and my sub bun was nice and crisp. Also got one of the desserts they offered and we had to grab another one, it was so good!
Now, this is Sumter, so don’t go expecting cut fresh pepperonis and mushrooms.
… moreYa walk in and see the big board of so many options then you order, pay and go take a seat. They’ll bring your food to you.
I was very happy the pizza wasn’t greasy and my sub bun was nice and crisp. Also got one of the desserts they offered and we had to grab another one, it was so good!
Now, this is Sumter, so don’t go expecting cut fresh pepperonis and mushrooms.
Cracker McSnacker
I waited 35 minutes for 1 large pizza that wasnt even cut all the way and tasted horrid, cheese was like plastic. Here’s a suggestion for the business – just do the NYC pizza recipe – crispy, cooked and real mozzarella cheese. The ingredients taste so cheapo pizza place.
… moreRenata C. Franklin
Worst pizza in Sumter!
The pizza dough is a standard bread dough (I’m not kidding) It’s thick and resembles a bad version of focaccia bread, nothing pizza about it. Both 16 inch pizzas were room temperature. The topping appeared to be tossed on after it was removed from the oven. The Whole Feta & Bread appetizer is just lame marinara sauce with crumbled grocery store feta accompanied with toasted french bread, not worth the price. My husband and I dined in and left a tip only to discover there was no table service. How could anyone anticipate that? The pizza, drinks, and appetizer had been brought out to our table, the girl never returned after. We requested a refund on the Tiramisu I never received but was available when I initially placed my order. It was sold out by the time we were done waiting for the cashier to bring it to us. The plates we requested never arrived, the cashier was taking a to-go call instead. I had to retrieve them from her personally. I asked for my tip back as well as the refund for the Tiramisu. The manager was not receptive to speaking with us and avoided us. We requested that our pizza be reheated, it took forever. We requested the pizza be boxed to go while it was still in the oven because we were not going to endure such bad service any longer. The two young girls taking payment were not trained well and were lost in the sauce. They did not know what Balsamic Vinaigrette was though it was a dressing featured on their menu. Every television was off and the environment was stone silent. It was not a pleasure dining in which explains the plethora of to-go orders that took way too long to complete. The manager insisted on speaking with us from the register, which created a scene. We asked to have the conversation in private. We appeared to be just another group of angry black folks who could not get their way. I’m sick and tired of these trash businesses in Sumter that take our money and give us bare minimum in return. Enough is enough. I will not be patronizing this establishment again. Neither should you. Bad service does not deserve the publics support. Hold these businesses accountable for their actions. We spent over $80 for our meal. That’s insane for the quality we received.
… moreThe pizza dough is a standard bread dough (I’m not kidding) It’s thick and resembles a bad version of focaccia bread, nothing pizza about it. Both 16 inch pizzas were room temperature. The topping appeared to be tossed on after it was removed from the oven. The Whole Feta & Bread appetizer is just lame marinara sauce with crumbled grocery store feta accompanied with toasted french bread, not worth the price. My husband and I dined in and left a tip only to discover there was no table service. How could anyone anticipate that? The pizza, drinks, and appetizer had been brought out to our table, the girl never returned after. We requested a refund on the Tiramisu I never received but was available when I initially placed my order. It was sold out by the time we were done waiting for the cashier to bring it to us. The plates we requested never arrived, the cashier was taking a to-go call instead. I had to retrieve them from her personally. I asked for my tip back as well as the refund for the Tiramisu. The manager was not receptive to speaking with us and avoided us. We requested that our pizza be reheated, it took forever. We requested the pizza be boxed to go while it was still in the oven because we were not going to endure such bad service any longer. The two young girls taking payment were not trained well and were lost in the sauce. They did not know what Balsamic Vinaigrette was though it was a dressing featured on their menu. Every television was off and the environment was stone silent. It was not a pleasure dining in which explains the plethora of to-go orders that took way too long to complete. The manager insisted on speaking with us from the register, which created a scene. We asked to have the conversation in private. We appeared to be just another group of angry black folks who could not get their way. I’m sick and tired of these trash businesses in Sumter that take our money and give us bare minimum in return. Enough is enough. I will not be patronizing this establishment again. Neither should you. Bad service does not deserve the publics support. Hold these businesses accountable for their actions. We spent over $80 for our meal. That’s insane for the quality we received.
Derek Wilson
The best pizza in Sumter, hands down.
And the Macaroni and cheese is to die for!!!! Tonight wasn’t as good as it has been in the past. The pizza crust wasn’t cooked all the way through and it seems like my order was given to someone else, because my family ordered a other pizza and macaroni and cheese after I did and they received there order 10 minutes before I got mine. It wasn’t the best night for me.
… moreAnd the Macaroni and cheese is to die for!!!! Tonight wasn’t as good as it has been in the past. The pizza crust wasn’t cooked all the way through and it seems like my order was given to someone else, because my family ordered a other pizza and macaroni and cheese after I did and they received there order 10 minutes before I got mine. It wasn’t the best night for me.
amy marshall
Best Pizza in Sumter!!! Great atmosphere!! Great people.
Price per person: …
… morePrice per person: …
Majestic Challenger
Of all the times I’ve been going here I never experienced my sub being burnt (see pics). The food is not cheap so l am very disappointed. I just wish l saw this before l left. I won’t be ordering a sub from here no more.
… moreEA M
Not sure how you screw up a chicken bacon spinach pizzas, but I received something with chicken and tomatoes on it and that was it. Annoying since we live 20 minutes away, so I’m not going to drive all the way back
… morePatricia Kolp
Had heard they had excellent pizza and decided to give it a try. I was not disappointed! Very friendly staff.
… more