Francene Brown
Food was EXCELLENT! Best tomato pie I’ve ever eaten. Great service! The server couldn’t have been more pleasant or accommodating. Very clean and a wonderful atmosphere! I will be returning! I highly recommend!
… morepatty rusinovich
I won’t be back! BYOB no Wine glasses,not a fan of over cooked Pizza so ordered it lightly cooked that was a bad choice because it’s was way undercooked. Ordered Meatball appetizer also not good. Very interested in seeing other reviews. Definitely will not return
… moreJerry Foley
Tyler is carrying on the tradition that his grandfather Big Rick started and making everyone who worked on Hamilton Avenue proud. Well done, Tyler.
… moreRocco Luciano
great pies and salads! the service was awesome, will definitely be back!
… moreAlexandria Thompson
FIRE PIZZA FIRE STAFF FIRE OWNER THEYRE ON TOPPPPP
… moreEllery Perfect
Had there pizza salad and bruschetta all was made great the server was really nice and i even got the chance to speak with the owner who was really kind and welcoming
… moreWade Cohen
Great tomato pie. Tyler is doing a nice job representing the Delorenzo family proudly.
… moreEileen Birk
We dined in. Food was delicious. 3 of us had personal pies, and shared a cheesesteak sandwich. Severe food allergies limitations were accommodated. Food was cooked to perfection, per individual requests for the delicious pies, and the sandwich was very tasty. Prices are very reasonable. Our server, Molly, was very friendly and efficient. The owner, Tyler, came to the table to speak with us. Very Welcoming. Very clean restaurant. We very much enjoyed our meal. And we look forward to dining there again soon. Thank you.
… moreSomesh Rao
I was so bummed when the DeLorenzo’s at the same location shutdown, I had been coming here for almost 10 year. But another DeLorenzo cousin started this restaurant and it is definitely very good. I ordered the famous DeLorenzo Tomato Pie and it did not disappoint. Crisp crust, not oily, a flavorful sauce and the right amount of cheese make this one of the best tomato pies you can buy. The restaurant is very well furnished. The old photos on the wall are interesting. Highly recommend. Once you eat a NJ Tomato Pie, you can never go back to pizza.
… moreMartin Pappaterra
I’ve been coming to this place for over 50 years. It’s one of the best pizza places in the entire country! Tyler, the new owner, is a well-mannered an intelligent young man. I have no doubt that he will be serving pizza for the next 50 years.
… more