Olivia Robinson
Wow the food is amazing!! I had eggplant Parmesan. My husband had baked ziti, and we both had a pepperoni and cheese pinwheel. The portions are enormous and there is plenty of leftovers for me to take to work for lunch tomorrow. The owner is so nice and down to earth! It’s a wonderful experience. We will definitely be back! Thank you for your exceptional food and service! ❤️
… moreSeana Gunn
I had to double check my map to make sure I was actually in Yulee, FL! DeCicco’s was recommended to me by a fellow “Yankee” who told me it’s the best pizza around. Having high hopes, I stopped in for a pizza and drove 30+ minutes home with it to Brunswick. He wasn’t kidding! My aunt, who was visiting from NJ at the time, raved about the pizza and we all agreed it tasted like “home”.
After dreaming about the food for a couple months, I stopped in again tonight with a friend on my way back from a shopping trip in Jacksonville. She had a slice of Sicilian pizza and baked ziti. I opted for the chicken parm with vodka sauce. Absolutely delicious and everything was super fresh.
Before we left, the owner sent over an order of Zeppoles. I haven’t had a zeppole since I was a kid and it brought back so much nostalgia. Such a tasty treat and a very kind gesture. I really enjoyed speaking with him and look forward to continuing to support his business.
I ordered a slice of rainbow cake to go because it reminded me of my Grandma’s rainbow cookies. I haven’t tried that yet, but I’m sure it will be delicious!
Thank you DeCicco’s for making me feel right at home!
… moreAdam G-Mann
DeCicco’s Pizzeria is a fantastic spot for some amazing pizza. This is definitely the best place we’ve had pizza from in a while. We ordered six slices amd a roll from the warming case, meat lovers, deluxe, grandma, buffalo chicken, smokey brisket, and a garlic roll. Even though they were sitting in the warmer and reheated, they were very tasty. The crust had great flavors and also a nice crisp to it. The sausage or ground beef had great flavor and spicy to it. There’s a few tables inside to eat in amd some tables outside as well.
… moreDawn Williams
I really want to give this place a 5, but something is missing. The crust is great at least in a large; it’s pretty thin until you get to the edge where it’s crisp on the outside and delightfully doughy chew on the inside. It’s not too greasy and uniformly covered in cheese. I’m not sure if there’s just not enough sauce, or lacking a flavor in general…it just needs something.
It’s much smaller inside than I thought it would be and I can see at least 6 people working and a steady flow of people coming in to take pizza to go, so it’s kind of loud because of a lot of people calling out orders. I like some of the NY signs and pictures that have up.
Not the same kind of friendly as most places are around here, but not at all rude. Probably just so busy is why. I also thought they had more pasta dishes, but they are primarily pizza and a good amount of sandwiches. We will definitely try some more things.
… moreAndy
My favorite place to have pizza in Yulee, crispy cheesy with a good crust on the bottom. Amazing people running the place such as Chris and his employees always smiling when you enter, Great people!
Highly recommend the meat pizza and the dessert tiramisu!
Chicken parm sandwich was crispy cutlet with lots of cheese and juicy inside.
… moreLorey Tinti
Delicious! Old NY style pizza and atmosphere. Our pizza was fresh and fantastic. Perfectly crispy crust and yummy zucchini fries. Service was excellent. Definitely stopping by again next time we’re in Jacksonville. The knots were already gone when I thought to take a picture:/
… moreJames Weiss
Friendly and helpful people! Amazing pizza randomly found on a road trip
Grandmas lasagna was amazing! Great deal for 2 slices and a drink! Wings were crispy and delicious with tasty buffalo sauce
… moreCheyenne Manzo
The staff is very polite and professional! Very welcoming and friendly to new customers as well as regulars! The food was AMAZING! We got garlic knots, two grandma slices and one Sicilian slice ♥️ they brought my kids coloring sheets, crayons and stickers! We loved our experience here!
… moreGene Velardo
Amazing food and customer service. The pizza reminds me of growing up on Long Island. The best I have had in Noryh Florida in my 23 years of living here. . If you happen to be on I-95 in North Florida get off at exit 373 in Yulee and give them a shot. You will not be disappointed!!!
Oh and the Rainbow cookie cake is phenomenal!!!!
… moreKathryn Zekas
You can tell the owners really care about the quality of their ingredients and their food. They make their sauce in house and it is fantastic! Great crust, fresh mozzarella and ingredients! This is the way that pizza is supposed to be! So delicious. And the chef and people behind the counter are so friendly! Thank you DeCiccos!
… more