Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3176 US-98, Mary Esther, FL 32569
Phone: (850) 374-3054
Website: https://damatteopizzeria.com/?utm_source=google
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Italian food in Mary Esther, FL | Da’ Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria …
Best locally-owned independent Italian restaurant in Mary Esther serving our real, authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients.
Da’ Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria | Mary Esther FL – Facebook
Best locally-owned independent Italian restaurant in Mary Esther serving our real, authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients.
Da’matteo Ristorante-pizzeria Delivery Menu – Mary Esther – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Da’matteo Ristorante-pizzeria in Mary Esther! View Da’matteo Ristorante-pizzeria’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Kaizu
Waitress was very kind, even when it started getting pretty full— easy to talk to and very helpful. Food was WONDERFUL, got 2 pizzas, a bowl of alfredo, their cheese cake, and their lemon cake (shared among the family). Tables were pretty comfortable, and the entire environment was very clean! Would totally come again if I come back to Florida
… moreSarah Godwin
Food was amazing. I enjoyed the atmosphere and my waitress. Very kind and informative. It was worth the money I spent and we all ate our leftovers for dinner, I normally forget to eat my leftovers but I wanted more.
… moreAlysha Reinersmann
Better than your typical pizza place! The crust is yummy and has the oven flavor that says authentic Italian pizza. New favorite pizzeria! We got a cheese and a pepperoni with jalapenos. Very tasty.
… moreKristin Mendoza
Okay Da’ Matteo… what did y’all put in this pasta?!
We ordered the spaghetti and the spaghetti carbonara and my husband has been saying “WOW” every two minutes like I didn’t cook dinner for him for years I can’t even be mad though — it’s honestly the best pasta we’ve had.
The carbonara was creamy and rich without being heavy, and the spaghetti meatballs came with meatballs the size of BASEBALLS. Not kidding. Huge. And so good.
If you’re thinking about trying them — do it. We’ll definitely be ordering again!
… moreWe ordered the spaghetti and the spaghetti carbonara and my husband has been saying “WOW” every two minutes like I didn’t cook dinner for him for years I can’t even be mad though — it’s honestly the best pasta we’ve had.
The carbonara was creamy and rich without being heavy, and the spaghetti meatballs came with meatballs the size of BASEBALLS. Not kidding. Huge. And so good.
If you’re thinking about trying them — do it. We’ll definitely be ordering again!
Leslie Six
We went late on a Saturday night for our anniversary while on vacation. We meet a local that recommended this place for a date night if we wanted casual,laid back atmosphere. It was definitely that! And the wood fired stove right up front! I ordered what seemed like everything! And it was ALL amazing!! Appetizers, Entree, Desserts, and a pizza to go!
… moreNathan Saam
The makings of a great pizza ruined by a flaccid dough. You can tell they use top shelf ingredients as the toppings were bright and tasty. The crust was also fantastic and chewy. You can tell they made the dough properly and let it rest. The problem is the the center of the pizza was not thoroughly cooked and it left a sad floppy piece of pizza.
… moreAutumn McAllister
I started eating here back in February this year. My mother’s family is from Napoli, and eating here is exactly like being in Napoli again. I’ve never been disappointed. The pizza is incredible, but so are the appetizers and the homemade pasta and sauce. The burrata and bruschetta alone make me smile. It’s a true, authentic family restaurant and an absolute treasure to have in our area.
… moreCissy Macias
The pizza crust was amazing.
The toppings were good.
The sauce was good.
Portion sizes were good.
The atmosphere is ok. It’s just not homey and feels more like fast-food.
The service was good.
The draft beer selection was not to my taste. I don’t like to drink beer out of a bottle or can when I am in a nice restaurant.
The wine list was good , but restaurant pours are usually small, and I feel I get more bang for my buck with a beer.
We were going to order dessert. However, the desserts are not homemade. Which was really disappointing. I feel if you’re going to make good food, it should also include making your own in-house desserts.
We will try this place again and order something other than pizza.
… moreThe toppings were good.
The sauce was good.
Portion sizes were good.
The atmosphere is ok. It’s just not homey and feels more like fast-food.
The service was good.
The draft beer selection was not to my taste. I don’t like to drink beer out of a bottle or can when I am in a nice restaurant.
The wine list was good , but restaurant pours are usually small, and I feel I get more bang for my buck with a beer.
We were going to order dessert. However, the desserts are not homemade. Which was really disappointing. I feel if you’re going to make good food, it should also include making your own in-house desserts.
We will try this place again and order something other than pizza.
Casey Scheff
My family stopped in after reading great reviews and we are so glad we did! The inside is super cute and well decorated. Our waitress greeted us promptly and was super patient while we decided what to get with our children. We started with a pizza- we did half pepperoni and half Al copone. You could tell all the ingredients were fresh and the crust was fantastic. We have been looking for a decent pizza since we moved to the area and this one definitely did. My husband got the 4 cheese gnocchi and it was so flavorful and delicious. I ordered the lasagna and it was huge. Great flavor but I will probably get something different next time. My son got the kids fettuccine Alfredo and it was great. They give you bread with a garlic olive oil dip and it was fresh and yummy. We ended with the limoncello cake and the cake itself was great but I wasn’t a fan of the sauce that came with it. We will absolutely be back. Great food and great service.
… moreMary Allen
Don’t let the simple exterior fool you! The authentic Italian food here is unbeatable! When we visit Navarre, this place is on our list of “must-haves”!
The food is fresh and made to order. They have a simple wine list and a full bar.
The Gnocchi Formaggi is my absolute favorite, and my daughter loves the lasagna!
You can dress up or come in your flips!
… moreThe food is fresh and made to order. They have a simple wine list and a full bar.
The Gnocchi Formaggi is my absolute favorite, and my daughter loves the lasagna!
You can dress up or come in your flips!