Maria Morales
I’ve been coming to Rusty’s Custard Factory for almost 25 years, and employees like Bradleigh and Deacon are what make this place so special. Bradleigh makes the best custards I’ve ever had. They’re absolutely perfect, and you can tell how much care and effort she puts into them. She does such an amazing job every time. Deacon is just as wonderful. He is always so kind and welcoming towards everyone. He makes every visit better and creates such a positive experience from start to finish.
I truly appreciate both of them so much. After coming here for decades, it’s clear that Bradleigh and Deacon are a huge part of why Rusty’s continues to be a place people love. They deserve all the recognition!
… moreRC Appas
Sweet Cravings after amazing burger couple of doors down led us to this place.
Ordered Cherry Bombshell, Vanilla Concrete with Fudge.
Cherry Bombshell was ok, cup had a small hole and started leaking. Vanilla concrete you can barely taste the fudge.
… moreAdam Abrahamson
This place is not the same place as it used to be. The Custard is not smooth at all. Instead, it is more icy/rough compared to what it used to be. With so many new places popping up in Norman, I just don’t see us going back here unless things change back.
Also, if the owner reads this: don’t advertise having a flavor (pumpkin) when it is not actually available. We specifically went here to try the pumpkin, since the google page and even the HUGE sign inside place say to order it……but when we did, we were told it isn’t ready until October…..why was this not part of the advertisements and signs?
Used to love this place, but done for now.
… moreVictoria Skinner
Used to love coming here ever since I was a little girl. Was sad to come in today when passing through from Kingston Oklahoma and be told that you do not have a menu with options and now it is a build your own. That is not at all how it used to be.
After sitting here and eating my custard i have seen several other customers come in and order things from I’m assuming used to be the menu. As I have heard them order the “sinister” and the “union boss”. Now I am wondering why we were not told about the menu and told it was build your own only.
… moreShelby Abraham
I’ve been going to this place for almost a decade now, just went back for the first time in a while and it made me very sad. Custard was bad and the toppings were sparse and very low quality. Employees were kind, but it’s definitely not worth the high price for such a small amount.
… morerandall adkins
not sure if they changed the recipe or what but not worth $6. use to be creamy and hard but now it doesn’t even taste like custard
… moreRachel Camp
We stopped in this afternoon to get a cool treat and we’re so happy we did! Ava was super helpful and patient since we’d never been there before and made up our order quickly. It was SOOOO good! Ava was very attentive and kind – customer service like that is hard to come by! We can’t wait to come back.
… moreMarciLynn
Super cute custard shop with lots of unique options! The service was great and environment welcoming. They even gave us the left over root beer from our order! Super fun find.
… moreAnne
Delicious butter pecan concrete! Also, the cashier was extremely kind and pleasant. She was patient as I paid in coins. Tip: if it’s warm outside, eat it inside so that it doesn’t melt. Part of what’s so good about concretes is their thick texture, which quickly melts away in warm weather.
… moreIv M
Great treat!! 3 flavors plus about 40 toppings. If you get there before 5pm of Sunday they have fresh waffles.
… more