Katie S
My family frequents this bakery almost every weekend they are open… everything is phenomenal and service is always great, even when they are crowded. Our absolute favorite is the powdered white cream donuts (it’s real cream not custard like all other bakeries), but Boston cream, jelly filled, and the crumb cake are also amazing. We also love the pb pie (to the point that we freeze a whole one to have at Thanksgiving). We are counting down the days til they reopen for the season! We love you Crust & Crumb, please never change!
… moreAmanda Broody
Go to this bakery for all of your SPECIAL OCCASION CAKES!! I ordered my son’s 6th birthday cake after looking over the bakeries in LBI and I was so happy how his cake turned out. It was BEAUTIFUL & DELICIOUS and we will definitely be ordering from here from now on! Coming from a baker myself, I was hesitant to order because of my expectations, but Crust and Crumb Bakery is AMAZING! THANK YOU EVERYONE for going out of your way for my last minute order!! It means everything to us♥️♥️
… moreCaitlyn McIntyre
I worked with Crust & Crumb to create a birthday cake for my daughter, and they absolutely delivered! The cake was not only delicious but beautifully made. When I went to pick it up, the team took the time to make sure everything was taken care of and that I felt heard and cared for. I truly appreciate all the hard work they put in. Thank you for making her birthday extra special!
… moreThomas Mertz
It’s been there for 40+ years. Great place to get “sticky buns” excellent elephant ear
… moreDaveT
Prices are high but quality is good. I love their elephant ears. Have tried a few other pastries with mixed success for my taste. Great location to get something, eat right outside on the mostly shaded tables on a hot day, or go walk to the gazebo down by the water across the parking lot. Coffee their and next door isn’t to my liking so much so I usually get it from Wawa beforehand.
… moreVegan Gearhead
Amazing vegan pastries, but unfortunately they are $8 each. I’m used to paying a premium for vegan food, but this price point is hard to swallow. As much as I loved the black and white cookie I purchased, I probably won’t be going back unless they can pull them into the $4-$5 range
… moreJudith Tabish
Haven’t been here in a while gave them a try and I’m kind of disappointed with the quality of the crème brûlée. Tasted bitter and burnt for $7 I guess since the receipt doesn’t itemize the pastries. The cannolis were okay for the price
… moreMichael M
Everything here is really tasty (as always), from bagels to cookies to crumb cakes. My first time visiting, I was like a kid in a candy shop, I wanted a little of everything! Jen and Joey are always so kind and make great recommendations. It’s a pleasure to walk into an establishment and be greeted with smiling faces. Definitely one of the best bakeries in South Jersey!
… moreJessica Civetta
Best jelly donuts on the island! We have been coming to the bakery for years and have loved all the items we’ve had at the shop, but recently my husband found a blueberry glazed donuts (not a blueberry cake donut, but a plain donut with a special blueberry glaze). I called to ask if they’d have this specific donut and they said they should but they were a bit confused on what I was asking for. When I showed up they didn’t have it, but staff was great, super accommodating and helped us by adding some blueberry glaze onto a strawberry glazed donut and my husband said it was even better than the original! Thank you to all the staff they were great and I wish I grabbed their names to give them a special shout out!
… moreBob Stewart
Pretty expensive, but pastries are good and good variety. E.g., the crumb buns cost a lot more than at Jersey Girl, but C&C had more varieties. Also, it’s part of Bay Village so probably costs more because of all the foot traffic.
FYI, when I got home, I noticed that C&C charged a 3% surcharge for a DEBIT card. Adding a surcharge for a credit card has become common, but I believe DEBIT cards cost the business less than credit cards. It’s not a big deal, but I’d like to see some customer push-back — better signage please, and then let us decide on cash, credit, or debit.
… more