Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Old-school pizza joint since 1973 providing round Sicilian pies, creative toppings & hot sandwiches.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Crosby Pizza Stop – Bronx, NY – 1731 Crosby Ave – Hours, Menu …
At our pizzeria, you can enjoy NY-style pies, Sicilian pizza, house pizza, and gluten-free pizza, too. Also, we make pizza by the slice and exotic pizza.
Crosby Pizza Stop – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Bronx, NY! Crosby Pizza Stop is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Crosby Pizza Stop | Restaurants – NYC Tourism + Conventions
Crosby Pizza Stop. place. 1731 Crosby Ave, Bronx, NY, 10461. Description. A top contender for the hotly contested honor of “best pizza in Pelham Bay,” Crosby …
Last Updates
Reviews
Nick
Their food has always been sub par, but I decided to try a hero for old time’s sake. Boy was that a mistake. I got an eggplant hero and this thing is seriously inedible. Soggy, lukewarm, the bread falls apart when you try to grab it. This is disgusting. Never ordering from this place again. It’s like biting into a wet diaper. Stay away from this place. Go to Joe’s, for Christ.
… moreSpace Dandy
Very delicious pizza. A staple in the community. Cash and credit are both accepted. 06/2025
… moreN “Natalia Corridori” Corridori
Yummy, yummy pizza! Nice sliced pizza. Folded up perfectly. Service was super fast and very friendly. And they support their local community. Last year for our Halloween party at Pelham bay little league they treated the kids to their amazing pizza. I have been going there since.
… morePeter Esposito
We made a trip to NYC and had to go out of our way to this spot to get 2 pies for home. Best pizza ever!! Thank you guys and keep up the good work.
… moreXavier Ramos
Portion sizes are terrible for the amount of money they’re charging. $6 for a pizza barely larger than a can of soda. The slice is like the size of a single slice of domino’s for $6!!!. This is insane. Never ordering from here again and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone else who wants some value for their money.
… moreAnagalis Peralta
It’s decent pizza . Honestly I’ve been to many pizzerias and I could say that this place feels extremely peaceful and comfortable to grab a quick slice with your friends. It’s worth it’s price. It’s clean and organized. I liked the visit.
… moretherealdallas4lyfe
I have never been here but will definitely visit if I am in the area. Just saw the pizza delivery video and have to say the customer service in this shop is unparalleled in today’s time. The driver is the epitome of “cool under pressure”. God bless your business, I wish you all the success!!!
… moreZay Mayers
Best pizza I ever had in my life. It was cheesey, greasy, and fresh. I cant lie if I ever had to refer pizza it would be this place. Also, the garlic knots were divine. Thanks!
… moreB “wollyCorgi” P
Saw the video of Billy the delivery guy getting assaulted. Hope Billy and Crosby’s are blessed with plenty of business in the future. I’m definitely getting a slice whenever I’m in town!
… more