Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
The Tastes You Crave, The Quality You Trust Since 1985! At Cristy’s Pizza, we’re known for doing things the right way — starting with bold, sweet sauce from fresh vine-ripened tomatoes, our signature dough recipe, all-natural premium cheese, fresh-cut vegetables, and old world pepperoni. It’s the quality ingredients and the care our team puts into every order that sets us apart.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Cristy’s Pizza – Chillicothe, Ohio
Cristy’s Pizza in Chillicothe is all about great food, friendly service, and being part of the local community. We offer in-store pickup, fast delivery,
Cristy’s Pizza: Your Favorite Local Pizza Shop in Southeast Ohio
Order online and see for yourself! Get pizza delivered in Amanda, Baltimore, Lancaster, Circleville, Chillicothe and Logan. You deserve it!
Cristys Pizza Menu | Pizza Delivery in Southeast Ohio
Get fast delivery and mouth-watering pizzas right to your door in Amanda, Lancaster, Chillicothe, Circleville, Logan and Baltimore, Ohio.
Reviews
Rachel Lamb
Got into Chillicothe and needed some nourishment- we chose Cristy’s. This pizza is great. It is absolutely LOADED with toppings and cooked perfectly and is absolutely delicious. They were super easy to find from our hotel and ordering for pickup was simple and fast on their website. Did i mention the pizza is DELICIOUS? We got a large veggie and added pepperoni and meatballs. Will definitely order again next time we are in town.
… moreS Smith
When you order Cristy’s, but they send you Temu pizza..
Not only is the presentation bad, it IS bad. Flat oil soaked crust that didn’t rise, not cooked thoroughly in the middle. Some cheese in middle not even melted.
The manager said, That’s how it’s supposed to be”. Hahahahahah. Nah, you can have this mess back.
… moreNot only is the presentation bad, it IS bad. Flat oil soaked crust that didn’t rise, not cooked thoroughly in the middle. Some cheese in middle not even melted.
The manager said, That’s how it’s supposed to be”. Hahahahahah. Nah, you can have this mess back.
Amy Rider
Ordered for pick up today after I got off work. Was ready when I got there, and smelled amazing! Employee was super nice who handed it to me. Couldn’t wait to sit down and eat it! It was perfect! I made modifications and they were all correct. Thank you for making my dinner delicious Cristy’s Chillicothe!
… moreLuke Bistor
I was in town for a gymnastics meet and got a “take n bake”. When we pulled up to the window we were treated by a young man who was excellent! I didn’t get his name but we were there on March 23rd at 1 pm. He personally carried out my order to my car…then my wife wanted a sub so I went in and placed the order, again he found us in the parking lot out back and hand delivered our food. Take n back turned out great! Added a few picks. Thanks again!
… moreRodney Cydrus
Great service
Great pizza!
Took about 20 minutes to get my order delivered today and I was blown away.
Very friendly delivery driver.
Great place
… moreGreat pizza!
Took about 20 minutes to get my order delivered today and I was blown away.
Very friendly delivery driver.
Great place
Christopher Aills
Being a restaurant y’all do know uncooked or raw dough after warm breeds Ecoli, the wrong strain will kill someone. All it takes is a small anomaly
… moreGinn Pendergraft
The service was excellent. The food was hot and ready. I just wasn’t a fan of the sauce on the pizza it reminded me of tomato soup or SpaghettiOs. I liked the breadsticks they were very tasty. So many people in Chillicothe say this is the only pizza to eat. It just wasn’t for me. The staff was amazing and super friendly though.
… moreDonnie Scaggs
I moved to Florida 3 years ago and came back to Chillicothe for an event for my daughter. One of my priorities was to get Christie’s pizza and true to form they did not disappoint. I have had pizza in many different states and many different types and I will not hesitate to say Christie’s pizza is the best pizza on the planet. Perfect sauce perfect crust perfect toppings, just hands down the absolute best. Thank you Christies for taking pride in what you do and making my trip from Florida to Ohio that much better. You are the best PERIOD!
… moreJeff Hardwick
The sauce has tang, the pepperoni has zip, the veggies seem fresh.
I’d love to score higher but they can’t figure out what “well done” means. I’ve tried time and again but I always have to come home and air fry it for another 5-7 minutes.
I don’t get it.
Edit____
The veggie is hard to get well done because of the water content in the veggies, I get it. It’s the best veggie we’ve had BTW, so don’t change it.
The last veggie we ordered (1/2 pep for me my wife has alfagal) …was still a little soggy, better, but still wet. It still needs a good under carriage “for me” but I know that you can’t please everyone.
Tonight I got a sausage, mushroom, onion and banana pepper well done and it had plenty of char and crisp! Loved it.
Upgraded to 5⭐️
… moreI’d love to score higher but they can’t figure out what “well done” means. I’ve tried time and again but I always have to come home and air fry it for another 5-7 minutes.
I don’t get it.
Edit____
The veggie is hard to get well done because of the water content in the veggies, I get it. It’s the best veggie we’ve had BTW, so don’t change it.
The last veggie we ordered (1/2 pep for me my wife has alfagal) …was still a little soggy, better, but still wet. It still needs a good under carriage “for me” but I know that you can’t please everyone.
Tonight I got a sausage, mushroom, onion and banana pepper well done and it had plenty of char and crisp! Loved it.
Upgraded to 5⭐️
selymsteed
was told if I subscribed to for their updates i would get 20% never got it.
… more