Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5210 State Rte N, Cottleville, MO 63304
Phone: (636) 336-2488
Menu Photos
cottleville-cookies-and-cream.square.site
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cottleville Cookies and Cream: Home
Hand-dipped ice cream in the heart of Historic Cottleville, MO.
Cottleville Cookies and Cream – Facebook
. 80% recommend (253 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 5210 Hwy N, Cottleville, MO, United States, 63304 …
Cottleville Cookies and Cream (@cottlevillecookiesandcream)
1.3K+ followers · 914 posts · Old time ice cream shop in the heart of historic Cottleville. Follow our friends at @plankroadpizza …
Reviews
Kristy Godi
Cottleville Cookies and Cream is an adorable ice cream and treat shop! It was clean, whimsically decorated, and had delicious treats at a reasonable cost. My daughters and I really enjoyed it and we will definitely go back next time we’re in the area!
… moreClaudine Lee
Cute spot for ice cream, stopped by after brunch on a hot and humid day so it was perfect. They had a good selection of flavour and I got the mint chocolate and the banana pudding on a waffle cone. There was a cookie at the bottom which was a pleasant surprise. Service was quick and staff was friendly.
… moreSerge Suprun
Great find (like every other small business) in this town. Indoor and outdoor seating, great service and unique choices of ice cream, sandwiches, shakes and floats. And doggy ice cream!
… moreBrandy Jay
Cute little cottage serving Blue Bell ice cream and intense flavored shakes. Plenty of seating indoors and outside.
There is an odor inside that we couldn’t place- somwhere in between old mildew cabkn and wood stain. Hard to describe, but very offputting. Hope you have a better experience than we did stepping indoors! The ice cream did not dissappoint.
… moreThere is an odor inside that we couldn’t place- somwhere in between old mildew cabkn and wood stain. Hard to describe, but very offputting. Hope you have a better experience than we did stepping indoors! The ice cream did not dissappoint.
A Banerjee
The ambience is very nice. The place is very well appointed with both interior and outside seats. But same accolades can’t be extended to the ice cream. The ice cream is bland and tastes nothing special. We had high expectations, but very disappointed. The ice cream was not that sweet (which is good), but had no flavor too. We were expecting, for example, the vanilla bean to be at least as good as Haagen vanilla bean, but it tasted horrible. In fact we were sitting joking that the cookie dough tasted just like dough. Neither me, nor my spouse was able to finish a serving of ice cream. While we enjoyed the ambience, overall we left very disappointed. Not coming back.
… moreLauren Vague
I had such a great experience at Cookies and Cream! The ice cream was fresh, creamy, and full of flavor — exactly what you want when you’re craving something sweet. The Cookies and Cream flavor in particular was rich and perfectly balanced, with plenty of cookie chunks in every bite.
The real standout, though, was the service. Lindsay and Sierra were absolutely fantastic — warm, welcoming, and genuinely friendly. They went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect and took the time to recommend flavors without ever rushing me. You can tell they truly care about their customers and take pride in their work.
It’s rare to find a place that nails both quality and customer service, but Cookies and Cream delivers on both fronts. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreThe real standout, though, was the service. Lindsay and Sierra were absolutely fantastic — warm, welcoming, and genuinely friendly. They went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect and took the time to recommend flavors without ever rushing me. You can tell they truly care about their customers and take pride in their work.
It’s rare to find a place that nails both quality and customer service, but Cookies and Cream delivers on both fronts. I’ll definitely be coming back!
Rick “Rick’s Picks” Cooper
Rick’s Picks score 92/120
Scoop of tiger tracks
Freezer set too high. Ice cream too solid. Darn tasty
… moreScoop of tiger tracks
Freezer set too high. Ice cream too solid. Darn tasty
Samantha Tyler
Love Cottleville Cookies & Cream and the new location! However, I would love to see ice cream options that don’t have high fructose corn syrup and artificial food dyes like most of the Blue Bell flavors, which is the brand of ice cream offered here. I would definitely visit more often if the ice cream options had cleaner ingredients.
… moreSteve White
Ice cream shake was good but did taste a little like melted ice cream in a cup. Price was not bad. Wish there were a few more options. The overall atmosphere was very nice.
… moreChrista Dennis
The #shop was rustic, and #clean. We felt bad for the young #lady working alone but even with the ice cream rush, her #service was kind, not rushed and we got exactly what we had ordered promptly. The #bathrooms were adorable, well stocked and #clean. The #ambiance both inside and out gave small #town_country_vibes and was so #relaxing. The in #house made ice cream was the best I’ve ever had. I ordered #Fudge_Brownie with #M&M’s and it was delicious. Their in #house made #waffle_cones were to die for. The #hint of #cinnamon and the soft crunch cone tasted as if we were #eating #fried_ice_cream. I would #eat here again daily if I could if they could only figure a way to not include calorie lol Great #place to go with #friends or family. Highly recommend. Love that they have indoor and outdoor seating
… more