Jake Kozlowski
Cottage Inn saved my Super Bowl. Stopped in for my wife’s pizza pickup and had them throw wings on the order too. Had the wings out ASAP, after I had to cancel my wing order at another nearby place that fell way behind on pickup times.
Cottage Inn’s wings a large and awesome.
Their pizzas are great!
… moreBrian Masserman
I was hired to photograph some of this pizzeria/tavern’s dishes today.
Owner Sam was wonderful to work with. As you can see from these pictures, his pastas and pizzas and breadsticks are fresh and delish. I loved the oven roasted wings! The cheese and sauce on the pizza has the right mixture of tomatoey and gooey happiness. When Covid is over, feel free to saddle up at his bar. Very cozy and a great selection of beers. I highly recommend this establishment
… moreColette Fodera
Only ordered tonight because Jet’s was closed for renovations. Hardly any pep on this pie. Service for pick up was mediocre at best. Jet’s can’t open soon enough
… moreCamron Priebe
This is ridiculous, every time I order here there’s something wrong I ordered garlic butter crust on all 3 of the pizzas (of course non of them had it)! Then I got a large ham pineapple and 2 slices had nothing on it! What is going on with your quality control? Jeez. Then the large Hawaiian pizza i got (toppings were supposed to be pineapple, ham and bacon) and the bacon was just on 2 pieces. then on the large BLT pizza I got the lettuce was brown! We took the lettuce off and had to put our lettuce on!. It’s just sad that every time I order here I feel like I’m just throwing money out. Who ever owns this place needs to work with there lazy employees. This location has good potential but needs to work on quality. This is just ridiculous.
… moreSam S
Perfect bake and decent flavor. Thanks NH CI!
Food: …
… moreJaclyn TeterFit
Let us get gluten free with a coupon because my daughter’s friend has celiac disease! It was so sweet of them!!
… moreLinda Gabbert
While I have not as of yet been inside of this pizzeria zi can tell by the person whom has answered the phone that he is a very pleasant to be around. And also the delivery persons have all been very nice and helpful.
… moreShannon Koch
Our family ordered 3 large pizzas from Cottage Inn and not a single pizza was made correctly. We should have known it would be incorrect as we had this happen a few months ago as well. The first time it happened we gave them the benefit of the doubt and figured maybe someone was training or having a bad day. However, knowing that this had happened previously, I had 2 other adults double-check my order to make such I put it in correctly before placing it. Between toppings missing (which we pay for), topping being on wrong pizza, and flavored crust not being done (no cost, but should not offer if you are not going to do it) our family will not be returning for pizza at Cottage Inn.
… moreMichael Jarasz
I have never had a pizza from a pizza place that made me think it was a frozen digiorno pizza until today. This doesn’t pass for Cottage Inn and we were really disappointed in the pizza we ordered tonight. We ordered 4 toppings and it was half bare and unevenly topped. As if that wasn’t enough, half of the pizza had no cheese on it while the other half got all of the cheese. On top of that the crust was dry and overcooked. Maybe it was whoever was working tonight, but I would be apprehensive to try this location again.
… moreBenjapol Piyawanichpong
One star off for my first impression that the food came quite slow despite i am only by myself and does not seems to be that vusy. But food and pizza (thin crispy crust) is the best i think.
… more