Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Costella’s Italian Restaurant and Market (214 39th Ave SW)
From any restaurant in Puyallup • From tacos to Titos, textbooks to MacBooks, Postmates is the app that delivers – anything from anywhere, in minutes.
Costella’s Italian Restaurant and Market (214 39th Ave SW)
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Costella’s Italian Restaurant and Market (214 39th Ave SW) in Puyallup. Browse the menu, view popular items, …
Costella’s (@costellasitalianrestaurant) · Puyallup, WA – Instagram
70 followers · 23 posts · Costella’s Italian Restaurant and Market was born out of a passion for Italy and its food.
Reviews
Karly Burmark
Very chic little place. Modern meets old world quality. Very nice wine selection and fancy food dishes. The quality of the food is sooooo fresh! Only thing I didn’t like was the very small glass wine pours, seems about half a regular glass pour honestly, so I would reccomend just getting a bottle instead. The Italian chardonnay is crisp and delightfully smooth with great flavor. I had the house salad appetizer-highly reccomend- superb light vinagarette, side of angel hair pasta and chefs choice of pasta that day- a gnocchi with Bolognese. The gnocchi was so light and fluffy and perfectly dressed on both pastas I am so giddy! Fair prices for good quality. I really like this place alot! Would be perfect for a first date or casual business dinner or just anytime.
… moresarah cook
Randomly found this Puyallup gem and so glad I did. The food was all very fresh and tasty. The outdoor patio was the perfect spot for our evening meal and we enjoyed the whole experience. The wait staff was extremely pleasant and we felt welcome as soon as we entered the establishment. Will be back again to try more of the menu but loved the shrimp cavatelli- a perfect combo of creamy but with a nice kick at the end & the chicken Marsala was another favorite. A perfect dinner out.
… moreShad Kerr
Very good food, and the service was friendly. I’m glad this place is here. Their food is house-made, and it was fantastic. My wife took me here for my birthday; we’ll definitely be back.
… moreStormy Guerra
This is our favorite restaurant in Puyallup! The food is fresh, delicious and authentic. My husband and I have been 4 times so far, and from the stuffed mushrooms, charcuterie board, calamari to the mushroom risotto or lasagna or fettuccine, we loved everything we’ve tried. Not only is the food so so good, but the service has always been top notch. We can’t wait to go back!
… moreJames Etherington
I want to be forgiving during what is likely a very hard time for restaurants, so I am ignoring the overstretched staff in my review.
We ordered the truffle cheesy bread, a Caesar salad, ravioli, and chef’s special (a spicy sauce Bolognese). The food was tasty, but not knock your socks off.
The cheesy bread felt like they bought cheesy bread from papa John’s and put truffles on it. It looked the same, it tasted the same. The marinara accompanying it had melted cheese, but the marinara wasn’t hot enough to actually melt the cheese, and it formed a protective layer on the top. The bread was light and fluffy, which was nice.
The ravioli was very tasty, but a little slimy and the bowl was full of oil.
The chef’s special was actually very flavorful and had a good amount of meat. The spice was the perfect level and added a ton of flavor. I’m not sure why this isn’t on the menu full time.
The Caesar was very good, and the croutons truly made the dish. I would definitely get this every time. I can’t tell if the dressing is homemade, but it doesn’t really made, as it was one of the better caesars I’ve had. But I would have liked a bit more.
The iced tea was a chai tea, which was different, and the Italian soda could have used a bit more cream.
All in all, the interior setup and decor was fantastic, with comfortable seating and good colors. A nice bar I can’t wait to sit at someday, and a cool Italian “market” setup to grab things and take them home. And they had Dean-o and other famous Italian singers crooning in the background.
… moreWe ordered the truffle cheesy bread, a Caesar salad, ravioli, and chef’s special (a spicy sauce Bolognese). The food was tasty, but not knock your socks off.
The cheesy bread felt like they bought cheesy bread from papa John’s and put truffles on it. It looked the same, it tasted the same. The marinara accompanying it had melted cheese, but the marinara wasn’t hot enough to actually melt the cheese, and it formed a protective layer on the top. The bread was light and fluffy, which was nice.
The ravioli was very tasty, but a little slimy and the bowl was full of oil.
The chef’s special was actually very flavorful and had a good amount of meat. The spice was the perfect level and added a ton of flavor. I’m not sure why this isn’t on the menu full time.
The Caesar was very good, and the croutons truly made the dish. I would definitely get this every time. I can’t tell if the dressing is homemade, but it doesn’t really made, as it was one of the better caesars I’ve had. But I would have liked a bit more.
The iced tea was a chai tea, which was different, and the Italian soda could have used a bit more cream.
All in all, the interior setup and decor was fantastic, with comfortable seating and good colors. A nice bar I can’t wait to sit at someday, and a cool Italian “market” setup to grab things and take them home. And they had Dean-o and other famous Italian singers crooning in the background.
Jenerfer O
OMG! This is my new Italian fave! The food is unique and delicious. The wine selection is awesome.
… moreMichael Dietrich
Almost 150 reviews, and 5 stars doesn’t come easy from me…A really relaxing atmosphere, amazing food. The only place for Italian in Puyallup. Definitely will be back….again and again
… moreTom Wilde
A truly special place. As soon as you walk in you feel welcome. The atmosphere is relaxing and the true Italian food is unlike anything you’ll find in the area. Enjoy custom cocktails and fine Italian wines while you listen to live music and shop the market. Go check them out soon. You won’t be disappointed. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreL Diaz
Decided to have a mother and daughter lunch date here, and the moment we walked in, we were quickly greeted and seated. Our waitress was wonderful. I didn’t know what to order, just wanted something light, and I explained that to her and she helped me create a pasta dish that was exactly what I was looking for. Kid’s menu options are great as well. Simple, and delicious. Loved the wine selection. Looking forward to family dinners there soon.
… moreIvan
Wow! I thought that this place sounded good from the other reviews – but it was exceptional. I ordered the special. The chicken was as moist as any I’ve had anywhere in the world (I’ve been to over 60 countries and lived in 8 and I’m a complete foodie) and the pasta was perfectly cooked. My friends all loved their food too. If I lived here I’d be eating here every week. This is a hidden gem.
… more