Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Coney I-Lander, a Tulsa tradition since 1926, features craveable, award-winning coneys made with grilled wieners in perfectly steamed buns, covered in Coney I-Lander’s world-famous, secret family recipe chili, mustard, onions, and cheese. Take a culinary trip down memory lane that will remind you of simpler days. We are open for lunch and dinner every day at our seven locations in Green County and look forward to seeing you in-store or for delivery!
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 901 N 9th St, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Phone: (918) 251-1242
Website: https://www.coneyi-lander.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Coney I-Lander | Tulsa Tradition since 1926 in OK
Coney I-Lander, a Tulsa tradition since 1926, features craveable, award-winning coneys made with grilled wieners in perfectly steamed buns, covered in Coney …
Coney I-Lander | Broken Arrow OK – Facebook
Coney I-Lander, Broken Arrow. 976 likes · 3819 were here. Since 1926, we haven’t changed a bite. Coneys, Tamales, Frito Pies & 3-Way Chili.
Coney I-Lander Delivery Menu | 901 N 9th St Broken Arrow – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Coney I-Lander in Broken Arrow! View Coney I-Lander’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Last Updates
Reviews
Shane Reed
The Coney’s are Delicious as Always. I’m very impressed that it’s still open and doing great! It was my Aunt Louise and her Husband Olen’s favorite place. Coney I-Lander is the Best! Coney’s, Cheese Coney’s, Frito Pies, Loaded Baked Potatoes, Tamales, Family Recipe Bowl of Chili and Potato Chips. A Tulsa and Broken Arrow Oklahoma Tradition since 1926 A.D. I highly recommend that if you are ever in the area to stop by and try it.
… moreGregory Olson
This place was definitely a favorite of mine. I’m from Louisiana and never had anything quite like this. The chili was unique and very delicious. The hotdogs and buns were exactly what I wanted. My son got the tamales and they were good too. Not a traditional tamale, it was over-steamed and topped with their signature chili. It was its own dish. My wife got the chili 3 ways, which was served over what looked like long macaroni noodles. All unique and delicious. Great spot to grab a meal that will stick to you. Seems like great food after a long night out. Employees were nice and helpful!
… moreJoshua
5 out of 5 for what it is. And what is it? Dogs and chili. Prices are great and you can eat for a few bucks or cater a birthday party or Corp lunch for cheap and plentiful deals.
Food is always good at this location. I love the small buns that fit the dogs perfect and then the house made dogs are so tasty! Loaded with house made chili, diced onions, and finaly some fine shredded cheese with a taste of mustard underneath.
Atmosphere was fun. Went through the drive through and the guy manning the Com was funny and had a voice that only fits him. Once we pulled up he and thr others were joking and working hard at thr same time.
… moreFood is always good at this location. I love the small buns that fit the dogs perfect and then the house made dogs are so tasty! Loaded with house made chili, diced onions, and finaly some fine shredded cheese with a taste of mustard underneath.
Atmosphere was fun. Went through the drive through and the guy manning the Com was funny and had a voice that only fits him. Once we pulled up he and thr others were joking and working hard at thr same time.
Ryan Brandt
After a long day of work and then a prolonged visit at the Urgent Care (a sprained wrist for me, a migraine for my fiancée), most places were closing up. We were hungry for chili and Coney-I-Lander was still open.
I’ve eaten here plenty, always liked it, but it was the first time for my gal. We were starving, our orders were taken promptly, but they were having issues… so they brought our coneys out later while we ate our chips.
When the coneys came out, we devoured them. Soon after the general manager came out, wanted our names to comp us our coneys on our next visit… as she explained the buns weren’t steamed as they usually are and wanted to make right.
Frankly, I hadn’t really noticed (I was SUPER STARVING at this point) and it was like twenty minutes till they closed, so couldn’t blame them anyway so close to quitting time (their steamer was on the fritz, btw).
But this kind gesture towards us, and the tasty food, is why I’m giving them five stars.
She didn’t have to do that, but I appreciate it nevertheless.
… moreI’ve eaten here plenty, always liked it, but it was the first time for my gal. We were starving, our orders were taken promptly, but they were having issues… so they brought our coneys out later while we ate our chips.
When the coneys came out, we devoured them. Soon after the general manager came out, wanted our names to comp us our coneys on our next visit… as she explained the buns weren’t steamed as they usually are and wanted to make right.
Frankly, I hadn’t really noticed (I was SUPER STARVING at this point) and it was like twenty minutes till they closed, so couldn’t blame them anyway so close to quitting time (their steamer was on the fritz, btw).
But this kind gesture towards us, and the tasty food, is why I’m giving them five stars.
She didn’t have to do that, but I appreciate it nevertheless.
Heath Craker
Ordered a cheese frito pie and could only get a couple bites down before I had to throw it away. Chili was terrible. My wife got the same thing and she couldn’t eat it either. The lobby was not clean (food all over the floor, tables, and seats). I had to wipe down a table so we could sit as all of them had food bits on them. Service was fine, but that is the first and last time I will visit here.
… moreAmber
COMPLETE waste of money. Ordered 7 coneys and every single one of them was not made correctly. I asked for no mustard. Not that hard. They made every single one of them with mustard and no onions. I can’t eat a single coney I spent money on. Very upset. I doordashed the order because it was more convenient for my schedule today. The young girl that answered the phone did not apologize once and told me I needed to go in and bring them my receipt before they could do anything. Very upset. I do not have time to go up there so I guess I just threw away money today instead of eating.
… moreZachary Fiddler
About 6 workers or so back there behind the counter and it takes forever to get one of them to take my order.and the older lady behind the counter with a blue shirt on needs to work on her tone if shes going to serve people she had a very sharp disrespectful tone to my vet grandpa when all he asked was how much are they a piece.and when they finally did take my order they just threw them together as fast as they can with barely what I asked for on the hotdog, if they are gonna raise there price like they did they could at least give decent service, it seemed like none of them wanted to be working there.
… moreDaniel
Love the Coney Islander experience. Great food and excellent customer service at a competitive price.
… moreTom Stewart
Like a reliable friend. Coneys were good and served before we paid. They were quick off the grill. Loaded and yummy!
… moreToedt Chris (Author Chris Toedt)
I’ve been eating Coney Island since the 1950’s back at the original location downtown when Christ Economu was always behind the counter cranking out $0.10 Coneys, no cheese Coneys back then.
Still the same great Chili
… moreStill the same great Chili