Indulge in the essence of Italy at Colonna’s Pizza! Since 1977, our cherished family-owned restaurant has elevated New York style pizza, hearty pasta, and other authentic Italian delights to new heights. Using the finest ingredients and generations of tradition, our dishes will transport you to culinary heaven. From mouthwatering salads to sizzling hot heroes, calzones, and stromboli, we infuse each creation with timeless Italian inspiration. Join us for an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you exclaiming ‘Bellissimo!’.
Relaxed joint offering NY-style slices & pies, Philly cheesesteaks & other casual Italian favorites.
Lisa Smith
This location is conveniently located in a shopping center with plenty of parking. We ordered online and went to go pick up the pizza. Everybody was really nice. The pizza was extremely hot and fresh on smelling the pizza. We decided that we should order some garlic knots and probably get some of the fresh gelato Which was definitely not a mistake. We got a large pineapple and jalapeño pizza the jalapeños refresh and not canned so they had a nice little spice to them. The pineapple was nice and tasty as well. I know not everybody likes pineapple on their pizza but if you haven’t tried the pineapple jalapeño pizza It’s delicious. The garlic knots are the best ever we had the ones with cheese. I’m sure the ones without are good as well. You could taste the fresh garlic, chopped into the knots. We got the chocolate gelato and it was extremely tasty nice and smooth and a very rich chocolatey flavor. The service there is very nice. Everybody was professional sweet and helpful 10 out of 10. Recommend this location, especially if you’re looking for a fresh pizza that doesn’t taste like a frozen or something that’s been sitting around for a long time. Everything is hot and fresh and made to order. They do have indoor seating but we chose to take it home. They have outdoor seating as well and this is a Christian company. I love that they have scriptures posted outside as well as on their pizza box. I will definitely be coming back and updating my review to let you know how it was for a second time.
… moreRaul Morales
This is far the best pizza I’ve ever had,
Very traditional, all ingredients are top quality.. it took me back to ITALIA 🙂 or EAST COAST. ♥️
Must try the half pineapple with ham and half spicy jalapeño pizza.
For deserts try a homemade cannoli
Very well done guys
… moreAmanda Perdue
This is the first time ordering from here and I will never do it again. The amount of grease from the pizza is unbelievable! The top and bottom was so disturbing with the amount of grease. I know pizza is a greasy food but I’ve never seen anything like this before. It soaked 10 paper towels from the top and the bottom of the pizza soaked all the way through the box with grease. The manager was nice and gave me a refund when I called but this is going straight into the garbage!
… moreA D
The space is utilized well here. There are booths and regular tables, and the restaurant feels bigger than it is. Loved the Blues Brothers figures located near the door. Pizza was good and service was timely. I would bring visitors here if I have some in the near future.
… moreSUSAN BURNSIDE
Didn’t eat in the restaurant but we have called for take out several times. The pizza is outstanding! Really great crust and ingredients. The first choice for us now. Excited to try different items on the menu. Great service also. Gelato amazing!
… moreCameron Miller
Colonna’s Pizza is a fantastic local spot. The pizza was delicious with a perfectly crisp crust, great toppings, and not greasy at all. The cheese was outstanding, and the cheese garlic knots were excellent as well. My son had a kids’ cheese slice and loved it. Prices are affordable, the service was great, and the overall experience was excellent. Highly recommend if you’re looking for quality local pizza.
… moreKhyla
We were super hyped to try Colonna’s after seeing all the great reviews and a TikTok post about it. The customer service and environment were definitely great, but the food itself was a big letdown. Everything felt slapped together, lacking flavor, and didn’t stay true to what it claimed to be.
My Philly cheesesteak was basically just ground beef with sliced cheese melted on top—no flavor, no structure, just a very sloppy sandwich. My husband’s pizza was the same story—you could tell the toppings were just thrown on with no real care or love for the craft.
Overall, we left really underwhelmed and wishing the food lived up to the hype. Sorry
… moreY’Anique Duke
I ordered 5 extra large pies for a youth football team and a personal gluten free pie for myself.
I picked up the pies, and unfortunately I didn’t get the gentleman’s name, but the service was amazing. The pizza was delicious and the kids loved it. I also loved the gluten free pie, so much so, I will probably take the long drive from Broomfield just to have it again.
As a native New Yorker, I was really impressed.
… moreDoug Dillmuth
I’ve had their large pizza before and it was good, but the XL was life changing. I think they use the large dough ball and stretch it further to make the XL and it comes out as one of the best versions of authentic NY pizza I have found in Colorado. You’ll notice the owner and family tossing pizza. Not some kid that doesn’t care. You’ll also notice authentic pizza ovens which beat the brakes off conveyer belt pizza ovens. Great service, great family place. First responder and military friendly.
… moreMarla B
I have been wanting to try Colonnas and was in the area. As I walked up for lunch, this huge sign greeted me. A clear sign that they don’t want my money. It is a private business, so it is certainly the right to advertise their moral and religious beliefs and I have the right to spend my money elsewhere. Which is what I did.
… more