Todd Knisley
Kinda locally famous for pizza, and now with a rejuvenated dine-in operation. I personally find the pizza to be unnecessarily thick and heavy. Not thick like East of Chicago, just lots of dough, thick.
The meatballs were good, but the pasta sauce missed the mark on our spaghetti (on the bitter side). The portion of spaghetti was huge and came with a well executed salad.
If you like Coccia – they are back for more than carryout!
… moreGary Sutton
First time here, caught it just right since they just opened the dining area back up after 6 years.
The pizza was very good, thick dough (a little more than i like, but good, solid piece of pizza) great sauce, toppings, and the cheese, WOW!
… moreJ C
Dined in for the first time in years, was seated right away. Off to a great start, Wrong! Had better meals at the fair. Service was absolutely terrible, waited over a hour to get our meatball subs. Waitress forgot to put our order in, then ignored us. Meatball subs had 2 meatballs each that were cut in half to make a full bland sandwich. $38.54 for 2 teas and 2 horrible sandwiches. So basically, $40 for 4 meatballs. What a deal. Never got our pizza because it was another 45 minutes. $0 tip for zero transparency and service. Very disappointing and will never go back. Giving 1 star is way too much!
… moreKeith Hommer
I see alot of local, newer reviews not so happy. Read the website, its updated. Dinning area is closed. No joke on rhe phone orders. It’s a thick heavy pizza. I got the pepperoni and sausage. It came half cooked so you bring it home and finish cooking it. It was $20.50 It is so heavy because of the amount of meat that was on it. I found it very thick and delicious. I got a good one apparently. Hard to get one pizza to please all the pie holes that eat it. The grass they give you to put on it is tasty too. Try it!!
… moreRonald Jarvis
This is the hands down best pizza I have ever had anywhere. I’ve been around but I also, coincidentally, grew up on Coccia. Local legend. People move away and have friends friends ship it. Total cult. If you have never had it, try it. Completely unique.
… moreLinda Morosko
Great atmosphere. Clearly a favorite of the locals. Went for my son’s birthday. A place he likes. He and my hubby loved the pizza. I did not. The crust on my pizza was hard and dry. Not appetizing. They had many other dishes in the menu. Next time, I’ll try one of those.
… moreWoodrow Smith
This pizza was so worth the 45 minute drive. Only disappointment was the dining room was closed. It was so delicious. So cheesy and the sauce was amazing!!! We will definitely go back for more.
… moreLE
Let me first say I love Coccia pizza. But finding a toothpick buried inside my pizza and ultimately not discovering it until it was it my mouth is inexcusable and dangerous! I have a picture to post, but it’s not giving me that option.
Please do better!!
… moreTrevor Bannavong
Stopped by for a late night dinner. Pizza was great and staff was very friendly. Prices were fair and they offer free refills on soft drinks. They also serve crafty beers and good wines.
The setting and feel of the restaurant feels very warm and cozy. Definitely will be coming to eat in more often.
… moreLil Darby
My family was told how great the pizza we were excited to try it unfortunately it was a little disappointing. Probably won’t be ordering it again.
… more