Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Take out
… View more
Catch a little taste of the beach life with every slice… try our key lime pie – handmade in small batches, with love! Local to Sussex County, Delaware? Check out our website for retail locations that sell our key lime pies – or stop by our new food truck next to the PetSmart in Rehoboth Beach! Not close by? No worries – we now ship our pies right to your doorstep using dry ice and one-day UPS shipping. Check out our website to order your key lime pie today! Coastal Key Lime Pie is a small, family-owned business located in Sussex County, Delaware. We take pride in serving our fresh, handmade key lime pies to our local community – and, shipped right to your door!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 19563 Coastal Hwy Parking Lot, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971
Phone: (302) 727-8868
Website: https://www.coastalkeylimepie.com/collections/pre-order
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Coastal Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pies, handmade with love. Fresh, locally crafted, and bursting with zesty flavor. A slice of coastal delight awaits you!
Local Pickup – Rehoboth Beach, DE – Coastal Key Lime Pie
Come out and visit us at our new food truck! January & February Hours: Friday’s and Saturday’s 12:00 PM to 5:00 PM Pre-orders are not required, …
Coastal Key Lime Pie | Rehoboth Beach DE – Facebook
⬇️ Coastal Key Lime Pie Food Truck: 19563 Coastal Hwy, Rehoboth (in the food truck parking lot next to PetSmart), open Fri-Sat 12-5PM ️ Find Coastal Key Lime …
Last Updates
Reviews
Joseph O
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
If you’re anywhere near Sussex County, do yourself a favor and try this Coastal Key Lime Pie — it is absolutely phenomenal! You can truly taste that it’s handmade with love from the very first bite. The balance of tart and sweet is perfect, with that bright, refreshing key lime flavor that’s bold but not overpowering.Thanks
… moreIf you’re anywhere near Sussex County, do yourself a favor and try this Coastal Key Lime Pie — it is absolutely phenomenal! You can truly taste that it’s handmade with love from the very first bite. The balance of tart and sweet is perfect, with that bright, refreshing key lime flavor that’s bold but not overpowering.Thanks
Ellen Buckwalter
I bake A LOT. And I generally think what I bake is better than anything I get anywhere. This Key Lime pie is simply phenomenal! I have made Key Lime pie before, and it is NOWHERE near this good. Going back to buy 2 pies-one for myself and one for my Key Lime pie loving friend! If you like Key Lime pie, you absolutely MUST give this a try.
… morePolly Boyd
Picked up two pies for Thanksgiving. Easy to thaw–you would never know they were ever frozen. Beautiful looking pie, the key lime is delicious, it was perfectly tart and the crust is amazing!
… moreRebecca Edel
There’s no bad time for Key Lime Pie!!
Amazing! From the tartness of the lime to the coconut accent in the crust, *chefs kiss
I will absolutely be back!
If you love Key Lime Pie, you need to go see these lovely people!
#philly-rehoboth
… moreAmazing! From the tartness of the lime to the coconut accent in the crust, *chefs kiss
I will absolutely be back!
If you love Key Lime Pie, you need to go see these lovely people!
#philly-rehoboth
Katerine Tsolakis
I’m writing this review because this company truly deserves it. Not only do they have the best key lime pie I’ve ever had, but their customer service is absolutely unmatched. They went above and beyond even staying open later than they needed to just for me. That level of care and dedication shows how much they value their customers and take pride in their business.
… moreKakaruchi “kakaruchi”
First off when I pulled up they were still in the process of opening. The owner said sorry bout that here’s a free slice on the house. It was still frozen. I ate it on the way back to the hotel. It was delicious. Came back the next day when they were open and brought two slices. One to share with others. They loved it. The plan was to buy a whole pie on the way home but with everything going on totally forgot. I was pissed. Now back in Philly not a week goes buy that I’m not thinking about their pie and kicking myself for not getting to grab a whole pie on the way home. People U gotta buy this pie it’s so delicious especially if u like Key Lime pie. U wont regret it. Hopefully I’ll be able to make this a tradition every time I come down. Please help me make this happen. Buy this pie
… moreCassidy K
Key lime is my favorite kind of pie, and Coastal Key Lime is the BEST! Delicious pies made with quality ingredients, friendly owners, and fun treats like chocolate covered pie slices. You can tell it’s a business that cares about their customers and providing them with a great product.
… moreStephanie L
My Dad purchased one of your pies for my moms birthday and it was the BEST key lime Ive had- sooo good 🙂
… moreE
The key lime pie is absolutely amazing! I just bought a whole pie and I love it! Authentic key lime pie, great quality ingredients, and wonderful husband and wife team! I highly recommend this gem of a place.
… moreKevin Larkin
The pie was good not great as expected having paid $32. I knew the price before I bought it so caveat emptor, but if it was worthy of the $32 I would buy it again. So it’s not the price but the value received for the price. Not “limey” enough and a very thick crust. I’m not complaining just sharing my thoughts.
… more