Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Authentic Italian-American Sandwich Institution! From our legendary cold subs like the Sinatra and Godfather to our mouth-watering toasted creations featuring Nonnie’s hand-rolled meatballs, we bring authentic Italian – American flavors to every sandwich. Don’t miss our loaded fries, fresh salads, and specialty bowls!
Wood-fired pizzas & breads earn raves at this stylish American spot offering gluten-free options.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 100 Seneca St, Geneva, NY 14456
Phone: (315) 828-2028
Website: http://www.cjsonseneca.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
CJ’S Sandwich Institution
CJ’S Sandwich Institution – Authentic Italian-American gourmet sandwiches and specialty dishes in Geneva, NY.
CJS | Geneva NY – Facebook
CJS, Geneva. 1547 likes · 47 talking about this · 96 were here. CJ’s Sandwich Institution Cranking out killer sandwiches daily 11:30–9 (closed…
CJ’S Sandwich Institution | Geneva, NY – Visit Finger Lakes
Serving up bold, Italian-inspired subs and local flavor in the heart of downtown Geneva. · 100 Seneca St Geneva, NY 14456 · (315) 828-2028.
Reviews
fran II
Food was good, cheese burger sub on fuchsia with garlic butter toasted! OMFG!! DELICIOUS.
The vodka chicken sub***** 5 star! Great!!
Mac salad* 1 star. I was assuming “homemade type taste” nope… tasted like walmart Mac salad. No flavor. Price a little heavy but not to bad.
… moreThe vodka chicken sub***** 5 star! Great!!
Mac salad* 1 star. I was assuming “homemade type taste” nope… tasted like walmart Mac salad. No flavor. Price a little heavy but not to bad.
Geoffrey Hellauer Geiger
I originally thought this was going to be a deli since I knew the menu was very sandwich forward. So I was a little surprised at first to see a more traditional sports bar / bistro type establishment. No matter however! Just an initial surprise.
Ordered to go – Godfather and Chopped Cheese. First I balked at the price tag $19 per sandwich approx. Holy cow because you get your money’s worth! Huge sandwiches with loads of filling and flavor. Definitely worth the splurge with plenty of leftovers.
The Chopped Cheese had fresh beef taste with onions, relish type burger sauce, and plenty of cheese. Just being nitpicky, I’d want more of a blanket of cheese versus incorporated. But it was creamy, sour, savory, everything. All at once. The roll was too soft, but again being nitpicky. Still five stars.
Highly recommend.
… moreOrdered to go – Godfather and Chopped Cheese. First I balked at the price tag $19 per sandwich approx. Holy cow because you get your money’s worth! Huge sandwiches with loads of filling and flavor. Definitely worth the splurge with plenty of leftovers.
The Chopped Cheese had fresh beef taste with onions, relish type burger sauce, and plenty of cheese. Just being nitpicky, I’d want more of a blanket of cheese versus incorporated. But it was creamy, sour, savory, everything. All at once. The roll was too soft, but again being nitpicky. Still five stars.
Highly recommend.
Jaclyn Chelenza
First time ordering here. We had been meaning to try it for the last few weeks. We were originally told 20 mins for a carryout order but ultimately waited 40 minutes total. Not a huge deal but you’d expect food to be ready when you’re provided a pickup time.
$40 later for 2 carryout sandwiches, I couldn’t even eat my chicken parm sub. The chicken was unfortunately left in the fryer too long or something because it was hard and very dark.
Hubby and I tried to switch meals but he couldnt eat it either. Luckily the sandwiches are big enough to share so we each had half of his sub.
His sub was very good but he noted how half the sub had loads of meat while the other half didnt seem to have much. Again, not a huge deal, you could manually “fix” it. However, for a $20 sub, you shouldn’t have to “doctor it up”.
We did end up calling and the guy who answered was apologetic and provided us with a gift card, which was very appreciated.
We will try this place again as it could have been an off night.
I loved the foil wrap around the subs. Kept my order hot. The sticker on the wrap is a nice personal touch as well as the carryout bag itself. Branding is done well.
Looking forward to revising my review and increasing “stars” upon our next visit.
Thank you!
… more$40 later for 2 carryout sandwiches, I couldn’t even eat my chicken parm sub. The chicken was unfortunately left in the fryer too long or something because it was hard and very dark.
Hubby and I tried to switch meals but he couldnt eat it either. Luckily the sandwiches are big enough to share so we each had half of his sub.
His sub was very good but he noted how half the sub had loads of meat while the other half didnt seem to have much. Again, not a huge deal, you could manually “fix” it. However, for a $20 sub, you shouldn’t have to “doctor it up”.
We did end up calling and the guy who answered was apologetic and provided us with a gift card, which was very appreciated.
We will try this place again as it could have been an off night.
I loved the foil wrap around the subs. Kept my order hot. The sticker on the wrap is a nice personal touch as well as the carryout bag itself. Branding is done well.
Looking forward to revising my review and increasing “stars” upon our next visit.
Thank you!
Melissa Shaw
Wow, go CJ’s! My friends and I met at CJs for the Buffalo Bills game and we had an awesome time. Although the Bills (barely) lost we felt like we won. The food was top-notch! Everyone at the table raved about their sandwiches. Our server , Suhaily was friendly, fast and fabulous. Even with a big crowd she made sure everyone had great service. The restaurant was clean and seating was comfortable. We’ll be back, thanks Suhaily
Ps sorry no pic, I was having too much fun
… morePs sorry no pic, I was having too much fun
Sal Genovesi
Not a Deli, but a Sandwich Bar/Restaurant. A unique idea and delicious food. The sandwiches are huge, the small size is plenty for most people.
… moreStephanie Allen
Upstate NYers know and need a good sandwich and this has become our favorite spot for guaranteed perfection. The variety of options for not only sandwiches but loaded fries and tots with a few other options (tom/cuc salad was super yum), the quality of the ingredients and how everything is crafted, the staff is skilled and extremely accommodating – it’s all just honestly unbeatable. The price point is honestly so impressive for the amount of food you get. We go out of our way to make this stop because there’s nothing we want more than to see this establishment succeed for a very long time!
… moreJeannie DeRider
Checking out a new place to eat in Geneva! So many hot and cold specialty subs and sandwiches! and lots of Fries options and salads too! Beer and Soda options, and the Beer loads through the bottom of the glass! So cool! Leaving you with a full belly and a cool magnet sealing the glass bottom that you can keep to put on your fridge at home! ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ Would highly recommend to check them out! We had 2 full hot subs along with the Mac n’ Tots that comes with a vodka sauce shooter to dress up your tots with a little more yum!!
… moreDavid Klehn
Ordered on door dash it was 45 dollars for one sandwich and an order of plain fry’s. One bite of the sandwich and I immediately wrapped it up to hand deliver into my trash. The fry’s tasted like reheated McDonald’s fry’s with no salt.
… moreHannah M
A great date night restaurant. A little on the pricier side, but usually the food is worth it. I recently had the crab cake appetizer and was not a fan- they were a little dry and not very flavorful, but that is the first meal I’ve had there that wasn’t great. Their pastas are amazing, pizza is incredible, and desserts are to die for.
… moreFinanceGirl Toronto
We were pleasantly surprised with this restaurant. Good quality food and excellent service. The pizza and bread was excellent. Okay e weren’t a fan of the bacon wrapped shrimp but could just be our taste buds . Overall a great find in the area and will visit again.
… more