Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Cinquino’s Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria proudly serving the community with what many call the Best pizza in Batavia NY. We believe great pizza starts with quality, which is why we make fresh dough and homemade sauce daily using time-tested recipes. Our menu features something for everyone, including delicious pizza, wings, pasta, and subs, all made with care and attention to detail. Whether you’re feeding the family, hosting a game-day party, or grabbing a quick bite, Cinquino’s Pizza delivers bold flavors, generous portions, and friendly hometown service. Stop in or order today and taste the difference that passion and tradition make.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 314 Ellicott St, Batavia, NY 14020
Phone: (585) 343-2447
Website: https://cinquinospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cinquino’s Pizza | Best Pizza in Batavia NY
A proud family-owned and operated pizzeria dedicated to delivering a consistent and mouthwatering dining experience.
Cinquino’s Pizza | Batavia NY – Facebook
Crispy. Golden. Made to Order. Our Hand Battered Chicken Fingers are the real deal! Perfect for lunch, dinner, or when that comfort food craving hits! Stop …
Cinquino’s Pizza – Batavia, NY | MenuGuide
Cinquino’s Pizza · Six Wings $7.49. Served with celery and blue cheese. · Single Wings $14.99. 12 wings. · Double Wings $26.99. 24 wings. · Triple Wings $37.99.
Last Updates
Reviews
Thaddeus Kuntz
We stopped at Cinquino’s on our way through Batavia tonight and had an excellent dinner experience.
They have a large corner table that fit our party of 11 plus a baby with room to spare.
We ordered the full sheet pizza with mushroom. It was nice and thick, and very tasty. All 11 of us barely finished the 32 slices.
We left a good tip and the total (with tip) was just over $40. Service was quick and helpful, good atmosphere, and the food was excellent. This made a phenomenal option for eating out with a larger group.
… moreThey have a large corner table that fit our party of 11 plus a baby with room to spare.
We ordered the full sheet pizza with mushroom. It was nice and thick, and very tasty. All 11 of us barely finished the 32 slices.
We left a good tip and the total (with tip) was just over $40. Service was quick and helpful, good atmosphere, and the food was excellent. This made a phenomenal option for eating out with a larger group.
Melvin Rosario
Excellent service, homemade food, is a family pizzeria with established clients, if you are driving around Batavia this is highly recommended
… moreDiane Lewis
My husband and I love coming here and we always bring our friends with us. It’s been coming our Sunday ritual after Church. Great food. Our little server who just got engaged is amazing and the food is always awesome. My husband loves the calzones
… moreD Love
What a treat! My friend Mary Anne brought me here today! I was visiting to attend the Bills game on Sunday! The food was amazing, service from Angie was awesome, and they were super nice to my pug to boot! Thanks for the warm welcome and the great experience! Go Bills!
… moreJoe Bradt
One of my favorite lunch stops! It’s hard to find a place that can turn a lunch around quick so you can get back to work… not only do they do that, they do it with a smile EVERY time! Can’t get a better chicken finger ANYWHERE.
… moreHeather GawNeulikhaus
Lunch specials meals! Available here!
We went in st 1pm and ordered two wraps and frie specials. One was chicken finger and the other was a BLT. Some of the staff was pleasant, the one who took my order look annoyed that we walked in, but we did have a TV to watch while waiting for our food. We received our food at 1:25 pm. Food is great and our wraps were delivered to our table by another staff member who was very pleasant!
… moreWe went in st 1pm and ordered two wraps and frie specials. One was chicken finger and the other was a BLT. Some of the staff was pleasant, the one who took my order look annoyed that we walked in, but we did have a TV to watch while waiting for our food. We received our food at 1:25 pm. Food is great and our wraps were delivered to our table by another staff member who was very pleasant!
Tomas Maybach
Love this place and it’s consistent quality.
Small pizza, kids spaghetti both delivered hot, and Garden side salad was cold and crisp.
Had it delivered. Very Happy. Support the local business Woman! Go here!
… moreSmall pizza, kids spaghetti both delivered hot, and Garden side salad was cold and crisp.
Had it delivered. Very Happy. Support the local business Woman! Go here!
Alexa Smart
Consistent food, especially the salads, which always have fresh ingredients. The fried dough I ordered was overcooked and uneatable, but maybe it was the employee, who was on the fry line, just didn’t care for his job. I walked in to place an order for take out (not at a busy time) the manager was on it right away, but I will think twice to eating in with friends, as I never heard such language from one the employees, very loud and unprofessional.
… moreerick lindberg
Pizza was unfortunately undercooked. The dough was still partially uncooked. The guy at the counter didn’t seem to care about the customer. I gave it a second shot and experienced the same.
I wish I could give a better review without being dishonest.
… moreI wish I could give a better review without being dishonest.
mallory bumpers
DELIVERS TO AREA51 MOTOCROSS TRACK!!!!!
(Sorry for the caps lock, just want other riders and their families to see that we have an option)
We are not locals to the area. We ride Motocross at the local track. We have never found a pizzeria that will deliver to the specific address. However! That changed this weekend. The pizza and wings were EXCEPTIONAL. I said extra crispy, extra saucy on the wings, and man did they follow the instructions!
We will DEFINITELY be ordering from here again at the next event! I ordered online, and it said 75 min. Which is fine. The food was hot, and right on point.
The delivery driver was super awesome to my husband, and was pleased to say that The track was now in there delivery radius.
Thank you again fir the great food, prompt service and awesome driver!
… more(Sorry for the caps lock, just want other riders and their families to see that we have an option)
We are not locals to the area. We ride Motocross at the local track. We have never found a pizzeria that will deliver to the specific address. However! That changed this weekend. The pizza and wings were EXCEPTIONAL. I said extra crispy, extra saucy on the wings, and man did they follow the instructions!
We will DEFINITELY be ordering from here again at the next event! I ordered online, and it said 75 min. Which is fine. The food was hot, and right on point.
The delivery driver was super awesome to my husband, and was pleased to say that The track was now in there delivery radius.
Thank you again fir the great food, prompt service and awesome driver!