Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Easygoing, enduring hangout with pizza & other typical bar fare, plus a full bar & outdoor seats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7466 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45255
Phone: (513) 407-6818
Website: https://cincinnatigoodfellows.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cincinnati Goodfellows: Home
Come find us in the Anderson Towne Center in Anderson Township, Ohio. You’ll just have to come to find out for yourself why Goodfellow’s is Cincinnati’s number …
Cincinnati’s Goodfellows | Cincinnati OH – Facebook
In the Anderson Towne Center, family owned and run. Established in 1987. Sports * Pizza * Spirits
Goodfellows, 7466 Beechmont Ave, Unit 412, Cincinnati … – MapQuest
Goodfellows is an Italian-inspired pizzeria and bar located in the Anderson Towne Center of Anderson Township, Ohio. Known as Cincinnati’s number-one …
Reviews
Evan Duckworth
Love this place! We came in kind of late on a Saturday night and the owner made sure we got a table. He also said the first round was on him because it took him so long to get to us. They were packed it wasn’t his fault.
Pizza was amazing and the beer selection was great. Will definitely come back.
… morePizza was amazing and the beer selection was great. Will definitely come back.
Cruisin 4 Jesus
We went here for my wife’s Birthday we had such a Great time…Owner is Kyle very very nice man. The food is Fresh and is Amazing… I look forward to going back again.
3-13-22 I tried the pizza this week Fantastic… My Favorite place now…
Not a fan 🙁
So, I went to this place on 8-24-25, and I’m not sure if it was just me, but the food wasn’t quite the same. The ingredients were different, and the overall experience was just okay. We had a group of 7 people, and we tried a bunch of different appetizers and meals. Unfortunately, no one was really impressed with the food. That’s why we gave it 3 stars.
… more3-13-22 I tried the pizza this week Fantastic… My Favorite place now…
Not a fan 🙁
So, I went to this place on 8-24-25, and I’m not sure if it was just me, but the food wasn’t quite the same. The ingredients were different, and the overall experience was just okay. We had a group of 7 people, and we tried a bunch of different appetizers and meals. Unfortunately, no one was really impressed with the food. That’s why we gave it 3 stars.
Taylor Rein (Tay)
We have been here a million times before and have always had a great experience. Service has been a little slow before though but that’s really it..tonight we came in around 6 pm. There were only maybe 4 other tables in the entire place. We sat there at our table for 30 minutes with several servers walking past our table and we weren’t acknowledged at all, not even eye contact from any of them. There is no excuse for that ever and i don’t think we will be back.
… moreDe’Asia Diamond
We had the Bbq Chicken with grippos!!! I love the spin they did on it. I’m a Cincinnati native and I love what they did with the grippos, baby rays bbq and the dough was perfect, not too thin nor too thick. 10/10. Oh and the wings were just as good !!!! Hot honey wasn’t my favorite but I’m glad the sauces come on the side.
… morenopath
I ordered food and a draft at the bar. 45 mins later I was asked if I had ordered food. It was packed to go and had been sitting for about 20 mins. That is a service issue but now the fries and bread were soggy. So I ate at the bar out of the to-go boxes
The sub was great, classic Italian with wonderful dressing on the side. The “Schriber Calzone” was also great. Good crust and generous fillings. Fries were inedible through.
… moreThe sub was great, classic Italian with wonderful dressing on the side. The “Schriber Calzone” was also great. Good crust and generous fillings. Fries were inedible through.
Z goose
Ok for the category. Sports bar with a good menu. Service was good. The waiter was busy but managed to check in with us and get the food delivered in a timely manner. The food was ok. We had the pepperoni chips which were burned too much, the cheese pizza which was standard, and the Italian beef which was super dried out with very little au jus. We like Good Fellas but will probably not return to this location.
… moreLong Legged One
Nestled in Cincinatti it looks on a few town lines, this place is a classic gem. I got the classic cheese pizza 16 in for $16. The pizza is done Omaha style as it resembled that as well as east coast style pizza and have not had flat Chicago style all that often as id just get deep dish if i was getting that. Id say the way it’s cut up is Omaha style. This pizza is on the level of the best pizza cities. If there’s any pizza better, people pay expensive transportation to go there and eat them and wait a long time so all things considered, it’s worth it just to come to a place like this if they’re around you. Servers are great in there, you can tell they take pride in their business. Bathrooms on opposite sides however..
… moreDarrell Hugueley
We visited Good Fellows on a slow Saturday afternoon, our first visit. Started off on an iffy note, as there was no one to greet and seat us. After a couple of minutes I got the attention of the bartender and she told us to sit wherever we wanted.
W seated ourselves at a high table for four against the wall. All the walls were covered with sports and gangster movie memorabilia. I counted over 25 TV screens, all featuring golf, baseball, or the prelims for an upcoming UFC event.
The menu is extensive, featuring plenty of craft, import, and traditional beers. They have an awesome, fully stocked bar with great bourbon and scotch selections. They have Coke products and tea as well.
We ordered a twelve-inch, three ingredient pizza. There were some yummy appetizers we wanted to try, but that’ll be for another visit. The hand tossed crust on the pizza was crispy on the bottom and chewy, with a good bready texture, held up its integrity for the length of our visit. I ordered a Guinness on draft, always a pleasure to find as more and more bars seem to have it only in cans. That is simply not done.
We were tempted by the menu description to order the cinnamon sticks for dessert, little more than thin pizza crust with butter and sugar and cinnamon, served with a thick icing on the side. But, v testament to the quality of the pizza crust, these were very tasty.
They have sports bar hours, which are very late on weekends. The menu features sandwiches and subs, salad, pasta, a burger, and baked wings, with some gluten free options and vegan choices here and there (a cauliflower crust for a $2 upcharge, for instance).
Visit Good Fellows and enjoy some great food.
… moreW seated ourselves at a high table for four against the wall. All the walls were covered with sports and gangster movie memorabilia. I counted over 25 TV screens, all featuring golf, baseball, or the prelims for an upcoming UFC event.
The menu is extensive, featuring plenty of craft, import, and traditional beers. They have an awesome, fully stocked bar with great bourbon and scotch selections. They have Coke products and tea as well.
We ordered a twelve-inch, three ingredient pizza. There were some yummy appetizers we wanted to try, but that’ll be for another visit. The hand tossed crust on the pizza was crispy on the bottom and chewy, with a good bready texture, held up its integrity for the length of our visit. I ordered a Guinness on draft, always a pleasure to find as more and more bars seem to have it only in cans. That is simply not done.
We were tempted by the menu description to order the cinnamon sticks for dessert, little more than thin pizza crust with butter and sugar and cinnamon, served with a thick icing on the side. But, v testament to the quality of the pizza crust, these were very tasty.
They have sports bar hours, which are very late on weekends. The menu features sandwiches and subs, salad, pasta, a burger, and baked wings, with some gluten free options and vegan choices here and there (a cauliflower crust for a $2 upcharge, for instance).
Visit Good Fellows and enjoy some great food.
Alyssa Moore
We order the pep balls which were good. They came out in a pool of garlic butter, but luckily weren’t soggy. We ordered a large pizza, 1/2 specialty and 1/2 with pepperoni and feta. Pizza was good, but very greasy which I didnt mind, but isn’t everyone’s cup of tea. Service was quick and good with one exception which is more of a business issue than the server herself.
The way they charged for the pizza was deceiving and unreasonable in my opinion. We were charged the price for a full specialty pizza and then on top of that, $2.50 per topping for the other half. $2.50 is the price for additional topping for a whole pizza. When I asked the server about it, she said it was just the way she was taught to ring it in. At a minimum, it should be noted that the extra charges apply like this, but it is honestly just unfair pricing.
… moreThe way they charged for the pizza was deceiving and unreasonable in my opinion. We were charged the price for a full specialty pizza and then on top of that, $2.50 per topping for the other half. $2.50 is the price for additional topping for a whole pizza. When I asked the server about it, she said it was just the way she was taught to ring it in. At a minimum, it should be noted that the extra charges apply like this, but it is honestly just unfair pricing.
Elizabeth
Came in a few minutes after opening midweek. Waitress was prompt. Started out with garlic bread and deviled eggs, both came within minutes. Bread was excellent, eggs were fine but had a mustard based filling (I prefer mayonnaise.) Next we ordered The Goodfellow and Louie’s Love with no banana peppers (pictured below!) Both were super tasty.
… more