Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Christiana Pizza Co., we take pride in serving our customers delicious food made with the freshest ingredients. Our menu offers a wide range of options featuring the highest quality products. Whether you’re indulging in our homemade lasagne or sticking with a classic pepperoni pie, we can guarantee your dish will be full of flavor. Located at 16 Gay Street, where Sicilian-style pizza, hearty pasta dishes, wings, and Italian favorites are served with love. Enjoy bold, oven-baked flavors crafted fresh and served with hometown pride.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 16 Gay St, Christiana, PA 17509
Phone: (717) 588-8133
Website: https://christianapizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Christiana Pizza Co – Christiana, PA – 16 Gay St – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 16 Gay St, Christiana, PA 1750916 Gay St, Christiana, PA 17509; (717) 588-8133.
Christiana Pizza Co – View Menu & Order Online – 16 Gay St … – Slice
Christiana Pizza Co · Christiana Pizza Co – View Menu & Order Online – 16 Gay St, Christiana, PA 17509 – Slice.
Christiana Pizza Company | Christiana PA – Facebook
Everything is made fresh and ready for you. Stop by, call in your order, or order online and start the weekend the right way. 7175888133 www.
Last Updates
Reviews
Annie Taylor
We ordered a hoagie tray for a family gathering over the holidays. It was absolutely fantastic! The bread was very fresh, the meat and cheese were generous and high quality. Each hoagie was perfectly made and packed with flavor. It was a huge hit with everyone and disappeared fast. Great value and great portions. The staff at Christiana Pizza are very friendly and we love that it is family owned and operated. We’ll definitely be ordering this again!
… moreLauren Benigni
Used to be great… now not so much. Order is always messed up or wrong. I ordered a Caesar salad wrap with a side of cbr fries… and a second order of the wrap but with reg fries and honey mustard. And one Diet Coke.
What I got. 2 diet cokes, 2 wraps with just lettuce and one burnt chicken. Regular fries. No honey mustard but Caesar to dip my fries in…. The guy on the phone even repeated my order correctly to me. Not sure how but I also got cbr full size fries and paid for it all.. $50 for this plus things I didn’t order…. This is not the first time we’ve had issues. Usually we are able to get the correct order made. At this point I didn’t even call I’m finished ordering from here. I miss how it was when they opened.
… moreWhat I got. 2 diet cokes, 2 wraps with just lettuce and one burnt chicken. Regular fries. No honey mustard but Caesar to dip my fries in…. The guy on the phone even repeated my order correctly to me. Not sure how but I also got cbr full size fries and paid for it all.. $50 for this plus things I didn’t order…. This is not the first time we’ve had issues. Usually we are able to get the correct order made. At this point I didn’t even call I’m finished ordering from here. I miss how it was when they opened.
Gabriel Burgos
Walked in after church service nearby, the young lady at the register was kind and polite. As I waited I could see the man (sorry for not knowing your name) making the pizza fresh! After handing me the food the man was extremely kind and thanked me for coming in. I brought the pizza home to my wife and kids, we all LOVED it. Absolutely will be back again. Sometimes, all it takes is one sentence or a smile to lift someone’s spirits, so I thank you guys for doing that for me today! Highly recommend this place.
Sincerely, Gabriel (the tattooed guy with the beard lol)
… moreSincerely, Gabriel (the tattooed guy with the beard lol)
Ed Heaton
Three time now they messed up our orders and this time was the last straw. The whole pizza crust was burnt I smelled it as soon as it was handed to me so I know the chef had to know it was burnt. I really wanted to like this place since it is so close to home but sadly I’m done with Christiana Pizza Co…
… moreGabby _93
I ordered over the phone for pick up, the food was ready when I got there. But over the phone I asked for a cheesesteak and red sauce on the side, along with onion rings. When I got home and opened the bag there were fries along with the cheesesteak, I had never asked for the fries because they cost extra. The breading on the cheesesteak was disgusting. It tasted hard & stale and was like a jaw work out to be able to chew it up…along with that, my fries were cold and soggy and the onion rings were severely overcooked and crunchy and very greasy. I paid $24 for a cheesesteak, onion rings, and fries I didn’t ask for, nor I wanted to pay extra for. Along with all this, there was no red sauce on the side like I asked for. I was there within 10 minutes after ordering and it was obvious nothing was made fresh. I am very local and it disappoints me that I cannot order from my local pizza shop like I could when Pasquale’s was there. Many of my other family member have also said how the food here is terrible and is very inconsistent. I will not be ordering from this place again.
… moreC WR
The folks that work here are nice. Over the last, 6-8 months the quality of food has gone down. I know a good bit of people will not eat here because the pizza is consistently undercooked. 10 times out of 10 times the dough will look like the dough in my picture. Would love for it to get better again because it is nice having a spot in town.
**UPDATE** 3 weeks after the original review, I gave them another try. It seems they went thinner on the crust, but still a large portion of the crust remains undercooked/doughy(see additonal photo). I will just have to drive a few minutes down the road and get properly prepared pizza at the pizza box.
… more**UPDATE** 3 weeks after the original review, I gave them another try. It seems they went thinner on the crust, but still a large portion of the crust remains undercooked/doughy(see additonal photo). I will just have to drive a few minutes down the road and get properly prepared pizza at the pizza box.
Melissa Gregor
We ordered here for takeout as a last minute dinner idea – we used to order with the previous owners as Berevillos & Pasquale’s. The lady who took our order did not listen and the order was repeated multiple times, we still ended up with a cheese steak sub and raw onions (not what we asked for, and clarified after she asked). The buffalo wings were ok. We also did not ask for fries & realized you get them but at an extra cost. We may try again in the future in hopes that we get the correct order and not upcharged for fries we didn’t ask for. Roll soggy falling apart. I hope all of these reviews help them sort it out, I’d love to see them thrive!
… moreBrynn Devine
We always stop on the way to do our laundry, we love they’re meal deal, 2 slices and a can of soda for $5.99
… moreRobert Conn
The pizza tasted good. The only issue I had was the service. We were dining in – I prepaid and gave a 20% tip. We were dining in so we went outside for a few minutes when we were waiting and came back and sat down. Our pizza was ready and the person sat down the pizza in a box (which is odd because we were dining in) and handed me two paper plates and one set of plastic fork/spoon. Dining in with a pizza box on the table and paper plates seems for lack of better words; underwhelming. We never had anyone ask us how the food was. Never asked us if we needed anything. Soon as the food was put on the glass counter top, staff went to back and were huddled up talking in the back. Do not get me wrong, everybody was extremely nice. Again food was good, but service was lackluster. For sitting down to eat, not sure I would return.
… moreteddye park
Oh my goodness, the Hoagie and fried Ravioli were DELICIOUS! Thank you for the awesome service and delicious food! Delivery was quick and courteous! Thank You!
… more