Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Relaxed waterfront venue with a view for full-service dining, cocktails, Sunday brunch & drag shows.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782
Phone: (631) 597-7859
Website: http://cherrysonthebay.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cherry’s on the bay
Welcome to Cherry’s on the Bay and Cherry Lane Cafe … Eat, Drink, Dance and be Cherry! Cherry’s on the bay. 158 Bayview Walk Cherry Grove, New York, 11782.
Cherry’s On The Bay & Cherry Lane Cafe (@cherrysonthebay)
7.7K+ followers · 291 posts · Drink, Eat, Dance, & Be Cherry ️ Hot nightlife, epic entertainment, and delicious dining on Fire Island… ONLY at Cherry’s …
Cherrys On The Bay & Cherry Lane Restaurant & Bar – Facebook
Cherrys On The Bay & Cherry Lane Restaurant & Bar is at Cherry Grove, Fire Island, NY. Jan 12 . …
Reviews
Sierra Cleveland
We came for the drag brunch. With our reservation we were seated immediately but left wondering where our server was for almost 30 minutes. No one even so much as glanced at us until we asked someone if they would take our order. The waiter came and told us he didn’t know he was assigned to our table. The service was fine after that though.
The food and drinks were terrible. We ordered the breakfast sandwich and the cheese was not even melted. The croissant was not toasted and the egg patty was very thick in some parts and thin in other parts. There was no sauce for the sandwich. The potatoes were the only redeeming part. All of the frozen drinks we had (Mudslide, Cherry bomb, and Rocket Fuel) tasted like there was no alcohol in it, and we did not feel even the slightest bit tipsy from it. The drinks were also really expensive especially considering how they barely had any alcohol in it which was disappointing. However the espresso martini was potent and delicious.
The performers were the only redeeming part of this experience. They were lively, dramatic, and so much fun. I cannot speak more highly of the performers and the show!
… moreThe food and drinks were terrible. We ordered the breakfast sandwich and the cheese was not even melted. The croissant was not toasted and the egg patty was very thick in some parts and thin in other parts. There was no sauce for the sandwich. The potatoes were the only redeeming part. All of the frozen drinks we had (Mudslide, Cherry bomb, and Rocket Fuel) tasted like there was no alcohol in it, and we did not feel even the slightest bit tipsy from it. The drinks were also really expensive especially considering how they barely had any alcohol in it which was disappointing. However the espresso martini was potent and delicious.
The performers were the only redeeming part of this experience. They were lively, dramatic, and so much fun. I cannot speak more highly of the performers and the show!
Miguel Ruiz
My favorite place to get cocktails on Fire Island and the food is always good.
… moreC B
This is for the restaurant/food only. We sat upstairs with a great view of the pier and perfect time to see the sunset. But the food definitely didn’t add to the experience. We ordered a piña colada to start and it didn’t have any alcohol. The server graciously offered to have it remade, the second one was a little better. I also ordered a ginger ale it was flat and tasted watered down. The food took a while to come out but the atmosphere made up for it. Keep in mind there is a loud bar very close by but we enjoyed the music. I had the fish and chips which were of course from frozen, there were two tiny pieces on top of a basket of fries. It was barely edible. The pasta was a decent portion and cooked well . The servers were nice but the overall service was slow. The prices are high and I would only go back to eat if I had no other options. There are 3 other restaurants around and they all have mixed reviews . I rather get a slice of pizza or go to Sand Castle and pay extra for slightly better food.
… moreDani D
Fun spot on the water. I didn’t eat here-just drinks and dancing. The dj was good and the drinks were good-except out last order they messed up and gave us vodka tonics instead of vodka seltzers. It’s so busy we couldn’t correct. They also don’t let you bring in your beach bag so be prepared. I will go back for more fun!
… moreAva M
Didn’t eat here but my girlfriend and I went for drinks and drag brunch. Genuinely one of the most fun times I’ve ever had. The drinks were good, bartenders were attentive, and the drag queens put on an amazing show. They are so talented. Came back later for another show and it was less crowded but just as good!! Can’t wait to come back someday soon.
… moreNumbahz
Cherry’s on the Bay go during a Drag show or a weekend night, and you’ll have a blast. I can promise dollar for dollar its amazing ! It’s a required life experience if your coming to F.I. and the best part is you can feel the vibe outside before you go spend your $$$s inside
… moreSky Thai
One of the highlights in the Cherry Grove neighborhoods. It’s right off the dock where the water taxis and ferries drop people off so it’s hard to miss. They have simple bar food, but are known for their frozen drinks. Definitely try out the CH-CH-CHHERRY BOMB!
I really enjoyed their Bloody Mary too. They have a Wasabi Sesame rim which is unique and really good! Not too spicy either, but enough of a kick to light that fire.
They have drag shows on the weekends too! We came on Sunday and got to catch a show. Note: there is a minimum spend to sit at the bar during this time, but standing is free.
… moreI really enjoyed their Bloody Mary too. They have a Wasabi Sesame rim which is unique and really good! Not too spicy either, but enough of a kick to light that fire.
They have drag shows on the weekends too! We came on Sunday and got to catch a show. Note: there is a minimum spend to sit at the bar during this time, but standing is free.
Sergii Starostin
This place is a very gay place in summer. You combine a drug performance at night with the food. Take burger, chicken dinner or chicken palliard – you will not be disappointed
… moreLe Si
The stars are for the bartenders!! Always great service from them!
Definitely did not expect a Queen to tell a woman in our group that they would “crack that chair over her head” simply because she was standing in an area that was supposedly off-limits, at the BAR (no signage or any sort of blocked off area) and next thing we know she was being aggressively scolded. Previously, the group was standing in another area and were told to move to the area we ended up in, because apparently that section was off-limits too? A large group of us were planning to stay and see the 9 PM assassin show, but felt very put off by the way the situation was dealt with and spent the rest of the night at the other bars. Such a shame to treat members of the community that are showing up and spending money to see them with such hostility and aggression.
… moreDefinitely did not expect a Queen to tell a woman in our group that they would “crack that chair over her head” simply because she was standing in an area that was supposedly off-limits, at the BAR (no signage or any sort of blocked off area) and next thing we know she was being aggressively scolded. Previously, the group was standing in another area and were told to move to the area we ended up in, because apparently that section was off-limits too? A large group of us were planning to stay and see the 9 PM assassin show, but felt very put off by the way the situation was dealt with and spent the rest of the night at the other bars. Such a shame to treat members of the community that are showing up and spending money to see them with such hostility and aggression.
Nilda “Esther” Nassauer
After relaxing on the beach for an hour or so; we decided to take a walk to Cherry grove. We met two 4 legged cuties from Rochester and hit it off with our waiter. The breeze off the water was great so we ordered seasoned fries and a few drinks.
… more