Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
This classic pizzeria, open late, also boasts an extensive menu of gyros, wings, calzones & heroes.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Phone: (212) 662-5223
Website: https://www.cheesypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cheesy Pizza NYC’s Menu
Cheesy Pizza NYC’s at 2640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 official menu and online ordering.
Cheesy Pizza – New York, NY – 2640 Broadway – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 10:30 AM-1:30 AM; Shop address is 2640 Broadway, New York, NY 100252640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025; (212) 662-5223.
Cheesy Pizza: HOME
2640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 … Bring Cheesy Pizza to You. From office lunches to family celebrations, let us bring the flavor. Our catering menu is …
Reviews
Manas
I come here pretty often for tres leches because they used to be pretty good. One time a while ago, I went to get it, it had clearly gone bad. The milk was bad. And as I saw it, I told the cashier. He and the guy making the pizza told me it was not, and so I asked if I could have another one, they refused. I tried it, it was indeed bad, so I just threw out the tres leches. I will attach the picture of it.
Yesterday, I went back because I thought maybe they had a bad day with storage. Told the guy there about my last experience and he said he was sorry, and offered 50% off on the tres leches I was buying. I declined and said it’s okay, I’ll pay for the whole thing because I didn’t want to seem like I was making things up for a discount. The thing tasted fine, something tasted off but not bad. Hours later me and the friend I shared it with ended up throwing up. We learned that it was the tres leches that made us vomit because perhaps the milk was bad again. Now I’m just scared to go back again or eat from there.
… moreYesterday, I went back because I thought maybe they had a bad day with storage. Told the guy there about my last experience and he said he was sorry, and offered 50% off on the tres leches I was buying. I declined and said it’s okay, I’ll pay for the whole thing because I didn’t want to seem like I was making things up for a discount. The thing tasted fine, something tasted off but not bad. Hours later me and the friend I shared it with ended up throwing up. We learned that it was the tres leches that made us vomit because perhaps the milk was bad again. Now I’m just scared to go back again or eat from there.
JAMES A PIERCE III
I’m really sad because I nostalgically ordered from Cheesy Pizza because they were my favorite pizza spot in the Upper West Side. Not only was my pizza terrible, I’m pretty sure it was a grocery store Frozen Pizza. Also, the GrubHub delivery person delivered my pizza at my door on the ground. Photo below. I’m so disappointed. ☹️
… moreiRome2Grub’nPub
It’s standard. Sometimes, you want and need standard.
Pros:
beef patty (and by that, I mean they serve it)
the biggest dining area in the hood w/AC
cheap slice
they got ice cream
open late
wings are an option…
feels kind of dirty
Con:
< quality than the top end slice spots
thicker more doughy slices
the AC can be weak on super hot days
feels kind of dirty
To summarize:
It’s the late night, don’t wanna wait in line, something cheaper, need to sit down and chill inside because it’s an oven/arctic cold outside- spot
… morePros:
beef patty (and by that, I mean they serve it)
the biggest dining area in the hood w/AC
cheap slice
they got ice cream
open late
wings are an option…
feels kind of dirty
Con:
< quality than the top end slice spots
thicker more doughy slices
the AC can be weak on super hot days
feels kind of dirty
To summarize:
It’s the late night, don’t wanna wait in line, something cheaper, need to sit down and chill inside because it’s an oven/arctic cold outside- spot
Ash
2 cheese slices with a soda that comes with it was $8 not bad. I loved that they had monster there too . One of the best slices in the area. I will bring my family here it was really good.
… moreAlexis Boucouvalas
The best pizza I’ve ever had without question. Excellent crust, not to thick and a bit of a crunch. I got the Grandma Vodka slice that had vodka sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
… moreMabeli Pujols
Wide variety. Good price and good food. The only thing that I can complain about it not having a bathroom for customers and the place was a bit messy even tho they didn’t have any other customers when I was there.
… morePAY-O MATTEO
Came here for lunch at 12 noon and can’t get a fresh slice of plain pizza. To want 4 or 5 bucks for day old slices of pizza , is criminal. Nothing pisses me off more than passing off stale over priced pizza.. I would avoid this place if you want fresh pizza.
… moreKirsten M
Great stop for a slice. I favor this place over others as the pizza is fresh and you can tell it hasn’t been sitting out and slices are large. Great customer service, very friendly. Will stop in again for a slice, soon.
… moreWhite Weezy
I’ve regularly ordered from this establishment for months with no complaints. Today I ordered a lasagna for my father for his 62nd birthday to find a piece of rolled up plastic found inside. This is disgusting and puts all customers at risk. DO NOT EAT HERE
… moreEleanor Wall
Service was super friendly, pizza was SO DELICIOUS! Loved the old school vibes and happiness at Cheesy Pizza!
… more