Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Cattleman’s Steakhouse (@cattlemanssteakhouseny) · Sidney, NY
Signature craft cocktails, lunch/dinner/late night bar menu Sidney, NY. Photo by Cattleman’s Steakhouse on February 22, 2023. To keep our employees as well …
Cattleman’s Steakhouse and Lounge – CLOSED, 66 Main St, Sidney …
Get more information for Cattleman’s Steakhouse and Lounge in Sidney, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Cattlemans Steakhouse, 66 Main St, Sidney, NY 13838, US
Cattleman’s Steakhouse in Sidney, NY, is a cozy pizzeria known for its delicious blend of classic Italian flavors and hearty steakhouse offerings.
Reviews
COWBOY CIRCUS with Danny Grant!
THIS RESTAURANT IS AWESOME!
Showed up late one evening for a drink at the bar and while talking to some other guests, the owner heard I was hungry so he went and had his chef grill me a steak and shrimp combo!
Really great food, great bartenders and staff and a super cool vibe for Sidney, NY.
… moreShowed up late one evening for a drink at the bar and while talking to some other guests, the owner heard I was hungry so he went and had his chef grill me a steak and shrimp combo!
Really great food, great bartenders and staff and a super cool vibe for Sidney, NY.
Tracy Thompson-Mack
Our reservation were for a little later in the evening so we did miss out on the Prime Rib but our food was good. Restaurant was clean and inviting. Our server Alexandria (I think that’s her name) was awesome. Polite, answered all of our questions. And she joked with us and I think we all had a great time. Will return in the future.
… moreAmber Hodge
Went here for Father’s day today. My husband and I love getting the delmonico steak. We usually get it with the shrimp skewers added, but they ran out of them today… onion petals were bland. Ranch dressing was mostly mayonnaise and very thick. I ended up sending my steak back and not eating my meal. Steak was very chewy and was not cooked correctly. had a nice talk with the manager who listened to my concerns and took the steak off my bill. We will return in the future to hopefully an improvement .
… moreantoinette toni munno
The Prime Rib dinner was delish. Everything had great flavor. Staff was very friendly and on hand.
… moreAmy Jones
The boom boom chicken sandwich was amazing and the chocolate cake was delicious. Service was excellent.
… moreNicole Barker
Their wings were by far the best we’ve had in a long time would 100% go solely for the wings but if you do that you would miss out on the even better steak offerings. Friday and Saturday Prime Rib was delicious and the Rib eye was just as good. Cooked to each of our tastes perfectly. Alexis our server was really sweet and accommodating! Appetizers to sides were great, this restaurant is really a gem.
… moreLEMA FAMILY
Nov 1, 2022: What’s the deal with this place? Hard to find them open. Closed, again, today. From 3 Stars to 1. April 2021: The food itself was very good. We had a full rack of ribs. Tender and tasty. French fries were great, crispy. We also had salads and everything appeared to be fresh. We also had pasta with red sauce. This was just okay. Not a lot of flavoring in the red sauce. The environment is okay. A little more social distancing at this time would probably be beneficial. We were seated at a table right next to the back door. That table should be removed. The service was a little haphazard. We had to keep asking for basic things like silverware, plates, and extra napkins with the ribs. The lack of a better rating is due to the social distancing and the service. But we’ll be back. And this review will be updated.
… moreTerry Schmierer
Had dinner out with my husband, daughter and sister in law. Dinner was great, but with one exception, my husband order appetizer the calamari, but it did look like he got really small pieces, and kinda over fried. The prime rib were excellent and so good . The service was great as well, our server Allison was always checking with us to see everything was good. She was full of energy, always smiling, yes we could tell under her mask. .Would diffinaty recommend The Cattlemen. We also met the owner which was a pleasure to meet. Thank you for a nice evening with our family.
… moreBrian Bancroft
The food was excellent. The server Glenn did a fantastic job ensuring we had plenty to drink and eat. Very polite. Atmosphere was great. Enjoyed the mix of older and newer country music. We had a party of 8 and they accommodated us without difficulty. No waiting for our table. Right on time with our reservation.
… moreJoe Gehl
Stopped in there for a quick lunch during the week. There was only two other customers at booths and two people at the bar. It took a few minutes to be greeted/seated. We decided to order the soup and lunch special Chicken bacon wrap to keep it simple. My wife said maybe she’ll just share some since she really wanted just the soup. The waitresses was rude with her response in the way she said then there will be a plate charge but didn’t know how much. Our soup arrived and it was delicious. We did not see the waitresses for over 30 minutes and then she appeared an said it shoukd be right out. About 20 minutes later she still hadn’t served us. So we asked for the warp to go as we had to get back to work. It was clear that either she forgot to put the order in or the cook disappeared. The owner walked in to check on the guy painting and it must have realized there was a problem. When its a slow day there’s no reason for extremely slow service.
… more