Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547
Phone: (914) 528-1000
Website: http://catanias-pizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Mohegan Lake, NY | Catania’s Pizza | Pizza near me
We’re located at 1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, right in the heart of the community. Join us for a casual meal indoors or relax outside with your dog …
Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Mohegan Lake, NY! Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive …
Catania’s Pizza Online Menu | Best Pizza in Mohegan Lake
Dressings: raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, thousand island, creamy Italian, bleu cheese, house balsamic vinaigrette, Italian, French. Mixed Green Garden Salad.
Reviews
Joanne Merola
We had food delivered. Ordering was a breeze. A nice thing is that you earn points each order & reach 1000 and you can get an appetizer like mozzie sticks and others. We ordered pizza, a meatball wedge and a meatball calzone. The calzone is great but I’ve never seen a calzone like this. Crispy outside and all meatball (anf delicious) inside. The pizza we ordered was a Sicilian with pepperoni and fresh garlic. The price for the garlic add-on was the same price as the pepperoni add-on which to me makes no sense. Charging the same amount for each topping Is odd, think of the markup on the garlic! But, yet the Sicilian dough was light and airy and the cheese didn’t slide off in a big blob. They delivered quickly. Definitely recommended.
… moreJessi James
Very cute atmosphere love the lights outside! I had the buffalo pizza and the chicken francese over penne- it was delicious! Fast kind service and can’t beat the price! Good music inside as well love the vibes
… moreregina hulse
We have been to Catania’s twice now in the past week. The first time, we had pizza. It was delicious! Tonight, we had a chicken parm dinner, Cajun chicken over cheese tortellini, and pasta with meat sauce. Everything was fantastic! We greatly enjoyed our meals. The owners are nice guys. We will definitely be back.
… moreDeshaun Davis
The pizza was pretty good. The garlic bread could have had more garlic and cooked longer but the experience was definitely good being it was my first time there. I know my son loved it.
… moreN
Never had a bad experience until today 11/5/25 around 3pm (check ur cameras) I was the only one inside I can tell no manger or supervisor wasn’t around just workers 2 ladies having their meals and the one worker by himself (photo) he told me “can you wait few mins and I am busy alone” I’m like okay I can wait (when a worker says that I understand u know but) I was waiting for 5-10 mins then I noticed hiding in the corner on his phone watching a show or movie obviously he forgot about me I was sitting where he saw me and I get up and I told him can I order now or I still have to wait he said “oh I forgot” I wanted to leave so bad but I was hungry I said “u told me to wait so I did but you lied to me so I want to order please” I made it obvious I was upset and he didn’t apologize nor anything I left the store around 3:18-3:19pm
Next time I’ll leave if it happens again
… moreNext time I’ll leave if it happens again
Adam Giambattista
Don’t sleep on their amazing pizza too! The sausage and rabe rolls are amazing too! All the empanadas are amazing, but if you’re not sure, ask Donnie behind the counter! Thank you!
… moreAmelia Gallagher
Amazing food service and staff. Best cookies around ! The skateboards at 2nd Nature loved all the food .
… moreMagdeline Pena
Catania’s used to be one of my families favorite place to go to and about a week ago we ordered a pie and it wasn’t as good as before, today we decided to give it a second chance and the pizza was very salty. Called the pizzeria and explained that for some reason it was salty, hoping that they could remake it and all they said was “our sauce is not salty”.
Never going back again.
… moreNever going back again.
Michael Sutton
Used to be solid, not sure what happened but it’s been going downhill for a while! Should be ashamed of the “calzone”, it’s basically an empanada, really weird, who makes a calzone with no cheese and only meat??! Used to love the pizza but it’s become avg at best, so sad. And DO NOT order online, they always get it wrong.
… moreSimply reviewed travels youtube
Great empanada place! Lots of choices and they have a good spin on empanadas. And there mini calzones is great. This way I don’t have to eat just calzone because it’s ginormous. It’s a great size for you to try a whole bunch of stuff. Great place.!
… more