Carol Clayton
Ended up here by chance, so pleased we did. Had brunch here. Food was delicious and our server was very kind, making sure we were happy with how our dishes were going to be cooked. Sat outside to enjoy the water and boats, met a wonderful old manatee who was asleep. Really enjoyed ourselves here
… moreJean Foster
Marathon has a true treasure in this restaurant. The food is excellent, the service is excellent, and the folks are friendly. We have eaten at places all over the world and we now add Castaway to our list of ultimate favorites. How much do we love this place? We’ve been here a week and today was our THIRD visit. First off, the service is awesome (times 100!). Servers are friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. They have a good synergy between the front and back end of the restaurant. Food is consistent, prompt, and damn good. We’ve been working our way through the menu… the chef and his staff know how to prepare fish/seafood. This is now the place we will judge future seafood/fish dinners by. We have at least one more visit coming up before we leave, there’s a couple more items to try (wink).
… moreChristine Fryberger
Our server Christine was very friendly and fabulous at her job . Best server we have ever had . Had the lion fish sushi roll and coconut shrimp- both were delicious. Service was fast !!
… moreJordan McCoy
A Serene Culinary Haven: Castaways Waterfront Restaurant
… moreSteven
We enjoyed some happy hour sushi, lumpia and fish fingers. The Tunachos were amazing and so was the Dragon Roll. The fish fingers were decent and the lumpia improved if you dipped it in the sauce that came with the dragon roll… Or was is the Tunachos sauce. Either way, very happy with the food and price point of the happy hour. Our server was extremely nice and would be worth going back just to be served by Mike.
… moreJill Winchel
We had dinner last week and enjoyed swordfish and lobster. Had to return today for sushi-Lion fish and Spicy Mae. All was wonderful and so fresh. Service both times was excellent. Definitely recommend if near Marathon Key.
… moreTeresa Price
Saw this place on Triple D right before we came to Florida, so naturally, we had to stop by. Everything was so delicious. We started with a Bloody Wilson and a Castaway Rum Bunch. Both were very good. Our appetizer was the Tunachos. Amazing tasty! We could have eaten these all day. Hubby and I shared the Lobster Enchiladas, which were stuffed with so much lobster we couldn’t believe it. We also shared the Lionfish, King of the Jungle rolls. So much food and so good. Our waitress was very attentive, which we really appreciated.
… moreJason Koschkee
If you appreciate great food and service, this is your place. In the area for a week, and my wife and I have been EVERYWHERE. We planned on trying a couple new places every day, but decided this place is worth a visit more than once. The bartenders and waitstaff are a treasure, and the chef is passionate about his craft. The drinks were amazing, and the food was perfect. Best Rangoons and sushi we’ve ever had. Never heard of lobster enchiladas, but they’re worth trying. Fantastic! If you’re lucky, you’ll see the manatees. Thank you for a great couple hours. You made our vacation memorable.
… moreAnna
Thank you to Heidi our waitperson, who took incredible care of us! She ensured my kiddo got tempura shrimp to eat and made our drink requests happen. Thank you also to the person who seated the three of us without a reservation. Awesome food too! And the manatees were wonderful. What a highlight of our trip!
… moreJennifer Boyd
Love Sunday brunch here! We had country fried steak and eggs with toast and hashbrowns. And blackened shrimp and grits with English muffin. And the mimosas and bloody Wilson’s are awesome too.
… more