
Warm, easygoing eatery serving grilled chops, seafood dishes & ample wine plus happy hours.
Hours
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 660 State St, New Haven, CT 06511
Phone: (203) 745-4669
Website: https://castironchefnewhaven.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – The Cast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster Bar
Cast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster Bar
Cast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster Bar | New Haven CT – Facebook
Reviews
The food was pretty good. I highly recommend the bone-in ribeye — we ordered it medium rare, and it was cooked perfectly with great seasoning. My friend had the New York strip, and that was delicious as well.
The shrimp was very fresh, though a bit too salty for our taste. The lobster tail was small, but nicely seasoned, tender, and juicy.
Someone at the next table was celebrating a birthday, and the staff brought out a cake with candles. When we were leaving, I noticed the plate said “Happy Birthday,” which was a really sweet touch.
To start, our waiter was wonderful—attentive, friendly, and patient. However, the food itself was just okay. I ordered the salmon, and the plating was very sloppy. It looked like it had been rushed and thrown on the plate without care, but honestly that wasn’t even the main issue of the night.
While my husband was enjoying his drink, the entire bottom of his glass suddenly broke off, spilling everywhere. It was extremely strange, and both our waiter and another customer witnessed it. Instead of handling the situation with concern or professionalism, the manager came over very aggressive and accusatory. She immediately questioned my husband, asking if he had hit the glass with the skillet, and even said she would be checking the cameras—as if the glass breaking clean off was somehow our fault.
When she returned from reviewing the footage, her attitude completely changed. She became apologetic once she realized the damage was not caused by us. But by then, the entire night was already ruined. I was upset and embarrassed that we even had to defend ourselves for something that was clearly out of our control.
As a Hispanic woman, I could not help but feel singled out and unfairly treated by this manager. Instead of addressing a safety issue, she treated us like we were doing something wrong. And the saddest part? I still paid the entire bill. For the emotional distress, the ruined birthday, and the disrespect we endured, our meal should have been fully comped.
This experience made it clear to me that not all customers are treated equally here. I will never return to this restaurant, and I hope management seriously reevaluates how they handle situations—and how they treat their guests.
Atmosphere/Appearance: Set right on the busy State Street is this gem. There’s no private parking, but plenty of comfortable, spacious street parking right out front. Once inside you’re immersed in a very fine-dining, elegant, laid-back atmosphere. Lots of woods, intimate-low lighting and upbeat music. I loved the vibes in here. The first room is your bar room where the rail is off to the left, but with plenty of seating to the right. If you continue through the room you enter the main dining room where it’s all booths and other tables.
Service: Stacey was our server. Things got off to a bit of a rocky start, but they smoothed out throughout the brunch.
Food/Drinks: The mimosa was okay… It was REALLY strong because there’s orange vodka and orange liqueur in it. It kinda killed the flavor for me because I’d prefer a traditional mimosa with minimal juice, but… no matter. They’re bottomless… or supposed to be… Just be mindful of who your server is. Brunch can consist of a prix-fixed menu, which is what we did so we’ll be going through that. First up were the Homemade Sausage Gravy and biscuits. These were super smothered and fantastic. Hot, savory, meaty, salty and even had a bit of a subtle sweetness. The biscuit was soft, butter and had crispy edges. Next up were the Cinnamon Rolls. These were HUGE. Lol. Like, how are we supposed to eat AND drink all of this stuff?! The exterior of the roll was crispy and the inside very soft. Not over-the-top sweetness or anything. These were very balanced. Next up were the Bananas Foster Pancakes. But this thing was enormous. It was so thick, like literally an inch thick. Lol. Fresh bananas sliced right on top, it cut like butter, was soft with the perfect crispy edges and these were AMAZING. Punch of sweetness up front, fluffy texture and just a great pancake. For dinner, this restaurant usually serves Cast Iron Popcorn instead of bread, so Stacey let us try it! It was smokey, a little-little sweet with a little bit of salt and maybe a hickory barbecue flavor. I liked it. Lastly, I chose the Steak & Eggs over Salmon & Eggs, but got to try both since my wife was with me. Each comes with gigantic fried potatoes, 3 eggs, a piece of toast, caramelized onions and your protein of choice. My steak was cooked perfectly (medium-rare). The flavors were excellent. It was a little fatty and just was done very well.
Value: $64.96 for bottomless mimosas and the prix-fixe menu. Probably the best value brunch in the state. SO MUCH FOOD and strong drinks. I don’t know what else you’d want!
In conclusion, I really enjoyed myself here and have revisited since my first time! Everything was just as awesome as the first. Check this place out if you’re in the area!
The menu is expansive enough that you can visit several times and try something different each time. We had the lamb lollipops, the mussels (which my husband said was an incredible amount for the price and the sauce was to die for), the short rib, the NY strip, the mushrooms, and the bread pudding with ice cream and caramel sauce. If you’re full just reading it, we were happily full eating it all. . The cocktails were also quite good (I’m a bourbon and gin girl and they delivered!)
Will certainly be back!
Food was excellent. Sat at the bar and ate while enjoying a few cocktails. Friendly service. I’m sure the dinner entrees are great as well. Give it a try.
Food was okay. Steak was a tiny bit overdone but not bad. Broccoli was undergone and too crunchy.
For the prices and experience, it was definitely disappointing.