Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 5–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2900 Lincoln Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
Phone: (812) 550-1199
Website: https://www.caseysdugout.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Baseball-Themed Pizza | Casey’s Dugout | Evansville IN
Enjoy delicious baseball-themed pizzas at Casey’s Dugout. Join our SMS program for exclusive discounts and order online today!
Casey’s Dugout | Evansville IN – Facebook
Casey’s Dugout, Evansville. 11574 likes · 3267 talking about this · 439 were here. Pizza place.
Casey’s Dugout – Explore Evansville
Casey’s Dugout · 2900 Lincoln Ave Evansville, IN 47714 · (812) 550-1199 · [email protected]. Overview. The neighborhood pizza boutique and home of The …
Reviews
Angela
Loved it!! First impression didn’t disappoint, very nicely decorated with sport memorabilia everywhere, pictures covering walls, many things to keep ur eyes entertained.. The food was not like any “I can get this anywhere” but has its own signature, thought out flavors… Very delicious, fresh and gives u that old fashioned, home made, family comfort feel. The staff were welcoming, polite and professional. In all a place to make u feel comfortable to come hang out with friends and family. Added bonus was to see the owner working hard along side the others.. Its shows the dedication and passion that goes into what makes it so great. Highly recommended!!!
… moreDavid Skau
This was our first visit to Casey’s and we were amazed. Fun atmosphere, friendly staff, fast service, and delicious pizza. It met and exceeded all of our expectations.
… morePatrick Gallman
Good pizza, had the Graham Slam, covered in pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, green peppers, banana peppers, mushrooms, black olives. Was so loaded, hard to pick up with one hand. Definitely a two handed slice. You order at window inside, get you own drinks, sit down. When order is ready they come out, call your name to find where you are seated and deliver food.
… moreTeeeve
Just had the pepperoni pizza and breadsticks from Casey’s Dugout, and it absolutely hit the spot. The pizza had that perfect balance—crispy crust, gooey cheese, and a generous amount of pepperoni with just the right kick of spice. You can tell they care about quality because everything tasted fresh and well-made.
The breadsticks were a surprise standout—soft on the inside, golden and slightly crispy on the outside, with just the right amount of garlic and seasoning. Dipping them in the marinara was dangerously good.
Fast service, friendly staff, and food that delivers on flavor. Definitely coming back—this spot’s a hidden gem
… moreThe breadsticks were a surprise standout—soft on the inside, golden and slightly crispy on the outside, with just the right amount of garlic and seasoning. Dipping them in the marinara was dangerously good.
Fast service, friendly staff, and food that delivers on flavor. Definitely coming back—this spot’s a hidden gem
Steve Rennels
This was my first time trying Casey’s dug out and it was a great experience. It was very busy but everyone working there was super friendly and helpful. The food was delicious. We had an appetizer pizza and the tiger balls for dessert. Everything was delicious if you’ve not tried Casey’s pizza I encourage you to go out and do so today. Also we seen some people eating the hot ham and cheese sandwich. It looked delicious and they said it’s the best in town that’s next on my list to try.
… moreTerry MacCauley
Living far from my hometown, I’ve been watching Casey Keown absolutely crush it with Casey’s Dugout, between the marketing and the rave reviews, this spot had been calling my name. I finally made the trip, and let me tell you: it’s now a priority visit no matter what the schedule looks like.
I came prepared—with a cooler in hand and plans to stock up for weekend football. Half-baked Strombolis? Check. Detailed finish-at-home instructions from Casey himself? Check. I even fired one up the second I got home, and it was pure magic.
Casey, you and your family are an Evansville treasure. Hoosier Hospitality is alive and thriving in your fine-ass establishment. Can’t wait to get back. Cheers to the entire Casey’s Dugout TEAM!
… moreI came prepared—with a cooler in hand and plans to stock up for weekend football. Half-baked Strombolis? Check. Detailed finish-at-home instructions from Casey himself? Check. I even fired one up the second I got home, and it was pure magic.
Casey, you and your family are an Evansville treasure. Hoosier Hospitality is alive and thriving in your fine-ass establishment. Can’t wait to get back. Cheers to the entire Casey’s Dugout TEAM!
Trevor Gibson
Incredible service, food, and ownership! Customer service from every member of the staff we encountered was genuine and welcoming. The food was incredible, good flavor on the pizza & stromboli and they both came out HOT and FRESH. Being checked on as the food came out and then while leaving by the owner of the restaurant was the cherry on top of an incredible experience! If you are looking for a neat and great place to try stop looking at reviews and head to Casey’s Dugout!! ⚾️
… moreEmily Waddell
Tonight was our first visit to Casey’s and I can’t say enough about the excellent service from all staff we encountered. Everyone working seemed to actually enjoy their job, and it showed!
The atmosphere was all around up beat and friendly. It was a busy night, and there were lots of people walking around chatting. Overall great family -friendly spot. 5/5 for an “Evansville sports bar” vibe.
I was so excited to try this place, but unfortunately they food was just lacking tonight. Maybe they were having trouble with the oven, but the pizza and fire balls were sub par. The fireballs had a burnt taste from the charred bacon (it seemed like they noticed this and added more bacon and served it anyway). The pizzas were soggy and flimsy from a poor bake. The crust it self did taste good and the mozzarella on the margarita pizza tasted great.
… moreThe atmosphere was all around up beat and friendly. It was a busy night, and there were lots of people walking around chatting. Overall great family -friendly spot. 5/5 for an “Evansville sports bar” vibe.
I was so excited to try this place, but unfortunately they food was just lacking tonight. Maybe they were having trouble with the oven, but the pizza and fire balls were sub par. The fireballs had a burnt taste from the charred bacon (it seemed like they noticed this and added more bacon and served it anyway). The pizzas were soggy and flimsy from a poor bake. The crust it self did taste good and the mozzarella on the margarita pizza tasted great.
M Poole
The food was delicious! Fireballs, jalepeno cheese bread and Utopia Pizza! Def worth the trip!
Casey’s was a great hometown experience. The atmosphere toward the customers was that of familiarity and care.
… moreCasey’s was a great hometown experience. The atmosphere toward the customers was that of familiarity and care.
April
Marketed as a boutique pizza place, you’re definitely going to get boutique prices, so be aware of that. As of writing this review 5/13/2024 they have no phone you can call to order carryout, which I find lacking. I would rather call and place my order than having to go in and wait for my order. I didn’t know they didn’t have a phone number as the local review sites have stated they were open for carryout after googling and looking at their website and all reviews I decided I’d just have to drive over and place an order and wait. I was told when i asked if they would be getting a phone i was told hopefully next week. This review is for what I ordered on 5/11/24 Saturday I went early a bit after they opened, which was 3 pm. I entered, and the person taking the orders was nice. Be aware it is kinda hard to hear in there as it can be a bit loud with everything going on when you’re placing an order. I ordered at around 3:40pm and had my order in hand and back to my car by 3:50pm. Didn’t expect that at all. The place itself is clean and has nice decor. I love the theme, especially since I am a baseball fan. I ordered breadsticks x2, the potato pizza 10-inch (they just renamed it), and the field of greens 10-inch total with tip was a little over $50. First, the breadsticks loved those I like that they add the toppings. The potato pizza minus the bacon (we had taken off) was supposed to have sour cream or tzatziki sauce we didn’t get either for some reason, so at home just added sour cream ourselves since we had it . I discovered this when I got home. The potatoes were nice and soft, and the pizza was ok. The field of greens was the better of the two. The ingredients were fresh which was great crust was good as well. Crust was nicely baked as well. Do I think its worth the price ? At this time for family and myself no. Maybe I’ll give it another try and try different pizzas they do have a small variety of their specialities. This isn’t a weekly pizza stop for us. I am glad i was finally able to try it i had been waiting for awhile. Also be aware there is only 4 parking spots if youre not from the area you will need to park across the street in the parking there becareful crossing Lincoln!
… more