S M
This review is for who ever made the Supreme pizza that I ordered at 11:45pm on October 21st 2023. MAAAAANNNNN you made the most BUSSIN AAAAA’hhhh pizza of my LIFE! Bro. 15/10 thank you SO much cause it hit the SPOT! You’re amazing. Give this person a RAISE!
… moreTrace Lundeen
The service was incredible. The driver let themselves in and plated my pizza for me. They even sat down for a bit and had a conversation with me while I started to eat. Will be ordering more from Casey’s.
… moreMakayla
My whole order was wrong. I specifically ordered Mac and cheese with no bacon and they gave me bacon. I also ordered the pull apart twizzlers and they gave me original. Finally, I ordered one ice cream and they didn’t have it, but instead of calling, they just gave me a random replacement. A flavor I don’t even like
… moreTrisha
I just ordered a Lg taco pizza this afternoon (4/29/21) and I gotta say…
The younger boy that made it made, he made it to absolutely perfection its like he put his heart and soul into making this pizza ❤
I mean like, I worked at this Casey’s 2 years ago and he made this pizza better than I could have made it for myself for real.
Thank you kid! You’re amazing at making taco pizzas!!!
… moreWatkins Christopher
They have some lovely pizza and food items to choose from and gas on a whim if you need it. But I feel like the people that work there need a better attitude towards customers. Occasionally the cashier just rings me up without a word, making the situation kind of awkward!!
… moreJoe Haggard
If your looking at grabbing a couple slices of pizza dont bother stopping here. I guess the 2 kids prefer to smack their gums instead of making pizzas for customers to buy. It was about 1230 and they had nothing to be bought in the warmers. If the manager would watch the camera’s they would see what’s really going on here. If they dont care I guess it’s time to say farewell to your store also.
… moreKimberly R
Called the number to order pizza and apparently they changed their phone number without updating any website. I ordered online and went to get it after 30 minutes and they didn’t see the online order, they found it and I had to wait an additional 35 minutes. Horrible experience. Casey’s is a joke in Mendota! Zero stars!
… moreBen Haas
I ordered pizza tonight a brisket and there was jalapenos and balery any bbq sauce on it the crust was not done all the way. And got a meat goloer and ask for onions there was no onions the crust on this one was not done they did not spread the meat out they did not cook the pepperoni
… moreFrom Compost To Table
My husband and I were staying in town for vacation recently and decided to get a pizza for a late dinner. I called at 8:47pm. Was told it would be ready in 20-25mins. We gave them a few mins and headed over. I believe we arrived at 9:10pm. My husband went in, then turned around and came out. They said that it would be another 10 mins. Seems like organizational issues or forgetfulness. Gave them 3 stars only bc the pizza was good.
… moreRebecka Knight
The food was bad. We stopped here trying to find a place eat at 1am traveling up I-39. We had to travel a few miles from the interstate and then through a small town. The employees watched us like hawks whilewe wandered around looking for suitable sustenance. Very small and limited options, for a place that makes their own hot food, only a few pieces of what tasted old sausage available were available. The cashier was polite. Overall, too small and too far off I-39, food not good enough for the hassle. Keep driving!
… more