Social Profile: ![]()
![]()
… View more
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pizza Delivery and Pickup in Whitewater, WI | Casey’s
About Casey’s 1353 W Main St … Fuel up and stock up at your local Casey’s for unbeatable convenience, quality products, and friendly service. Find what you need …
Pizza Delivery and Pickup in Whitewater, WI | Casey’s
Discover Casey’s delivery and pickup service at 650 Milwaukee St, Whitewater. Enjoy hot and fresh pizza, and more, anytime, anywhere.
Casey’s Pizza, Food & Grocery Delivery | Gas Station …
Order the best made-from-scratch pizza, sandwiches, appetizers & more for delivery or pickup from your local Casey’s. See our full menu and find store …
Reviews
Double B
4/2024 4* Just stopped to buy gas. The squeegee bins for washing your windows were almost completely dry and no paper towels. Otherwise, I would have given 5*.
… morerbennett53520
Usually Casey’s are great. But this one is having issues apparently. Not the first time I went in there and it’s 8 am. No donuts, no hot food. Kinda ridiculous.
… moreRoxana Perozo
I have never made a review before but this deserves it… Worst customer service ever. The brown hair girl on the liquor side has the worst attitude ever. I do not know how she got hired. Very disrespectful, very rude, very unprofessional. Yelling at customers for no reason
… moreMelina Vreealnd
Didn’t pump gas, but the bathrooms are spacious and clean. Very nice locking mechanism. Store was clean and easy to find the products I was looking for. Clerk was efficient, though seemed tired. Lack of music makes the store a little uncomfortable.
… moreSandra Stone
This review is specific to Ashley who makes the pizza around the lunch hours. Rarely is there pepperoni pizza available (their most popular type), and often there is no pizza at all. I am not the only customer who sees this situation and turns around to leave without buying anything. Despite several discussions about this continuing problem, Ashley’s goal is to never have any pizza left over, rather than to always have all three types of pizza available. I’m sure many people have simply stopped trying to get pizza there, because she will either just have a sad piece of sausage in the carousel or no pizza at all.
On a positive note, the woman up front is always cheerful and helpful.
… moreOn a positive note, the woman up front is always cheerful and helpful.
Kevin DeCoux
I’ve pulled in here two or three times heading out of town and haven’t been able to pay at the pump. I’ve just had to leave and drive back into town to get gas somewhere else. They are conveniently located, but I’m not going inside. Also, they say if you pay for gas you get money off on a car wash, but my car doesn’t hold enough fuel to get the discount. That is dumb. I like their carwash. Not much else.
… moreAlexandra Valdez
The brown hair girl on the liquor side has the worst customer service ever. I do not know how she got hired. I will not ever use this store again after three times of her disrespect. Im done
… moreTyler Zotti
Pretty decent establishment, good food and beer. One time though, I was driving through the drive through alcohol pick up with my dog in the front seat. I asked for a 30pk of Miller Lite so I can go home and pound some brews. When I was about to pay for my beer, the gentleman in the window said “does she have some ID?” referring to my dog. I am not sure if this was serious or a joke but I didn’t find it funny at all. 1, She’s obviously not of drinking age and 2, she’s a dog! Alcohol is bad for dogs and I would never give her any. After a awkward 2 minute stare down, I reversed out of the drive through lane. Also, I bought a phone charger there one time and it was like $26!! Its probably for spaceship phones or drunk dogs.
… moreSam Howe
The pizza here is delicious and the staff are always super kind and friendly.
… morematt e
When it was frawleys I was able to get my receipt at the pump. Ever since the change I have had to go inside for my receipt. Literally every time. It gets worse they won’t let you fuel before you pay. Talk about a credit card hassle.
… more