Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Family run and operated, the “Boss,” Mimmo Gambino, opened the doors of Casa Rustia in Smithtown, NY, in 1985. In the past, he had created many fine-dining establishments in New York City. Born and raised in a “small town you’ve never heard of in Palermo, Italy,” as Mimmo Gambino used to say, Mimmo came to New York City to purse the American dream. Focusing on his Sicilan upbringing, he instilled a new culture to the recipes that we still use today.
Old-world Italian cuisine is the draw at this upscale ristorante with rustic accents & fireplace.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787
Phone: (631) 265-9265
Website: http://casarusticali.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Casa Rustica: Home
World-famous Lobster Flambé, Authentic Sicilian Cuisine, Original Craft Cocktails and Much More! Proudly serving the great village of Smithtown, New York since …
Casa Rustica | Smithtown NY – Facebook
Treat yourself to some authentic Italian food to get you through the week. Visit us at 175 Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787. We can’t wait to serve you!
Casa Rustica – Updated 2026, Italian Restaurant in Smithtown, NY
Cafe Rustica is a fine Italian restaurant that recreates the authentic cuisine of the Mediterranean country with love and a careful attention to detail.
Reviews
hannah salons
We’ve been coming here for years and it never disappoints. It’s one of those small Italian places that just feels like home the second you walk in, warm, friendly, and you can tell everything is made with care. The pasta is always fresh, the sauces taste like someone’s grandma is in the kitchen, and the specials are consistently amazing. The staff knows us by now and they’re always so welcoming. It’s the kind of spot you look forward to going back to every time. Highly recommend if you want real, comforting Italian food.
… moreLora DiNapoli
We just had our daughter’s communion luncheon there, can’t say enough great things: from the first moment when we booked, everything was really easy and smooth. Very accommodating and friendly. The service was excellent! The luncheon package had a beautiful variety of meat and fish, it was a great menu, all the guests loved the food and said they would come back on their own. Excellent experience!
… moreShawn Cooper
I’ve been coming to Casa Rustica since I was a kid, my parents used to bring my sister and me, and now it’s become one of my all-time favorite restaurants. Over the years, the food has somehow managed to stay incredibly consistent while continuing to evolve and impress. Every dish is made with care, passion, and authentic Italian flavor.
The lobster flambé is an absolute must-try — unforgettable and perfectly prepared table side, with a show! The chicken parm is classic comfort food done right, and the Australian rack of lamb is nothing short of spectacular.
The entire staff is warm, professional, and treats you like family. It’s rare to find a restaurant where the quality of food and service both remain exceptional year after year, but Casa Rustica delivers every single time.
If you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine, outstanding quality, and a place that truly cares about its guests, I can’t recommend Casa Rustica enough.
… moreThe lobster flambé is an absolute must-try — unforgettable and perfectly prepared table side, with a show! The chicken parm is classic comfort food done right, and the Australian rack of lamb is nothing short of spectacular.
The entire staff is warm, professional, and treats you like family. It’s rare to find a restaurant where the quality of food and service both remain exceptional year after year, but Casa Rustica delivers every single time.
If you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine, outstanding quality, and a place that truly cares about its guests, I can’t recommend Casa Rustica enough.
Cassandra Leggio (Cassandra)
My boyfriend and I had the pleasure of experiencing a delightful Valentine’s Day dinner at Cafe Rustica in Smithtown, and it exceeded all expectations.
From the moment we stepped in, we were warmly greeted and seated with genuine delight. Our waiter was incredibly attentive, patiently answering our questions about the specials and offering his recommendations on the most popular and tastiest entrees. Within minutes, we were toasting to another Valentine’s Day celebration with perfectly crafted dirty martinis that set the tone for the evening.
The appetizers arrived promptly, and we couldn’t have been happier with our choice of clams and oysters. The seafood was impeccably fresh, as if it had just been plucked from the ocean!
My boyfriends main course, lobster, was an absolute delight. Each bite was bursting with flavor, making it one of the most delicious dishes I’ve ever tasted! For my entree, I ordered my favorite, a classic beet and goat cheese salad, which always leaves me satsfied, and this salad was .
True to their excellent service, our waiter even remembered to wrap up the leftovers for me to enjoy as lunch the following day, saving me from forgetting it as we headed towards our valeted vehicle.
Overall, our dining experience at Cafe Rustica was splendid. The freshness, impeccable service, and cozy atmosphere made it a memorable evening. I can’t wait to return for another dinner and indulge in their exquisite cuisine once again.
Highly recommended!
… moreFrom the moment we stepped in, we were warmly greeted and seated with genuine delight. Our waiter was incredibly attentive, patiently answering our questions about the specials and offering his recommendations on the most popular and tastiest entrees. Within minutes, we were toasting to another Valentine’s Day celebration with perfectly crafted dirty martinis that set the tone for the evening.
The appetizers arrived promptly, and we couldn’t have been happier with our choice of clams and oysters. The seafood was impeccably fresh, as if it had just been plucked from the ocean!
My boyfriends main course, lobster, was an absolute delight. Each bite was bursting with flavor, making it one of the most delicious dishes I’ve ever tasted! For my entree, I ordered my favorite, a classic beet and goat cheese salad, which always leaves me satsfied, and this salad was .
True to their excellent service, our waiter even remembered to wrap up the leftovers for me to enjoy as lunch the following day, saving me from forgetting it as we headed towards our valeted vehicle.
Overall, our dining experience at Cafe Rustica was splendid. The freshness, impeccable service, and cozy atmosphere made it a memorable evening. I can’t wait to return for another dinner and indulge in their exquisite cuisine once again.
Highly recommended!
Franklin Martinez
Is the best place ever . Plus the chef use to cook for us in the green park in Morristown we know him for the last 20 hears great person clean and professional.
And they have means huge discount for my child birthday party just for been a costumer
… moreAnd they have means huge discount for my child birthday party just for been a costumer
joeysal77
Went out for a Saturday date night with my wife. She hasn’t been here in decades, me never.
We were seated downstairs in a nice cozy dining room.
Our drinks were perfect as well as the table starters they initially place like the breads, oils, etc.
We started off with their broccoli rabe, a Caesar salad and the mussels. Honestly, the sausages in the mussels dish mixed with corn….some of the best we have ever tasted. I should mention that my wife is almost off the boat Italian and a chef herself. We know great cuisine.
For our entrees, we had the rigatoni nonna and the veal chop T. The portions were bountiful and the taste other worldly. We actually saw a coworker with her husband and friends and they spoke so highly as regulars. We were mad we haven’t been here more…but are def gong back real soon. We ended with a cappochino and some tiramisu.
This is real old school Italian, checking off all the boxes. We would highly recommend and would try absolutely anything on this diverse menu.
… moreWe were seated downstairs in a nice cozy dining room.
Our drinks were perfect as well as the table starters they initially place like the breads, oils, etc.
We started off with their broccoli rabe, a Caesar salad and the mussels. Honestly, the sausages in the mussels dish mixed with corn….some of the best we have ever tasted. I should mention that my wife is almost off the boat Italian and a chef herself. We know great cuisine.
For our entrees, we had the rigatoni nonna and the veal chop T. The portions were bountiful and the taste other worldly. We actually saw a coworker with her husband and friends and they spoke so highly as regulars. We were mad we haven’t been here more…but are def gong back real soon. We ended with a cappochino and some tiramisu.
This is real old school Italian, checking off all the boxes. We would highly recommend and would try absolutely anything on this diverse menu.
Kimberly Crettol
This past weekend we had a luncheon for my daughter’s sweet 16. From the first call to Benny to the end of the event everything ran smoothly. The food, staff and atmosphere were perfect in every way. My husband and I will be frequenting Casa Rustica again. Superb
… moreTommy Chic
Absolutely the worst service I have ever experienced. I wanted a drink before our price fixe dinner of a large group and the waiter acted like I was a burden! We ordered the first round of drinks and he brought us a bill to pay for the drinks! I handed it back to him asking what it was, meaning why!? We were going to want more drinks and were willing to pay for it, he acted like he was afraid that we weren’t going to pay! I’ll probably never go back there with that type of attitude. I never felt so indignant at a restaurant. 2 stars Cafe Rustica!
… moreVal C
Food was delicious, and service was great.
My only big complain:
We ordered plain pasta and 1 meatball for our 2 year old daughter. The plate was tiny, maybe 15 units of penne? They charged $12 for that. Ridiculous, considering we spent $100+ in dinner.
The “kids menu” wasn’t listed on the menu, so we assumed that was a normal order of pasta without sauce and 1 meatball.
Definitely not a family friendly restaurant.
… moreMy only big complain:
We ordered plain pasta and 1 meatball for our 2 year old daughter. The plate was tiny, maybe 15 units of penne? They charged $12 for that. Ridiculous, considering we spent $100+ in dinner.
The “kids menu” wasn’t listed on the menu, so we assumed that was a normal order of pasta without sauce and 1 meatball.
Definitely not a family friendly restaurant.
Tommy John
Classic Italian fine dining in Smithtown. I love coming here with my family for dinner. The food is always delicious – i recommend their flambéed butter lobster, calamari, baked clams, and pastas.
… more