Lisa Dellapina
Amazing Italian food! Very fresh, very yummy. I’d definitely go back for any occasion. We did have to wait sometimes when our server was busy and/or kitchen was backed up. But well worth it!
… moreMisty Galentine
What a hidden gem! My husband and I had the most incredible dining experience last night at Casa Cosenza. The owner greeted us at the door, and remained attentive to what seemed like the entire room, the entire time we were there! The piano music… wow, what a surprise and beautiful delight! A huge thanks to our waiter, Freddy. From the moment we sat down, his warmth and attentiveness made us feel completely at ease. He guided us through the menu and the specials with expertise – perfect recommendations and his wine suggestion paired beautifully with every bite. We haven’t had service this exceptional in a long time – Freddy truly elevated our date night and we look forward to going back!
… moreDavid Knott
The absolute best Italian food in Tampa. Every dish is made fresh with homemade pasta and natural ingredients making this place special. With only 15 tables, make a reservation. Giuseppe and his wife have created and quiet, relaxed atmosphere for a great dining experience.
… morecarly kline
Had dinner here recently and it was fantastic. I had the gnocchi and it was honestly the best italian food i’ve had in an extremely long time. The atmosphere is fancy while still being friendly and perfect for families or romantic dinners. The waiter was great and extremely helpful when deciding menu items. Overall, I would strongly recommend this place for families, romantic dinners, or special occasions
… moreSarah Maddox
Giuseppe and his team are amazing. During Covid, they kindly seated my family outside, as my dad had cancer and could not be inside. It was my parents’ 45th, and Casa Cozenza and their team made our night amazing. The service was great, and we felt special. We have been here for many family events. When my dad passed, I couldn’t think of a better place to honor his love of food. Giuseppe was amazing and was so kind and thoughtful as I dealt with grief and planning a memorial dinner. He was thoughtful and offered up a great fixed price menu for our party of 20. When we got there, the service was second to none, and the food was amazing. They made an anxious and sad day amazing, and our family loved all the food. I can’t thank them enough for supporting me during the hardest time of my life. The food there is amazing and you will be treated like family.
… moreMichelle Minitti
Charming strip mall gem with terrific pasta, great staff, and a very cool bar. Every dish our party of six had was wonderful, with flavorful sauces. The house salad dressing is unique and delicious. Support this great spot!
… moreCarrie Oden
Such a wonderful experience for my daughter’s wedding shower. The owners are amazing and went above and beyond to help decorate, as well as make sure every guest was happy. Food was amazing! Will definitely make sure to go back!
… moreNate
My server for the night was Peppe. He was absolutely lovely the entire time. Little bit of a slow night, still made sure to keep a good energy and left me feeling appreciated for giving this place a try. Brought food out quickly, and gave great recommendations on what to try. He’s a star and represents this place perfectly.
If I had to sum this place up with three vibes?
Delicious
Savory
Calm and soothing
Open dining space, and with a homely atmosphere. There is a piano befitting of the relaxing atmosphere. Unfortunately I did not get to hear anyone play it, but I look forward to hearing it on the next time I’m here. Appears very clean, very minor things to clean such as curtains and windowsills.
Appetizer
Stuffed Tortellini (special of the day)
Thoughts:
Well plated, well portioned
Very delicious seasoning on the sauce
Tortellini was perfectly cooked
Ate it so quickly I forgot to take a picture
Highly recommend
Fettuccine Primavera
Amazing, hands down one of the best dishes I’ve had in a while.
Sauce perfectly seasoned, absolutely not lacking missing any flavor.
The pancetta, onion, mushroom, cherry tomatoes, spinach, and peas were like a flavor explosion. Incredibly satisfied. Fettuccine was perfectly cooked again, the best way to warm up in this Florida cold.
Tiramasu-
I know, everyone has tiramasu. This was one of the better ones I’ve had , and tasted wonderful. The slight bitterness of the coffee mixing with the sweetness of the milk/cream was just amazing, perfect texture. 100% ordering it again.
I ordered a Ravioli Casa togo, to bring home to the wife.
Ravioli Casa- Brought it home for the wife, who said it traveled well. Said the sauce was delicious, and that she just wished it had a slightly higher portion size.
All in all this was absolutely a 5-star visit and I can’t wait to come back.
… moreAnastasios Deligiannis
We drove past the restaurant location and it caught our interest. I looked at their website and was impressed by their offering of dishes. We went for dinner with friends on a Thursday. When we stepped in the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. We were met by the host who showed us to our table. My wife had Gnocchi alla Sorentina and Lasagna, I had the Nettuno sea food fish. Presentation was excellent and the flavor of the dishes reminded us of being in Italy. We also had the Bruschette and the Polpette alla Nonna. The owners came to our table due to my wife being Italian and we had a great conversation down memory lane. I am looking forward to our next visit to Casa Cosenza and we both highly recommend this hidden gem in Oldsmar for great tasting authentic Italian cuisine.
… moreMaria Hidalgo Dolan
What a great hidden gem! We love this place. Beautiful! Cozy! Romantic! Exceptional food! Fresh ingredients! Great decor! White and Blue decorations! Don’t let the strip mall location fool you. This is one classy restaurant! They also have gluten free and vegetarian options! Many dishes they can accommodate special requests! The waiter was enchanting and endearing!
… more