Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (917) 540-5600
Website: https://www.casacarmennyc.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
CASA CARMEN | Mexican restaurant in NYC
CASA CARMEN FLATIRON. 5 W 21st Street, New York, NY, 10010 · [email protected]. Phone: (917)540-5600. CASA CARMEN TRIBECA. 114 Franklin Street …
Casa Carmen (@casacarmennyc) • Instagram photos and videos
9.4K+ followers · 83 following · 697 posts · @casacarmennyc: “Mexican restaurant in NYC Tribeca, 114 Franklin street Flatiron, 5 W 21st street Book …
Casa Carmen Flatiron Restaurant – New York, NY | OpenTable
Casa Carmen Flatiron offers a “chic vibe” with “delicious food” and “excellent service.” Guests rave about the “authentic Mexican cuisine,” “beautiful ambiance, …
Last Updates
Reviews
Selin Ozguler
Casa Carmen is an amazing Mexican restaurant.
We started with guac and chips and they were so good. My only small criticism is that the portion could be bigger because we had to order another one. That’s how good it was.
I had the rib taco and my friends absolutely loved their food too. Everyone ordered something different and everything was great.For drinks, of course I had a Mezcalita Rocks margarita and I highly recommend it.
We also had churros for dessert and they were delicious.I will definitely be coming back again very soon.
… moreWe started with guac and chips and they were so good. My only small criticism is that the portion could be bigger because we had to order another one. That’s how good it was.
I had the rib taco and my friends absolutely loved their food too. Everyone ordered something different and everything was great.For drinks, of course I had a Mezcalita Rocks margarita and I highly recommend it.
We also had churros for dessert and they were delicious.I will definitely be coming back again very soon.
Kyle McCarthy
Nice, tranquil, elegant eatery for authentic Mexican food in a business or date night setting. Tried the tacos de carnitas, super tasty roast pork with onions in fresh blue corn tortillas. A Habanero-infused salsa on the side for those who don’t like too spicy. Loved the Esquites and cream (corn off the cob) and Chicken Mole de Xico which was an aromatic, slightly sweet and spicy cacao-based sauce. Prices are fair for the generous portions and attentive service, worth noting the good 3-course lunch special with lots of options is $30 but was too much to eat! Will be back to try some of their more unusual plates!
… moreBailey Jaworski
Casa Carmen has a great atmosphere for elevated Mexican cuisine. A bit on the pricier side, but everything was delicious.
The margarita is great, the guacamole is fresh, and as someone with a dislike for cilantro, they graciously accommodated.
My friend and I ordered and split two versions of enchiladas (verdes, Xico/mole). My friend preferred the verdes while I preferred the mole so to each their own! Personally, I would definitely reorded the mole enchiladas when I return.
Great spot if you’re craving Mexican food and are looking for a slightly elevated dining experience.
… moreThe margarita is great, the guacamole is fresh, and as someone with a dislike for cilantro, they graciously accommodated.
My friend and I ordered and split two versions of enchiladas (verdes, Xico/mole). My friend preferred the verdes while I preferred the mole so to each their own! Personally, I would definitely reorded the mole enchiladas when I return.
Great spot if you’re craving Mexican food and are looking for a slightly elevated dining experience.
Brian Brunius
Amazing food. From the very first appetizer all the way to the end of the meal, Casa Carmen is delightful! You will love eating here.
… moreIvan Đaković
An excellent Mexican brunch spot! I loved their take on eggs Benedict, and their service was fantastic – fast and friendly. Highly recommend!
… moreMicaela
I recently dined at Casa Carmen and had the pleasure of being served by Franco from the moment we sat down, he was attentive and friendly. He promptly took our drink orders. He was knowledgeable about the menu and patiently answered our questions, offering helpful recommendations. Our food arrived quickly and was exactly as ordered. We started with the tostada de cangrejo which was spectacular. I had the ribeye and it was perfectly cooked. And throughout the meal, he checked on us regularly, ensuring we had everything we needed without being intrusive.
Franco excellent service truly enhanced our dining experience. He was professional, courteous, and made us feel welcome. I highly recommend Franco and will definitely be back to restaurants not only for the food but also for the great service!
… moreFranco excellent service truly enhanced our dining experience. He was professional, courteous, and made us feel welcome. I highly recommend Franco and will definitely be back to restaurants not only for the food but also for the great service!
Dhillon Harry
8 of us met up for dinner in the height of a heavy snowfall on December 26th, 2025. We were able to find parking right on the street where this restaurant is located. We shared a few apps like the Garnachas Orizabenas, and a few other tacos, Ceviche and the corn which was really good. Service was good, quick and everything tasted well.
… moreTamar A
Honestly disappointed. the guac was so bland we had to ask for salt and lome to make it edible. the chile relleno lacked any semblance of seasoning and the rice and bean portion were tiny. Will say the drinks are good but not a bargain. was expecting more.
… moreBill O
Great experience with this Flatiron area Mexican restaurant. Beautiful space, creative menu, and thoughtful service throughout. The menu draws on sophisticated Oaxacan flavors and much more than a taco/burrito joint. Enjoyed the unique cocktails as well.
… moreAndres Alarcon
As a Mexican I can say this is the best and most authentic Mexican restaurant in New York. Just top notch food, drinks, service and ambiance. Not cheap but worth every penny. I will be back!
… more