Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Family owned restaurant serving homemade from scratch Italian specialties and homemade desserts. Our background is Sicilian and we are best known for our eggplant ,veal and seafood dishes as well as for homemade Tiramisu , Italian cheesecake and cannolis. Homemade manicotti, pasta fogioli, escarole & beans, chicken cacciatore, scungilli salad , brasiole and riceballs delight our guests and bring back childhood memories.
Casual restaurant with a retro vibe offering Southern Italian fare, outdoor tables & homey accents.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 197 Blackford Way, St. Augustine, FL 32086
Phone: (904) 471-5999
Website: http://www.casabenedettos.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Casa Benedetto’s – St. Augustine’s Italian Restaurant
Casa Benedetto’s proudly continues our traditions of fresh authentic Sicilian cuisine prepared from scratch that we learned to appreciate growing up in the …
Casa Benedetto’s | Visit St. Augustine
Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante has opened at their new location, 197 Blackford Way, Unit F, St. Augustine. Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante offers traditional …
Great Italian Food at Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante in Saint Augustine
I think it’s the best Italian restaurant in Saint Augustine. Robin is amazing|Our favorite Italian restaurant. Nothing compares!
Last Updates
Reviews
Ally
Food was nice. Got the chicken marsala and had no problems with it. Also tired the Parmesan shrimp because it sounded interesting and was pretty good. The tiramisu was a little too soggy for me but still delicious. Overall the food and vibe of the restaurant was great aside from a few health concerns I had. There were dogs kept in the restaurant and the owner sat at the table next to us vaping. Still decent, but can’t give a full 5 stars.
… moreValerie Iglesias
If you want a wonderful intimate experience that transports you to a night in Italy, this is the place.
Pros:
The food is so delicious! I tried various dishes and could not find a single fault! The portions are not too big and not too small! The people working here are so attentive and kind. If you need anything, they anticipate your need and quietly get you drinks, bread, or even a simple conversation. At the same time, they also will give you plenty of time to have your own conversation without intruding. Perfect combination!
Cons:
The restaurants layout is long and narrow, making accommodating a group larger than 6 people harder. It’s doesn’t mean they can’t, but your table will have to stretch out lengthwise to do it.
Honestly, I highly recommend you get a reservation. There will be a line out the door for walk-ins.
… morePros:
The food is so delicious! I tried various dishes and could not find a single fault! The portions are not too big and not too small! The people working here are so attentive and kind. If you need anything, they anticipate your need and quietly get you drinks, bread, or even a simple conversation. At the same time, they also will give you plenty of time to have your own conversation without intruding. Perfect combination!
Cons:
The restaurants layout is long and narrow, making accommodating a group larger than 6 people harder. It’s doesn’t mean they can’t, but your table will have to stretch out lengthwise to do it.
Honestly, I highly recommend you get a reservation. There will be a line out the door for walk-ins.
Lori Koschnick
Delicious Italian food. Inviting atmosphere. Attentive staff. We left so happy
… moreSusan Romanello
Very nice and cozy Italian restaurant. The chicken parm and eggplant parmigiano were excellent! Fresh crispy bread! The service was fantastic! I left my handbag there by accident, of course, and didn’t realize it till the next day. When I called the restaurant, they told me no worries, it’s been put away safe for you. That made the whole meal and experience the best!
… moreTodd Dillon
I had a special clam and mussels pasta dish. Outstanding sauce with just the slightest spicy kick. I can’t do spicy hot food but this was just perfect. Atmosphere is a bit snug . There’s 2 bird cages when we walked in but no birds. Our waiter was awesome. He was super attentive. Very knowledgeable about all the menu options.
… moreVickie Bowman
OMG! I felt transported back to my childhood! I’m from Buffalo NY my husband from Brooklyn, the food was sooo awesome, I was amazed at the portion sizes. The bread and spread heartwarming!
We are planning on many date nights here!
… moreWe are planning on many date nights here!
Charlie Muller
JoJo was our waitress and she was fantastic, attended to every little detail.
Food was prepared fresh and served hot and delicious. We had the rice balls, fusilli and meatballs, and clams in red sauce over linguine. Salads where fresh and served cold as they should be.
I highly recommend this small quaint hidden gem of a true southern Italy restaurante.
We will certainly return again next time in St Augustine.
… moreFood was prepared fresh and served hot and delicious. We had the rice balls, fusilli and meatballs, and clams in red sauce over linguine. Salads where fresh and served cold as they should be.
I highly recommend this small quaint hidden gem of a true southern Italy restaurante.
We will certainly return again next time in St Augustine.
briasiah cooper
I absolutely love this place. The food is amazing. I usually go on my lunch break, whenever I’m looking for something quick and cheesy to eat!!
… moreSharon McCloud
Started with caponata and bread which comes when you are seated. I had spaghetti and meat sauce salad and cannoli for Dessert. The best Italian food I have had out of New York City and I have tried numerous places everywhere over the last 50 years. Five of us went for lunch everyone was thrilled with the whole experience. We are looking forward to eating there again tomorrow on our way back home.
… moreStarlight Lifter
Five stars all the way. We shared a lasagna and each had a very fresh and tasty salad. They served warm bread with a delicious olive oil with seasoning. So good i really enjoyed our lunch, and it was my wife’s birthday and she was very pleased. Great job Casa Benedetto’s.
… more