Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11618 Penn Hills Dr, Penn Hills Township, PA 15235
Phone: (412) 242-0650
Website: https://m.facebook.com/Carol-of-Caseys-135737553458239/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop: The Home of Flavorful Hoagies …
Discover Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop in Penn Hills, PA, where mouthwatering traditional pizzas and oven-baked hoagies await. Enjoy delicious dishes like …
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop – Penn Hills – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop at 11618 Penn Hills Drive in Penn Hills. Order online and track your order live.
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop 11618 Penn Hills Drive – Order Online
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop. 11618 Penn Hills Dr, Penn Hills, PA 15235, USAOnline ordering hours: 11:00 AM – 9:40 PM.
Reviews
Ulyana K
Pretty solid food, but not the best quality. The inside is small and definitely seems like a less popular, hole in the wall type of pizza joint. After all, it is located in a strip-mall type place and rammed in the corner of a turn.
The food itself is not bad, just very average. I had the cheese calzone. It was much smaller than I had anticipated. This would make for a decent lunch, but not enough for leftovers or a smaller than average dinner. The price was also decent but I’ve seen better deals.
The tomato sauce on the inside was a bit sweet and seemed like a standard canned sauce. There was an adequate amount of cheese, although I did get the impression it was lower quality. Too much tomato sauce. The crust was decent but was covered in cheese that was crunchy and just plain odd.
All in all, I wasn’t a huge fan of this calzone. It wasn’t terrible, but I’ve definitely had much better. The size was small and the quality was not that great.
… moreThe food itself is not bad, just very average. I had the cheese calzone. It was much smaller than I had anticipated. This would make for a decent lunch, but not enough for leftovers or a smaller than average dinner. The price was also decent but I’ve seen better deals.
The tomato sauce on the inside was a bit sweet and seemed like a standard canned sauce. There was an adequate amount of cheese, although I did get the impression it was lower quality. Too much tomato sauce. The crust was decent but was covered in cheese that was crunchy and just plain odd.
All in all, I wasn’t a huge fan of this calzone. It wasn’t terrible, but I’ve definitely had much better. The size was small and the quality was not that great.
Richard Massafra
I had a take out medium pizza. If you read my reviews, you know I like thick best. It wasn’t thick, but the service was good and the chocolate chip cookies were good as well.
… moreGoddess Of Magi
They illegally charge a dollar for any debit card/credit transactions. No gloves. The girl at the front was nice but I had to wait for my order even tho it was ready because she had to answer phones and show some dude how to heat up a slice of pizza.
I got the small pizza, do not get scammed into paying extra for toppings I got 8 slices of pepperoni, which is about 2/shov slice, this is basically cheese pizza.
I got half italian hoagie which is the only reason I have 3 stars is cause I’ve had it before and it’s not bad.
… moreI got the small pizza, do not get scammed into paying extra for toppings I got 8 slices of pepperoni, which is about 2/shov slice, this is basically cheese pizza.
I got half italian hoagie which is the only reason I have 3 stars is cause I’ve had it before and it’s not bad.
Amanda S
My aboslute FAVORITE pizza is their Philly Steak! Must try!
… moreWilliam Reid
I DoorDashed their Greek Pizza… and it was really tasty… thanks
… moreKrista Denton
Best family pizza restaurant in the area! The staff is warm and welcoming, greet you with a smile, and work quickly to prepare your order. I was surprised at how quickly my order was ready. The Greek pizza with white sauce is the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m going to add chicken to it next time and then I’m certain I’ll have same praise for that pizza. I have some super picky kids and one of them said “I can actually eat the crust of this pizza because it’s soft and chewy”. Truly, this could very well be the perfect pizza. I’m impressed.
… moreNina Ross
This isn’t my main go-to for Pizza or hoagies, it’s there if we get the urge. The service is always good, as well as the food.
… moremark Nelson
Odered a 4 cut and it was the bomb!! So went and gog a larger pizza and it was like nite and day!! Raw? No sauce ? Crazy! Then tried pep calzone? Thought was like before? Nope! Super small! And barely any thing inside? Guess it depends on who makes it i guess? Here’s. Photo of this 8 cut! Had so much sauce pouring over! No chesse! And raw!?
… moreDavid
Best hoagie around, even the bag smells great!
Service: …
… moreService: …
Leverett Diggs
Came in at 9:25 shop closes at 10 o’clock told me that they were closing in 10 minutes and wouldn’t be able to take my order. Told her that I thought they close at 10 o’clock only wanted grilled chicken Focaccia sandwiches. Employees wanted time to clean up to be going out the door at 10 o’clock. Maybe just say you’re not taking any walk-ins after 9 then… footnote my chicken wasn’t cooked fully. Don’t worry, I’ll take the hit. I will not be eating there anymore. The sad thing is, I’m sure the owner has no idea. #customer_service_used_to_mean_something
… more