David Brand
I ordered 2 slices of pizza today and they were not very good at all, they had very little sauce or cheese, and was tasteless. Also, there is definitely no Carlos who owns this pizzeria. Maybe many years ago it was owned by Carlos, but it’s definitely owned by other people today. I do-not recommend this restaurant. Have a great day….
… moreLynda Baviera
This is the best pizza I ever had! The rest of the food I ordered is delicious too. Very tasty and not over cooked. I highly recommend this restaurant. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreMichael
Carlo’s Pizza is not only great tasting but incredibly reasonably priced. This is a great place to get your pizza and other foods. They are a bit hidden if you don’t use your GPS (or haven’t been there before) but it’s worth it.
… moreChris Conley
It’s so odd. The pizza here seems to get better and better every time I order. FYI, if you moved here from NYC or LI, just order your pizza “well done”. I felt like I was eating dinner in Bensonhurst tonight. Outstanding!
… moreCindy for Joan Frick’s care
Have had their pizza and other things for many yrs. Ordered and it was delivered. Last night was the worse, think made ahead, heated over, burnt crust, hardly any sauce or cheese. I ate 1 piece and tossed the rest. I called and they weren’t interested in what I had to say or replacing it. Lost a customer forever.
… morePatrick Lewis (praxmoney7729)
I would like to call myself a pizza afficiando. I happened to stumble upon Carlo’s while on my lunch break. Although the decor isn’t updated, the slices are large, remniscent of a slice from the Jersey Boardwalk. Typically I’d accompany my review with a photo but my mind was somewhere else. Looking to fill up at a .ore than reasonable price, look no further and grab yourself a slice!
… moreJacob Hunter
This is some CRUST! Stop by and try the pie. This pizza will not disappoint!
… moreNorman Venezia (Stormin)
I was in a hurry but needed to get something to eat. I stopped and ordered a slice of Pizza at Carlos. It was one of the best thin crust pizza I ever had. Will definitely return.
… moreCharles Barba
I have been eating here for over 25 years and we love their pizza. They are always friendly and fast. They also have great appetizers and cheese stakes.
… moreMike Broughton
Food is great. I believe it was just two guys working and one of them also ran their deliveries, but they were putting work in, didn’t take long at all. Will definitely order from there again.
… more