Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family owned and operated since 1966, The Original Carlo’s Pizzeria and Restaurant of Middle Village, New York, provides generations of family Italian traditions. From our well-known pizza to pasta to a wide selection of home style cooking and catering, we take pride in providing the finest quality and service. People travel near and far to enjoy our homemade specialties all served by a warm and friendly staff in a casual dining establishment. Proudly calling Middle Village home for over 50 years, Carlo’s thanks the community and customers for our continuous success and the opportunity to prosper for many more family generations to come.
Long-standing pizza parlor providing classic pies, slices & Italian entrees in a no-frills interior.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379
Phone: (718) 894-7915
Website: https://www.carlospizzaofmv.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Original Carlo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant | View Menu & Order Online
Location 74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379. Find Us on: banner. About. The Original Carlo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant. Carlo. Welcome. Family owned …
Carlo’s Pizza – Middle Village, NY – 74-02 Metropolitan Ave – Hours …
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 1137974-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379 …
Carlo’s Pizzeria and Restaurant | Middle Village NY – Facebook
74-02 Metropolitan Avenue, Middle Village, NY (718) 894-7915 Want to purchase our sauce? Link in bio Takeout, delivery, and catering available
Last Updates
Reviews
Lupita Garcia
Carlo’s pizza never fails, always super delicious! I definitely recommend getting the penne ala vodka, with breaded chicken SUPER DELICIOUS, my partner regretted not getting it for himself. The bread was warm and crispy too ! AMAZING
… moreIrene M. Cruz
I eat here everytime we come into town to visit family and it is NY pizza to the max.
The guys behind the counter are friendly and cool to talk to. They have alot of options and everything including their garlic knots is really tasty.
You won’t be disappointed. I find it a bit pricey as 2 slices of pepperoni pizza is $10 but it seems inflation has affected everyone.
… moreThe guys behind the counter are friendly and cool to talk to. They have alot of options and everything including their garlic knots is really tasty.
You won’t be disappointed. I find it a bit pricey as 2 slices of pepperoni pizza is $10 but it seems inflation has affected everyone.
Daniel Pino
Carlo’s Pizza
Est. 1966
Layout/atmosphere
*Tables; two TVs
Food/drink
*Margherita slice – Good; liked the tomato/crust
… moreEst. 1966
Layout/atmosphere
*Tables; two TVs
Food/drink
*Margherita slice – Good; liked the tomato/crust
Andrew Park
I’ve lived in Middle Village for like 15 years and only recently had the pleasure of having a slice from Carlo’s. Pizza’s great. Probably the best slice in this neighborhood. They sell really good homemade dry pasta too- I used their tomato radiatori to make a pasta salad.
… moreDanielle Bourne
Great clean place with a friendly staff. This place has a great variety of Italian food that tastes amazing for a very good price. I would highly recommend anyone to come here if they love Italian food. (I also recommend they’re rigatoni with vodka sauce; it’s just perfect)
… moreMichael p
Just met Carlo’s grandson and picked up a jar of his grandfather’s sauce and pasta at a local fair on eastern long island. OMG! Paired that with a tomato and onion focaccia and had a fantastic meal! Can’t wait to visit!
… moreLee Stat
The bread that came out was warm and fresh and absolutely delicious. The steak salad was well cooked and tasty. The chicken parmesan was fresh and on the homemade bread. The service was excellent and very friendly. The place was very clean including the bathroom.
… moreDana Holmes
We order pizza from here almost every Friday and for our kids birthday parties. The pizza is great. Just don’t be surprised if they mix up how you want your toppings. If you want half one thing and half another, you may end up with both sides with everything, or one side missing a topping. We accept this as a quirk of this excellent spot and never complain about it. It tastes good no matter what. The zucchini sticks are an awesome alternative to mozzarella sticks that kids love. The staff is very friendly and efficient and prices are fair. It’s definitely worth a visit or order!
… moreRobert Intelisano
Carlo’s pizza is a must try when in Middle Village! Excellent regular slice, pepperoni bites and very good value for the price. I suggest leaving with a jar of their special homemade sauce, since 1966!
… moreABOMB-JR11
I don’t get the pizza, but their food is really good. Mozz sticks and penne vodka are all I need for a meal. Atmosphere is nice and the best service and delicious food. Will go again!
… more