Sita Goss
I ordered a calzone and asked for it to be freshly made, not taken from the display and reheated. I was given a calzone that was cut open on the bottom to add my requested filling and then reheated. The filling leaked out the bottom cut, all over the bag. In addition, it was not freshly made as promised and was burnt and dried out. Very disappointed.
… moreMIKEY LAP
Carlo’s signature panini was enjoyable! I would definitely order it again & the pizza had a good crisp!!
… moreJack Sparrow
Wow absolutely delicious pizzeria! They just opened up last week and they completely renovated the entire restaurant with new dining tables and kitchen equipment. I was surprised the restaurant is based out of NY and glad they decided to do business here in NJ. I decided to order 2 plain slices and a Jamaican Patty. Which was something that caught my eye and eat all the time. The slices were delicious, including the Jamaican Patty. They were rich in flavor and the slices were extremely cheesy! Would definitely come back here and give it another go with the rest of their menu items. Awesome service guys!
… moreItzM1sty
Had an incredible experience here! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented you can tell a lot of care goes into every dish. The staff were friendly, attentive, and made us feel really welcome. The atmosphere was cozy but still felt special, perfect for a night out. Everything from start to finish was spot on can’t wait to come back!
… moreRosa Maria Constante
We love the fact that it’s a family based restaurant with kids running around. Customer service great. The pizza, another story – needed seasoning, plus it fell apart as we tried raising it towards our mouths, to the extent of needing fork and knife to manage eating it. One of the toppings was mushroom and fried onions, but the onions were barely sauteed – far from being fried.
… moreChris Cooke
First time stopping in since changing to “Carlo’s Cucuna”. Hoping to meet Carlo but he was not in, don’t worry Carlo, your staff was great! Ordered a pizza “to go” and it was great! Lot’s of mushrooms and pepperoni topping a nice soft crust. Newly renovated interior looks very nice. Will be back for a sit-down dinner next time.
… moreMr Unknown
Absolutely loved this place the food was delicious fresh ingredients, great portions, and full of flavor. The staff were friendly and attentive without being overbearing, and everything came out quickly the restaurant has such a nice atmosphere clean, comfortable, and welcoming you can tell they really care about their customers and the quality of what they serve I’ll definitely be coming back soon!
… moreEd B
Ordered food for delivery and had to wait over 1hr for delivery. I could of went to dinner (without drinks) and spent the same amount and waited less. This is he 2nd time we ordered due to convince. I could be starving and will not order from here again. Food was cold, fries were soggy had to be one of the worse dinners I ever had. Definitely NOT a place to go!!
… moreshickey718
Honestly my favorite pizza in the region. The crust is crunchy the cheese is melty the sauce is so good. The staff is also wonderfully helpful and cheerful and the environment is cozy and clean
… moreChuck Mound
Very Big Pizzeria with a lot of seating. I am sure they have a goid business in Stanhope with the catering..The Pizza.. A good slice for a local pizzeria that seemed to be your standard strip mall slice. Did not taste much sauce, the cheese was plentiful and took over the slice. The crust was ok. Looked like they offered a variety of different slices and the people were very nice. Compared to the rest of NJ at this point, the pizza is middle of the road. We will see where they end up on the Pizza Hunters App Ratings.
… more