Matt Hagens
The paella tasted like low tide and cost $80 with seafood that warrants at best $30. The staff were great and very attentive. I let the manager know and she told me she wished I had told her earlier. That response left me a bit confused, so I’m sharing it here instead.
I would avoid the paella and bring your wallet 10 out of 10 cost on 5 out of 10 quality.
… moreRob
Kat made our dinner at Caribbean Fish Market unforgettable. From the moment we sat down, her bubbly, welcoming personality lit up the table and turned a great meal into an amazing experience. We even watched the table next to us come back and request her because they had such a good time. If you’re making a reservation, put in the notes that you want Kat. She truly makes the night special.
… moreVanessa – Travel Agent
Very nice quiet restaurant on the water. All the food was amazing & the service was great! The shrimp tacos were delicious. I’d definitely go back.
… moreMirkelys
We visited Caribbean Fish Market in St. Thomas and had a really nice experience. The staff was friendly and attentive, making us feel welcome the entire time. You can sit outside facing the sea and relax while enjoying the sound of the waves. They also have a nice selection of wines. If you’re in St. Thomas, this is a great spot to stop by! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreGabriel Pires
Seafood was amazing. For appetizers we had pawns grilled and for dinner I had the 2lb lobster and stuffed shrimp. Great view of the beach and employees were friendly and funny
… moreAtlanta Katt
Very beautiful location. Great service and Extra friendly staff. Loved the lollipop lamb chops, the tomahawk was very tender and flavorable, the shrimp salad was pretty good, loved the seasoned shrimp with bacon. The citrus vinegarette dressing was the best to me. The alcohol drinks were also refreshing. Our meal total around $300. We will definitely return next year.
… moreNot Available
Great experience. The food is listed and commented on being a higher class meal. Multiple options are available outside of seafood. Not somewhere I would suggest. Waiter was a very cool gentleman and personable really made it a good experience. Overpriced for what you’re getting. Ordered dine in Apple Bacon Stuffed Lamb Chop, Lemon Half chicken, and coconut rum punch cough cough without the punch just saying
… moreAlexandra Shuy
All the Yuma and all the vibes are here. The food was absolutely spectacular and our waiter was a very charismatic guy that we really enjoyed! The wahoo was so good. I would eat that again. Honestly all the food we had was really good. Don’t miss out on the rum cake for dessert. It was delicious.
… moreBerenice M
My husband & I stayed at Elysian and we were hesitant to try Caribbean Fish Market after reading the mixed reviews but I am happy we decided to try it because we had a great experience. Both our meals were great & service was quick and super attentive. My husband had the stuffed lobster & I had the Seafood Hot Pot. The Calamari was also delicious. I was pleasantly surprised with our experience. We also hung out at the bar a couple nights since we stayed at Elysian. Nice clean bar and good company.
… moreTim Wenzel
Great food, I mean delicious!! Service was good but not great. We had reservations and were ten minutes early and they told us to go to the bar and they would come get us. 5 min after our reservation I went looking for them because they forgot. Waiter was awesome! We got spicy Brussel sprouts which were delicious. Then I got lobster and the wife got wahoo. Small portions but good food and good display. Took about 1:45 hrs for the both of us. Price was about 150 dollars for us both. 4 stars because the price and service. I expect a little better service and a little more food if I’m spending that much money. 3 asparagus with my lobster and mashed potatoes isn’t much.
… more