Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Caraglio’s Pizza is a locally owned pizzeria serving up classic, crowd-pleasing favorites made with quality ingredients and a whole lot of care. From our hand-tossed pizzas and signature wing flavors to hearty subs, salads, and family-friendly meals, we’ve got something for everyone and every occasion. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family, or ordering for game day, Caraglio’s is your go-to spot for great food, friendly service, and consistent quality.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7 Main St, Hilton, NY 14468
Phone: (585) 392-9000
Website: https://www.caragliospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza and Wings in Rochester | Best Local Pizzeria
We’ve got the best pizza and wings in Rochester! Visit Caraglio’s Pizza for fresh, flavorful meals and unbeatable deals!
Caraglio’s Pizza | Hilton NY – Facebook
Caraglio’s Pizza, Hilton. 6765 likes · 96 talking about this · 162 were here. Pizza, Wings, Subs, Calzones, Plates, Appetizers, Desserts, Salads,…
Caraglio’s Pizza, 7 Main St, Hilton, NY 14468, US – MapQuest
They offer an extensive menu featuring pizza, wings, subs, salads, and more, catering to special dietary needs including gluten-free options. With multiple …
Last Updates
Reviews
Matthew Loftus
Love seeing bad reviews and then going into the public profile to see what miserable humans they are and only leave 5 stars to places who give special treatment. Yeah frank im talking about you… anyways. 5 stars for the Hilton location. I ordered for superbowl Sunday on the website and there was either a glitch with my bank or glitch with the system. It wouldn’t accept my order but put a hold for the charge. I called, spoke with Jessica and she made sure one way or another I was getting my order when I wanted it regardless of the money situation. About an hour later, the hold was released and I called back to pay for my order. My wife and I use to run a very busy pizza shop and know what it takes to do this job. Can’t please EVERYONE, yes Frank, about you again. I am very pleased with the customer service. I’ve had your food before and its a great pie. Thank you for all that you do in the community and for serving us great service and great pizza and a bonus for dealing with jack wagons like frank here. Thanks Guys!!!
… moreJimmy Hossen
Was so upset when I got home. Should have opened the box before I left. Never seen a cheese pizza so burnt in my life. 7-11 has better. Sry
… moreClaire Freeling
We ordered from the Webster location. The cheese pizza was burnt, crust was thin and very dry. Absolutely disgusting!
… moreJonathan Wood
Best one in the chain is this location. They make great pizzas, simple and elaborate. Out of the dozen places to order pizza within 5 miles. You’ll never find a better locally made pizza done right!
… moreMike Ozug
Really good pizza, probably the best dough around. Constantly cooked perfectly. Great amount of toppings. They consistently make the pizzas smaller than advertised, and that isn’t just this location. The one pictured is a large, which is supposed to be 16 inches, but closer to 15 1/4. I know that sounds picky, but that adds up to be a large area, especially when it happens every time. I’ll still be back, but know what you’re getting. The size discrepancy is worse on sheets.
… moreTerrance Ray Trybus
Great pizza, really good service and conveniently located at a place near you. Many local locations.
… moreGeorge Lama
Great pizza and wings. They get extremely busy so don’t be surprised if it takes your order one hour to be ready for pickup. Frankly, their pizza and wings are worth waiting for, just call well ahead just in case, particularly during big football events.
… moreEvan Brundage
Order a pizza and wings and was told 30 minutes. Arrived 30 minutes later and they had forgotten to start it. We waited 20+ minutes for our order, and during that time my girlfriend had I overheard the workers taking rudely about us numerous times- as if their mistake was on us. The pizza was subpar compared to even a gas station, but edible. The wings were the driest I’ve ever had. It was over a 60 dollar order for the worst service I’ve ever had, and mediocre food. First and last time trying this place.
… moreMichael Brown
I ordered for pick up Sun Eve 3/30/ 25 and my wife had garlic parm extra crispy wings and I had supreme calzone, we both agree it was the best we’ve ordered from here, my compliments to the crew!
Well sadly I have to say I went there tonight 6/17/ 25 and I got this IKEA calzone, I had to pick up the pieces and try and put them back together and there was no cheese and the dough was full of holes thin as paper, I couldn’t believe it was the same place, very disappointed
… moreWell sadly I have to say I went there tonight 6/17/ 25 and I got this IKEA calzone, I had to pick up the pieces and try and put them back together and there was no cheese and the dough was full of holes thin as paper, I couldn’t believe it was the same place, very disappointed
Scott
Originally I like the food so I came here often. but I noticed This place likes to scam their customers. I’ve ordered food prepaid for the food online. Only to see they charged my bank account a different amount than I was originally charged. Spoke to management looks like they employ incompetent teenagers who have no clue how to get the money refunded they stole. Will not be returning.
… more