Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 50 Strongs Ave, Rutland, VT 05701
Phone: (802) 747-9001
Website: https://www.caramiaspizza.com/menu/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza, Pasta, Subs | Takeout & Delivery | Cara Mia’s Pizza | Rutland …
Everything is homemade and weuse the best produts including Stanislaus tomato products, Grande cheeses ( the finest Italian cheeses), Genoa salami and …
Pizza, Subs, Salads Menu | Cara Mia’s Pizza | Rutland, VT
ALL. Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Meatballs, Sausage, Pepperoni ; Cara Mia. Red Pesto, Broccoli, Grilled Chicken, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Mozzarella & Asiago ; Veggie.
Cara Mia’s Pizzeria | Rutland (city) VT – Facebook
Cara Mia’s Pizzeria, Rutland (city). 1374 likes · 2 talking about this · 77 were here. Cara Mia’s opened Halloween 1997. Serving tasty pizza, calzones,…
Reviews
Amanda Vassallo
Cara Mia’s is quickly becoming our favorite pizza spot in Rutland. Pizza and salads are consistently great and tastes just like my hometown pizza shop in NY (in the best way). Staff are always super friendly and professional, whether it’s ordering over the phone, picking up take out and getting delivery. Highly recommend!
… moreM Dappollone
Incredible sticker shock. Two large pizzas and a large mozzarella sticks, $77. The food here is fine, not life changing. For this much money the pizzas should also do my taxes.
… moreMatthew DeNicola
Absolutely vile pizza, insane this place is open with the quality of food we got. The toppings are low quality, the baking is completely off, they manage to make cheese unappetizing. $70 for a salad, regular cheese pizza, and small Bianca. Please, do yourself a favor and go ANYWHERE else.
… moreEric Erwin
Cara Mia’s has changed up their game. The pepperoni pizza is completely different from just a year ago. I really enjoyed it, but too much pepperoni (which some were soggy from being buried in cheese). Now it’s the right amount, crispy cup pepperoni, and such an amazing pizza! Sure, it’s more expensive than others in town, but for now, I am definitely good with it. You pay for what you get. Thanks for improving the pizzas cara Mia!
… morePauline Morris
I have always enjoyed Cara Mia’s and still do . I order the chef salad almost every time we get pizza . I was disappointed with it the last couple of times I ordered as it was mostly lettuce . I thought maybe prepared by someone new. Tonight I get another salad (sadly my last )and it looked amazing at first . Sprinkled with bits of scraps for the meats 2 tomatoes. I get food costs are up but does that mean skimmping on ingredients ? Too much money for lettuce
… moreKrissee Arnold
I Ordered a chicken Parm sandwich..I ate half of it cause I was starving. Then I realized I’m tasting just cheese and bread.. open up my other half and have one small piece of barely breaded chicken and cheese just randomly all over the place.
Honestly I’m not surprised. The last time I ordered a chicken, broccoli and cheese calzone, had to send it back cause it was basically just bread.. was told I could not get a refund. But instead a new calzone or sandwich. When the time came to get this, they couldn’t ” find me” in the system.
I’ve ordered a few sandwiches since this time, and nothing stands out. Very bland and just nothing to them. No more chances.
Not to mention, the lady who works during the day is almost always rude on the phone. Or in person as well!
Will not be calling and complaining cause it’s just a waste of time and money at this point.
… moreHonestly I’m not surprised. The last time I ordered a chicken, broccoli and cheese calzone, had to send it back cause it was basically just bread.. was told I could not get a refund. But instead a new calzone or sandwich. When the time came to get this, they couldn’t ” find me” in the system.
I’ve ordered a few sandwiches since this time, and nothing stands out. Very bland and just nothing to them. No more chances.
Not to mention, the lady who works during the day is almost always rude on the phone. Or in person as well!
Will not be calling and complaining cause it’s just a waste of time and money at this point.
Annalea Thompson
this is the best pizza in Rutland and anybody that tells you otherwise is a hater or hasn’t tried it. Yes, the delivery times can take a while, yes, the pizza is pricey, but great work takes time and You get what you pay for. It’s worth it. This pizza is phenomenal!!!
… moreAlicia Wil
My friend and I ordered a meatball and a chx parm sub. They took an hour to deliver. When we finally did get them the subs were so soggy. The subs looked like they were thrown together with no heart in them at all. Olympic Pizza is the way to go. Cara mias just isn’t for me. The subs showing up like that was a real disappointment and won’t order there subs again if anything on the menu.
… moreDale Chappell
Delivery is spotty. Call ahead to verify delivery will be available. Couldn’t get a delivery on a Friday For a planned event. Great pizza otherwise. My favorite. But it’s Vermont and things can be unpredictable.
… moreChristian Carman
Their sub advertised as 12” on menu tasted decent but fell well short of the 12” promised.. kinda skimpy on the meatballs too.
… more