Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Laid-back venue on the 2nd floor for Italian pies & salads, plus beer, wine & ample take-out fare.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11513 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva, FL 33924
Phone: (239) 395-0823
Website: http://www.captivaislandpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Captiva Island Pizza
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Copyright © 2026 Captiva Island Pizza …
Captiva Crust: Home
Just steps from ‘Tween Waters Inn & Marina, Captiva Crust serves up handcrafted personal pizzas with fresh high-quality ingredients made just the way you …
Captiva Island Pizza – Facebook
Captiva Island Pizza, Captiva. 1191 likes · 3 talking about this · 67 were here. Pizza place.
Reviews
jeff kovatch
Very good NY style pizza. Get with extra cheese. Owner very nice guy. How anyone can give this place less than five stars doesn’t know anything about pizza. This is the very best pizza you’ll get in FL. Trust me.
… moreKristina L.
Delicious NY style pizza, flavorful, crisp botton but soft and chewy inside. We loved our pepperoni pizza.
… moreAlexandra Farmer
This shop absolutely delivers. The classic pepperoni is exactly what you want—perfectly crisp edges, great flavor, and super satisfying. They also have a delicious specialty pizza that’s perfect for adults looking for something a little different. The service was quick, friendly, and felt really personal. Highly recommend stopping by!
… moreNeil Thornbury
Really great pizza — bold, flavorful, and made with genuinely fresh ingredients. You can taste the quality in every bite. Fun, laid-back atmosphere too, making it a cool spot to grab a slice while on the island. Definitely worth stopping in if you are on Captiva.
… moreYPC.Koelewijn
I’m from Europe and didn’t really like the pizza’s here in the US. But these are amazing
Also a very nice and friendly guy
I will definitely go back here.
… moreAlso a very nice and friendly guy
I will definitely go back here.
Lori Devine
The website says delivery 5-9 pm Fridays and Saturdays – guy on the phone said, “We don’t deliver”. Toppings offered inaccurate…. but when you’re on an island? You suck it up and try it!
My 4 toppings were scarce, and basically all in the middle. Photos attached.
So….Digiornos or this…. one you bring with, one you have to go pick up… so take your pick! They both put a lump in your gut and you’re not hungry anymore!
… moreMy 4 toppings were scarce, and basically all in the middle. Photos attached.
So….Digiornos or this…. one you bring with, one you have to go pick up… so take your pick! They both put a lump in your gut and you’re not hungry anymore!
Jack Burdette
Pizza is AMAZING you gotta be understanding and patient if you come here while there busy it’s a small mom and pop pizza shop and it’s worth it this shop uses real cheese and it has the perfect crust with every bite best pizza spot in SWFL
… moreBethany Calo
We went to order in person late in the evening this week and they were out of dough, so we made sure to order earlier the next day and it was definitely worth the wait! We loved it! Don’t let any negative reviews steer you away, because you’ll be missing out on amazing pizza made from scratch! And the cheese bread, YUM!
… moreChristian Barnes
Best pizza on the island, no contest. I’m a chef from Chicago. Have friends in pizza business island pizza is as good or better. Very nice people as well. Thank you guys!!
… moreScott Moreland
Ordered pizza with multiple ingredients. Many pieces had no or only one of an ingredient type.
Thin soft crust pizza. Flavor not bad, and pizza was not expensive
… moreThin soft crust pizza. Flavor not bad, and pizza was not expensive