Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Enduring spot serving fish sandwiches & other coastal eats in casual digs with ocean-themed decor.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 90154 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier, FL 33070
Phone: (305) 852-9424
Website: http://captcraigs.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Captain Craig’s in Islamorada, Florida Keys
Craig’s Restaurant in Islamorada, Florida Keys offers fresh seafood and more, and is known for its world famous Fish Sandwich.
Captain’s Craig’s Restaurant
Florida Keys, Islamorada restaurant offering fresh seafood and more. View our menu for our specialties.
Captain Craig’s Restaurant | Islamorada FL – Facebook
Cook for busy Tavernier restaurant. Full time, fun, busy atmosphere. Inquire within or send us a message.
Reviews
Shaun R S
The Fish Sandwich came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. The catch of the day was the grouped, very fresh and well prepared.
We felt the seafood pasta was the best some of us thought.
Nice ambiance!
… moreWe felt the seafood pasta was the best some of us thought.
Nice ambiance!
Cheryl Marshburn
I have the jalapeno encrusted mahi-mahi it was fantastic. With the entree I got a side of mashed potatoes even those were delicious. Everybody at the table really loved everything they got including the side of green beans that were blistered and yummy.
… moreEvan Sidman
Best fish tacos. Very clean restaurant. Easy parking. Stopped for early lunch and everything was fresh. Alvaro is a good server, too.
… moreGeorge B KLA
Was visiting family in The Keys
Brother in law caught a sword fish and had captain Craig’s prepare the fish !
FANTASTIC, delicious!
Service was great!
… moreBrother in law caught a sword fish and had captain Craig’s prepare the fish !
FANTASTIC, delicious!
Service was great!
Kathi Belviso
This place is amazing! A must stop when you are in Key Largo. If you like a whole fried fish definitely order it.
… morePam Weinert
we absolutely loved captain Craig’s. It’s got a great local vibe and the seafood is fresh as can be. We had the seafood grill and we shared it and had plenty of food we had it served over rice. It was excellent had scallops, grouper, shrimp and squid so so good
we also had conch fritters to start. I had some kind of a basil martini that was just delicious. Not too sweet beautifully prepared. We definitely will return.
… morewe also had conch fritters to start. I had some kind of a basil martini that was just delicious. Not too sweet beautifully prepared. We definitely will return.
Melody Smith
Good was really good. Service was excellent! Friendliness and excitement about the menu items was top notch. Tables and bar/counter seating available. We had Stone Crab Chowder, jalapeño encrusted Hogfish, filet with house-made peppercorn sauce and rice. Delicious unsweet tea (important to tea drinkers!), house-made key lime pie with meringue also made in house. Great experience. Found by searching for local places with the highest reviews. Glad we came here! Thank you Nataly & Blanca for a wonderful experience!
… moreLucas Yamada
If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience, Captain Craig’s is a hidden gem that truly exceeded all expectations. From the moment we stepped inside, we were transported to a nautical paradise—themed like the interior of a ship, complete with charming details that made it feel as though we were dining on the open sea.
The food was nothing short of spectacular. Every dish was expertly prepared, bursting with flavor, and among the best meals I’ve ever had. Whether you’re a seafood lover or prefer other options, you’re in for a treat. Each bite was a testament to the chef’s skill and attention to detail.
The service elevated the experience even further. Our waitress was an absolute delight—kind, attentive, and genuinely invested in ensuring we had an amazing time. She went above and beyond to make our visit special, adding a personal touch that’s hard to find elsewhere.
Captain Craig’s isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a unique place to dine, this spot will leave a lasting impression. Highly recommended!
… moreThe food was nothing short of spectacular. Every dish was expertly prepared, bursting with flavor, and among the best meals I’ve ever had. Whether you’re a seafood lover or prefer other options, you’re in for a treat. Each bite was a testament to the chef’s skill and attention to detail.
The service elevated the experience even further. Our waitress was an absolute delight—kind, attentive, and genuinely invested in ensuring we had an amazing time. She went above and beyond to make our visit special, adding a personal touch that’s hard to find elsewhere.
Captain Craig’s isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a unique place to dine, this spot will leave a lasting impression. Highly recommended!
N T
I do not know what happened this time. I have not been here in a while. They have remodeled since the last time I was here. I walked in and was greeted right away. That’s pretty much the most positive thing I can say. I loved this place. I bragged about how good the fish sandwich is here. Sadly, I was highly disappointed. Not only did it take approximately 40 minutes to get my food, but when it came out, it was not made with any love”. No seasoning on the fish or breading. The French fries had no salt on them. The bread for the sandwich was tough. Barely any tartar sauce. Just a real let down. I also had a featured rum punch that tasted like sugar. I wonder if there are new owners? I’d try again, but not anytime soon.
… morePaul Medeiros
We are from New England we live on the largest fishing harbor on the east coast.
We know fresh food, and We are blown away with every dish that hit our table. My wife had the shrimp scampi, and I had tge grouper captains style. Its pan seared parmesean crusted. It was seriously the best fish dish i ever had. Our waitress Natilie was extremely friendly, and on point with everything. We have 2 days left in our vacation, staying an hour away from here. Yet we are coming back tomorrow 100%.
… moreWe know fresh food, and We are blown away with every dish that hit our table. My wife had the shrimp scampi, and I had tge grouper captains style. Its pan seared parmesean crusted. It was seriously the best fish dish i ever had. Our waitress Natilie was extremely friendly, and on point with everything. We have 2 days left in our vacation, staying an hour away from here. Yet we are coming back tomorrow 100%.